4 ms·
"I dont magic myself a raise because income tax goes up. It works the same for landlords. If supply and demand remains unchanged, prices remain unchanged." Wha
by giantg2 5y ago
"I dont magic myself a raise because income tax goes up. It works the same for landlords. If supply and demand remains unchanged, prices remain unchanged."
What you're missing is that the market floor get universally pushed up. There's no competition from cheaper places because they all increased their rent to cover the new coat so they can still make their same margin. The demand is still there because people still need a place to live.
"The only change I could forsee to affect either is previously empty properties being put up for rent"
Any numbers on that, or are you just going to keep claiming it's a big enough vacant supply to significantly affect prices?
"They'd really love for that to be how it works and sometimes they pretend it is."
This is still tied to the previous comment. If the number of vacancies are not sufficient, then supply is adequately constrained to just increase the prices to cover costs. Because, again, this increase moves the market floor.
- lurgburg 5y ago> they all increased their rent Why would they not have done this before, if they could? Landlords aren't trying to maintain some fixed margin, they want as much as possible, always.
- giantg2 5y agoBecause of competition. They can't all conspire together to price fix (or if they do they could be arrested).
- lurgburg 5y agoWriting in context of preceding comment, which seemed to be predicated on them having a special capacity to raise prices in response to land taxes. I did wonder briefly if a land tax might decrease competition => higher prices, but then I recalled that the supply of land is fixed.
- giantg2 5y agoIf it's s limited resource which people require (shelters), the price (rent) will be quite elastic. There will still be competition if the taxes go up. Competition is what prevents the price from rising unnecessary. The floor for all the competitors went up because taxes went up and they all want to stay profitable. They aren't going to take loss, so they raise rent to cover it. Buying won't look very attractive either because the tax increase raises those costs, and if it's as significant as they other poster wanted (to affect rich people) then it will likely exceed the $10k SALT deduction limit. This SALT deduction is part of how they penalize landlords already, which is just passed on in the rent payments. This is part of the reason renting is more expensive than buying (comparing just monthly payments), in addition to management fees, profit, and repair/renovation reserves.
- majormajor 5y agoThe last few cities I've lived in have seen 10+ straight years of rent increases (with a brief drop then rapid spike again from COVID) so... they do already do this?
- lurgburg 5y agoWriting in the context of preceding comment. Landlords increase prices as much as they're able, they don't decline to increase when they could to maintain some fixed margin. I'm not saying they're generally unable to rise prices in general, but that they have no special additional capacity to raise prices in response to land taxes.
- giantg2 5y ago"but that they have no special additional capacity to raise prices in response to land taxes." How so? If all landlords now have a significant new cost, why would they not raise rent to cover it? This seems to say they cover 80-90% of tax increases through rent increases. And commercial properties should be more competitive. https://mitcre.mit.edu/news/blog/can-landlords-really-pass-higher-property-taxes-tenants https://mitcre.mit.edu/news/blog/can-landlords-really-pass-h...
- pydry 5y ago>What you're missing is that the market floor get universally pushed up. There's no competition from cheaper places because they all increased their rent to cover the new coat so they can still make their same margin. You're saying that it doesnt matter if supply and demand remains unchanged, rent goes up coz every landlord independently decided that it does?
- giantg2 5y agoNot that they decided it does, but generally that they all had to in order to stay profitable. Part of this is due to the othwr commenter's suggested goal that the rise in rates be significant enough to demotivate rich people. Here is some research on commercial properties, which would in theory be more competitive than residential. It shows that 80-90% of any tax increase is covered by an increase in rent. https://mitcre.mit.edu/news/blog/can-landlords-really-pass-higher-property-taxes-tenants https://mitcre.mit.edu/news/blog/can-landlords-really-pass-h... And of course many landlord resources say to just build it in. "The best way to protect yourself from taking a hit is to plan ahead. Plan for a tax increase every single year and adjust your rents accordingly. Build the tax increase into your rent and allow for future rent increases. A planned annual rent increase will allow you to stay ahead of tax increases instead of being caught off guard and behind." https://commonsenselandlording.com/property-taxes-rental-property/ https://commonsenselandlording.com/property-taxes-rental-pro...