6 ms·
It's all about consumer preference. It seems this article largely misses this. People want to live in specific locations, or have to in order to find work. Thi
by giantg2 5y ago
It's all about consumer preference. It seems this article largely misses this.
People want to live in specific locations, or have to in order to find work. This drives land values up as demand increases. Policies can make this worse, but the problem will still manifest itself to some degree. (Potentially as affluent people, especially in suburban areas, buying up more land to create setbacks, or simply buying because they can afford it now, or HOAs setting limits, none of which help density, demand, and cost).
"reduce the costs of construction, particularly residential construction (ie: housing)"
Changing preferences are the best way to address this, yet is likely the most difficult to sucessfully influence. Houses being built today are mostly larger homes, and definitely much larger than the majority homes built generations ago. This means more materials, more labor, more regulation, etc. Now we might be using cheaper materials, or less per sqft, or using tools that increase speed of laborers. But I think this is mostly canceled out by just increasing the size of the house (ie we're growing into our fish bowl).
For a personal example, my wife complains that an 1800 sqft house is too small.
- com2kid 5y ago> For a personal example, my wife complains that an 1800 sqft house is too small. A modern blueprint 1800sqft house, yeah, for sure. But somehow a 1960s split level at 1800sqft is spacious. We are throwing square footage away on multiple large bathrooms, 2 living rooms, 2 dining rooms, and then wonder why the rooms we actually occupy are so small. The recent trend towards 4 story narrow houses doesn't help. A literal 1/3rd of the house is taken up by stairs! I'm in a 2300sqft house that has 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms and an office. There is still a bit of wasted space, but not much! Meanwhile, I've seen new houses, 3000sqft, 3 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, 1.5 million. "Oh you want 4 bedrooms? Those start at 1.7 million" <-- Said by an actual house developer
- bumby 5y ago>But somehow a 1960s split level at 1800sqft is spacious. I've actually found the opposite. Modern builds seems to prefer open floor plans and higher ceilings that older homes do not. To me at least, this can make the equivalent square footage seem less cramped. To your point though, it's much more common for newer homes to have more bathrooms than older builds of similar size which obviously erodes living space.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> it's much more common for newer homes to have more bathrooms than older builds of similar size which obviously erodes living space. Newer homes also seem to be kitchen heavy, and have larger closets (and also bedrooms), all of which reduces shared (and, but for the bedroom part, total) living space with the same square footage.
- ghaff 5y agoYes, although the dining area is often part of a largely open common area that includes the kitchen and living room. My brother recently rebuilt a house in Maine and largely went with an open floor plan with relatively modestly-sized bedrooms and bathrooms. It makes pretty efficient use of space. The downside is that if someone want to have their own space, they pretty much have to go outside or retreat to their bedroom. My house is fairly standard 200 year old New England Cape (though some of it isn't original). I've largely opened up the downstairs to be a common space that I use heavily. Upstairs are four fairly small bedrooms and one small bathroom. It's fine for myself and guests. But even with just two people, there's really only one spare room which I tend to use for staging trips and various hobby stuff I don't want to clutter my office. I'd add that for a lot of people, one small bathroom would be a deal-breaker although shared bathrooms were considered the norm a few decades ago.
- nemo44x 5y agoBig kitchens with islands and casual dining space add so much value to a home today. People absolutely love making the kitchen a centerpiece room. It can be used for so many things. I think in older homes the thought at the time was that the kitchen was a utility room meant for cooking, food storage and dishes. And that the living room was the center of it all.
- ghaff 5y ago>I think in older homes the thought at the time was that the kitchen was a utility room meant for cooking, food storage and dishes. And in some cases, it was where the servants dealt with such things out of site of any guests. The house I grew up in had such an arrangement. And although we didn't have a cook, etc., in the sixties, my parents did a lot of large dinner party entertainment. While my mother did the cooking, it would still have been pretty much unthinkable for guests to be hanging out in the kitchen much less helping to clean up etc.
- giantg2 5y ago"A modern blueprint 1800sqft house, yeah, for sure." This seems to mostly be a difference in preference. The house is 1.5 baths and not large ones. Some layout parts are less efficient, like a master bedroom bigger than it has to be (so opposite of the numerous small rooms issue you brought up). But overall there is plenty of room, even a room dedicated as a play room. But overall this is a great example of shifting preferences over time since an average size house was 1970 was about 200 sqft less that this, and I grew up in an 1100sqft house. Prices vary by location. You can have a 4 bed house build for a quarter of that in many areas of the country.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> We are throwing square footage away on multiple large bathrooms, 2 living rooms, 2 dining rooms Two living rooms (well, “living” and “family”) and two (“formal” and, well, not) dining rooms are pretty common in 1960s homes at the size being discussed. Bedrooms, bedroom closets, and kitchens are probably smaller than newer homes, though. > The recent trend towards 4 story narrow houses doesn't help. Tall, narrow houses have been a feature of urban single-family homes for a while, I don't think they are a new trend.
