3 ms·
> On two occasions I have been asked,—“Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?” In one case a member of t
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> On two occasions I have been asked,—“Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?” In one case a member of the Upper, and in the other a member of the Lower, House put this question. I am not able rightly to apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question.
It's nice to know, as someone that works with computers, that this layman attitude is eternal and not something unique to our current times.
- ajb 5y agoAlthough, I always wondered if that was a snide way of asking if the machine was a fake, that Babbage didn't pick up on.
- buu700 5y agoI was going to say that Poe's law existed even back then, but apparently it was coined by a different Poe in 2005.
- vvguifyjf 5y agoMachinery tends to be used to "refine" raw materials. Rough timber is transformed into precisely dimensioned planks, for example. So it's not unreasonable to ask whether a machine for producing numerical data can operate with crude and inaccurate raw materials (inputs). Consider: The "regula falsi" approach to solving equations in one unknown actually involves a guessed, "false" input. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regula_falsi#The_regula_falsi_(false_position)_method https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regula_falsi#The_regula_fals... Robert Recorde wrote: Gesse at this woorke as happe doth leade. By chaunce to truthe you may procede. And firste woorke by the question, Although no truthe therein be don. Suche falsehode is so good a grounde, That truth by it will soone be founde. From many bate to many mo, From to fewe take to fewe also. With to much ioyne to fewe againe, To to fewe adde to manye plaine. In crossewaies multiplye contrary kinde, All truthe by falsehode for to fynde. Now, somebody on HN ("wzdd") has previously tried to defend Babbage, on more than one occasion (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29605135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29605135), saying that he wasn't mystified by the misunderstanding, but instead was making some kind of joke at his own expense (not a snide comment at the expense of the questioner.) I'm far from convinced. It seems to me that we shouldn't be celebrating this mean-spirited passage from Babbage's writing.
- guessbest 5y agoI always assumed we are only hearing Babbage's side without the context of the question. Was this part of a series of questions presented to Babbage trying to help him along in almost a Socratic method to understand the Parliament's hesitation? Knowing that most politicians of that era discussed 'to whose benefit' and 'for what purpose' when most of the upper class were landed gentry, it would be most likely affecting a whole new sector of the economy they didn't understand. How would this machine be used for Law? Could it help the homeless? War widows? Managing pensions? I presume the question could also be directed at whether the machine would require a specially trained operator and thus more funding or whether anyone skilled in the Arts and the Trades could work the machine efficiently without oversight or much necessary direction. Given the machine was a whole new step and direction of the economy, I can understand their hesitation. A computer without a program, while brilliant, is useless.