4 ms·
I was including that under "or simply buying because they can afford it now". "Of the two, B is a more prudent way of making property prices sane again." Mayb
by giantg2 5y ago
I was including that under "or simply buying because they can afford it now".
"Of the two, B is a more prudent way of making property prices sane again."
Maybe if you taxed unused land. Otherwise that tax will end up increasing a resident's rent/mortgage substantially (as it's a perpetual annual expense). So really, you'd have to tax way above what a normal person can afford (average US household about $75k, so $7500 is 10% gross), and that still wouldn't be much of a disincentive to the wealthy (ignoring the fact the the market would collapse because normal people can't afford to buy it from them nor pay the rent).
Now if we did tax unused land, then we are reducing conservation and incentivize development. This is a major concern for some areas, especially around loss of agriculture land, riparian buffers for water quality, etc.
If we had work that was more distributed, like remote is for IT, then it's possible the effects of all the capital flooding a handful of markets would be diluted by spreading it across numerous others. A generation or two ago we had many small cities with industrial or manufacturing jobs. Now it seems many of those cities have shrunk while the national population has grown, mostly concentrating in specific metro areas.
- ehnto 5y ago> ignoring the fact the the market would collapse I think that is the point. The market doesn't make sense already for people who actually use the homes because of the investors. If there were property policies that targeted investors and forced their money elsewhere, prices would drop dramatically, making housing affordable again.
- giantg2 5y ago"The market doesn't make sense already for people who actually use the homes because of the investors." I think that depends on the area. A true crash, if it were to happen, would affect all though. You'd have people underwater on their mortgages, unable to move by selling or renting out the home and instead being foreclosed. People in some sectors my lose their job because people have less discretionary money (if they'd be smart and save more for retirement to offset the loss on their property). If anything, I would think more people would be looking for cheaper apartments to rent because they were foreclosed, leading them to rent from the rich who have a large share of that type of housing.
- majormajor 5y agoIf it was just investors why would rent be as close to mortgage payment amounts as it is? The vacancy rate is low. Demand is high. Demand is high even among people with more money than me so there are a lot of places that both sell for more than I can afford, and rent for more than I can afford. People are competing for the more desirable neighborhoods, whether renting from an investor or buying outright, that's what makes it an attractive investment in the first place. They'd still be competing, so the prices would still go up until an equilibrium was reached. Maybe just slower?
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"If it was just investors why would rent be as close to mortgage payment amounts as it is?" I am not clear how this is meant to prove anything, an influx of investors increases prices and rent, both. perhaps it's better to call them speculators, because they don't invest in the economy to create new properties, just inflate prices on existing ones.
- pydry 5y ago>Otherwise that tax will end up increasing a resident's rent/mortgage It would do nothing to rents or mortgages intrinsically but it would cause property prices to fall and it could add to the tax burden of regular property owners depending on how it were implemented (i.e. if the tax free threshold were set too low). >that still wouldn't be much of a disincentive to the wealthy It would be a massive disincentive to the wealthy, since they own the most property and are used to it being an asset not a liability. They would dispose of properties that were nonperforming because taxes > capital appreciation + rent and this would spiral as falling prices leads to more hoarded properties being given up. They would also scramble to rent out previously unrented properties where capital appreciation wasnt covering taxes. More rentals on the market means even lower rents which makes their properties worth even less to them.
- giantg2 5y ago"It would do nothing to rents or mortgages intrinsically" Most people have their property taxes escrowed with their mortgage payments. Taxes can easily account for 25% of one's monthly payments. As for rent, the property owners just pass the cost on to the tenants by increasing rent. So property taxes are related to rent and mortgage payments. Even if not included directly in the mortgage payment, it affects how much of a mortgage one can afford. "It would be a massive disincentive to the wealthy, since they own the most property and are used to it being an asset not a liability." I'm not sure about this. Just because they own more property doesn't mean they would be the most affected. The tax would likely be a larger percentage of a "normal" person's income for their own home and thus more impactful to them. Plus, if the wealthy are renting out the majority of the properties, then they can make up for tax increases by raising rents (because property tax increase priced more people out of homes (because the price drop was a drop in demand), increasing demand for rentals). I do agree that it should incentivize full utilization of rental properties. But I don't think there are enough vacant rentals to affect supply/pricing, but I don't have the numbers. I would think that most owners are already utilizing residential rentals pretty much at full capacity in the markets that are the tightest.
- pydry 5y ago