- asielen 5y agoModern homes have less room to live and more room to store crap.
- giantg2 5y agoI haven't really noticed that. Some older home don't have closets, or only small ones. But then it was common to have a shifero etc, taking up space too. Areas commonly used for storage, like unfinished attics, basements, and garages aren't generally counted in the assessed sqft.
- com2kid 5y ago3 car garages so full of stuff they can't fit a single car! Modern America in a nutshell. The number of "parlors" I've seen full of boxes is unreal.
- com2kid 5y ago> Two living rooms (well, “living” and “family”) and two (“formal” and, well, not) dining rooms are pretty common in 1960s homes at the size being discussed. When house buying in 2020/2021 I looked at over 100 homes. Very few, if any, of the 1960s houses wasted space on two dining rooms, and a fair number had basements converted to family rooms but it obviously wasn't an original part of the floor plan. The 1960s split level design is obscenely efficient in space usage. There are plenty of variations on it, but the well done ones, vaulted ceilings, visible interior wood trusses, are still nice to live in today. The only modern amenities they are missing are a walk in closet and a full master bath. Clocking in at ~2000sqft they can do more than a modern 3000+ sqft home does. > Tall, narrow houses have been a feature of urban single-family homes for a while, I don't think they are a new trend. Agreed, but the new breed is much narrower than before. I've been in Chicago row houses, and sure they are narrow, but the new ones they are building around Seattle are insane. It is basically one room then a flight of stairs. 3 bedrooms, one in basement, one on 2nd floor, 3rd on top floor. It borders on unlivable for a family, not to mention anyone over the age of 35. Honestly it'd be much better if they just made regular condos, instead of 4 across narrow homes of 4 stories, do 4 flats.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"The recent trend towards 4 story narrow houses doesn't help. A literal 1/3rd of the house is taken up by stairs" If you want vertical efficiency, we have apartments for that. You get a single staircase and 20 single-story homes instead of 20 staircases in 20 homes. Its funny that US/UK/ anglosphere seems to have never figured out apartments, in Uk you can't even be a true owner - first you pay leasehold, then you pay ground rent, then you pay service charge (for which they are not obligated to provide any service), so you paid 3 times for the same thing! And then when yoy find out that your block was built in breach of fire regulations, it's not the material supplier, not the developer and not the building landlord that get the bill, its the leaseholder that does not even own the house that has to pay for 'waking watch' (pateolls by firemen) and any repairs! People who bought Shared Ownership apartments (you own 25%, other 75% is owned by investors) are responsible for 100% of the cost of fixing the building because between developer, supplier, fire inspector and landlord someone has commited fraud. UK likes to think fo itself as free country, but I have never seen laws as tyranical and feudal as housing laws here. It's like they were writted for medieval lords to opress their peasanta and never changed. If you want to know more about this, google 'cladding scandal, UK'
- bobthepanda 5y agoThe US has large apartment buildings, the problem is that there is not a whole lot of anything between 5-20 stories, and there is a construction premium for 20+ story buildings. (And in the US it would be two staircases and 20 single story homes, specifically because building codes require two staircases to prevent a Grenfell-like disaster.
- yholio 5y agoIn all honesty, Grenfell was caused by bad construction choices, materials and political penny-pinching. A second stairway filled with cyanide smoke would have had very limited benefits.
- neilwilson 5y agoNobody really wants to live in an apartment. People really want to live in their own little hut - as we have done for centuries. "in Uk you can't even be a true owner " You can never be the 'true owner' of any land in England. All land is technically owned by the Crown. You can only ever hold an interest in land in England - a freehold being the best you can get, and even those are littered with covenants these days.
- pydry 5y ago>People want to live in specific locations, or have to in order to find work. This drives land values up as demand increases. This ignores the world's giant pool of floating capital ravenous for returns that jumps on trends and amplifies demand by buying up what it thinks will have good resale or rental value. I saw this happen in the area I grew up in recently. Some people I know who were struggling to gather a deposit saw their dreams of homeownership go up in smoke as they got consistently outbid on a series of properties by investors. This would be a pretty harmless outlet of an for a glut of capital if A) land werent finite or B) land had not been slowly untaxed for decades. Of the two, B is a more prudent way of making property prices sane again.
