2 ms·
US gov't systems have already been pushing out the little bespoke apps for a while now anyways. They're a security nightmare with or without a VPN. Plus, the ma
by Jtsummers 5y ago
US gov't systems have already been pushing out the little bespoke apps for a while now anyways. They're a security nightmare with or without a VPN. Plus, the majority of them seem to cover three things:
1. Task management (JIRA clones, but worse) and coordination, possibly with external user (contractor) access which opens up a hole in the system anyways.
2. Custom workflows (BPMN-ish, but not disciplined and not, easily, connectable to each other), again with external user (contractor, citizen, applicants, whatever) access.
3. Document sharing (SharePoint, but more like a skin over a network share), again with external user access.
All of those can be covered by other systems, sometimes simpler ones than presently used (3 is the core of what HTTP was meant to serve, they "just" need access control on top of a basic HTTP server which is a solved problem these days).
A bigger problem with the bespoke apps is that they often have their own access control mechanisms, which don't always play well with the larger organization access control systems. They have their own user names and passwords, they may or may not connect to a CAC-authenticated backend. Or they do stupid things (had to fix one of these once) like not authenticating the CAC but using trust-on-first-use, and then the user's access had to be reset when they got a new CAC. Brilliant. These aren't good systems, they are serviceable systems.
There are other rapid application development tools (see Appian and others) that can cover (1) and (2) but provide a unified backend (which means the workflows can now be composed, too). SharePoint and other document management systems can cover (3). SharePoint can also cover (1) and (2) (though I've barely tolerated it for either use, it is at least better than dropping $1 million+ a year on hardware and software licenses for a one-off product supporting a half dozen users that doesn't integrate into the rest of the system).