6 ms·
No, I don't think that captures the ideas in Richard Gabriel's essays. Simple vs. The Right Thing are the two sides, where the right thing is a complete and pol
by epistasis 15y ago
No, I don't think that captures the ideas in Richard Gabriel's essays. Simple vs. The Right Thing are the two sides, where the right thing is a complete and polished piece of software full of features, what a typical young engineer would create if given lots of time and resources to do things "the right way".
I think he calls it "worse" as a way of emphasizing that e better course of action may not feel fully responsible, as in the PC-losering example.
- derleth 15y ago> PC-losering Has any OS other than ITS ever fully addressed this?
- vilhelm_s 15y agoIt's mentioned in the paper "EROS: a fast capability system" (http://www.eros-os.org/papers/sosp99-eros-preprint.ps http://www.eros-os.org/papers/sosp99-eros-preprint.ps): they write "This design is similar to that adopted in Fluke and MIT’s ITS system" and cite the ITS reference manual for the latter. (I remembered reading that paragraph since before that I had only ever seen the technique mentioned in Gabriel's essay :) ).
- derleth 15y agoWell, my point is this: If only three or four OSes have ever implemented it, none of which have been very successful, how important could it possibly be? Do other OSes have ways of making the problem irrelevant without actually fixing it like ITS, Fluke, and EROS did?