- bumby 5y agoHow do you implement B) without causing a disproportionately negative impact on existing homeowners? For example, would you just tax "new" purchases more heavily? Or scale it into existing homes? Give caveats for fixed-income (elderly and disabled)? Politically, this seems like a tough road, even if it's the best choice. You have to essentially convince people to vote against their own economic self-interest. I think current tax policy around homes is curious because it's one of the few areas that there is a rather clear consensus around economists that it's bad policy that incentivizes the wrong actions, yet we can't seem to change them.
- pydry 5y agoLand value tax. It could be made palatable to regular people by making a high tax free threshold. Most homeowners could be left unaffected. That leaves 50% of land owned by the 1%. A fair chunk. Additionally the money could be funneled initially into pensions for the impoverished elderly. Capital/billionaires would fight back by arguing that it would hit the elderly the hardest just as the howard jarvis taxpayers foundation did with prop 13 but if it was very obvious how many elderly people were helped, crying about grandmothers having to sell multimillion dollar mansions would probably backfire. They would throw immense resources at trying to discredit and kill this, though. They would use every character assassination trick in the book to stop those pushing it. Some would probably also resort to violence if that failed. It would be an uphill battle the whole way.
- brailsafe 5y agoI don't necessarily disagree, but I have been thinking about what it would take to hypothetically limit the ability for people to buy multiple properties within some geographical boundary, or even put some pressure on low density owners in that geographical boundary while the cost of housing/vacancy rates are within some extremely scarce range. It's a naive thought atm, but I would be curious if everyone basically had only one slot for residential ownership in the metro area of the city, how much could regional demand actually push prices? For example, is it even remotely reasonable as a society to allow extremely wealthy people to own two or more condos in Toronto, when the minimum cost to get any condo is 3/4 of a million and salaries not remotely keeping pace? Is it unreasonable to settle on a definition of excess being that of the multiple residential property owner? Likewise for consideration towards residential property development companies. Maybe it's possible to own a lot of land specifically designated for development, but not for just holding more than one or a few properties.
- svachalek 5y agoI don't think it's possible with all the shell corporations and other gimmicks the rich use. It's just too easy to conceal who owns what. I think simply removing all the market restrictions that make homes such a valuable investment would do it, when demand meets supply suddenly housing markets start to look like any other market. But this seems to be politically unthinkable just about everywhere.
- brailsafe 5y agoI think there's a difference between completely impossible, and partially very difficult. If reasonably well-off people can pretty easily leverage low-interest rates and take control over property that otherwise wouldn't have as much competition, then that's probably a bad thing. The super rich will always figure out a way if it's lucrative enough, but those actions would stand out more if it was generally unacceptable. As it stands, I don't even know how to track down data on how many people own multiple properties. Likewise, you can't possibly out-pace multiple property ownership with supply in a desirable place unless you exhaust the excess capital available to wealthy people and ban low-density zoning codes and maybe even ban surface-level parking lots. In my neighbourhood, lots of wealthy homeowners have signs up decrying the construction of a sky-scraper that's sort of vaguely near the edge of their neighbourhood, which is currently occupied by a parking lot. The effect it would theoretically have, is adding to the available housing supply in the area for people currently renting at absurd rates because it's impossible to buy anything. It would take away rental income from people who already leveraged themselves too much, and marginally decrease demand for their scarce commodity known as a place to live.
- R0b0t1 5y agoA lot of it is cost of labor. What I suspect is cheap loans to homebuilders has propped up the price of trades and secondarily materials to the point most people can't afford to build their own house in any location. Then, depending on where you are, you have fixed costs for building in an area like geological or ecological impact statements that can be $20k or more. Too much.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Changing preferences are the best way to address this, yet is likely the most difficult to sucessfully influence. Houses being built today are mostly larger homes" Surely people who are currently homeless would rather rent a small house than none at all? I haven't met one demanding '1800sqft or i'd rather live on the street!'
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThis is why minimum wage, that prohibits low-wage work, and minimum floor size ordinances, that prohibit micro-suites, are so harmful. Fortunately the former has been mostly neutralized by the statutory minimum wage being reduced by inflation, but the latter is getting worse, with more such laws being implemented and reducing affordable housing.
- bobthepanda 5y agoSo yes and no. One important factor to increasing house size is that localities in the US tend to have fairly large lot sizes. To recoup the cost of building on more expensive land, builders build more house, because the opposite (building 2 or more houses and subdividing the land) is just illegal.
- pinephoneguy 5y ago