3 ms·
No, probably not. Usually you only have to abide by a countries laws if your server are based there, or you have a company incorporated there. If you have a US
by rmc 15y ago
No, probably not. Usually you only have to abide by a countries laws if your server are based there, or you have a company incorporated there. If you have a US company with servers hosted in the US, acbd an EU citizen uses it, and claims you are breaking their laws, then there its nothing the courts in that country can do to make you abide them.
To put it another way, are you worried if your US company breaks Chinese censorship laws? That's illegal in China. Are you worried if your company denies that the Holocaust happened? That's illegal in Germany.
You only need to abide by laws in the country you are in. Unless you have a EU server you don't have to abide by EU laws.
- zatara 15y agoDoes this apply to patents as well?
- rmc 15y agoNot sure. Almost all countries respect each others copyrights, that's why if a work is copyrighted in the UK, then it is copyrighted in Brasil (that's the Geneve Convention I think). I'm not sure about patents, especially when it comes to things like software patents. Ask your lawyer.
- Someone 15y agoI think you mean Berne: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention_for_the_Protection_of_Literary_and_Artistic_Works http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention_for_the_Protec.... The Geneva conventions are about victims of war.
- tonfa 15y agoLike most legal matter it's a bit more complex than that. As far as I know, you can be targeted by foreign laws with a .com domain, and servers physically in the US. If you specifically target/advertize (e.g. with translated interfaces) your services to EU citizens, a judge might decide that EU laws apply to you.
- Sandman 15y agoIs this just your opinion or do you have some examples to back it up? I don't see why a US judge would care at all if a US company breaks laws of another country.
- tonfa 15y agoCheck "conflict of laws" and "conflict of jurisdiction". I don't know the US legal system well enough to find it, but it happens in European countries (e.g. french judge applying US laws), so I guess it would be similar. Moreover a US judge might not care, but a French or German judge might decide he is competent (if there are good reasons to think the website is not US only).
- Sandman 15y agoIf a french or german court decides that a foreign company is violating their laws, they can do little besides preventing them from reaching their market, which would in this case mean that they can order ISPs to block the site. I'm pretty sure that there is no way that they can actually make a foreign-based company abide by their laws. How would they enforce the ruling? Of course, if the company in question also owns a EU-based daughter company through which it operates on EU market (as Facebook apparently does), then that's a whole different ballgame.
- rmc 15y agoYes things like .com's would complicate matters. I'd guess the only thing they could do would be confiscate your .com. Worse case is they might try to extradide you. Of course if you were to set up shop in the USA later, your past would catch up to you.
- lawnchair_larry 15y agoUnless it is a US law. You better believe that those apply globally. They can and will shut you down and/or throw you in prison.
- rmc 15y agoThey would have to come and get you.