3 ms·
There's another factor in the equation that you're not considering. "How much battery storage". The equation is finding an optima on a(cost of nuclear) + b(cost
by godelski 5y ago
There's another factor in the equation that you're not considering. "How much battery storage". The equation is finding an optima on a(cost of nuclear) + b(cost of renewables) + c(cost of storage). Restricting the equation to just aN + c_NS vs bR + c_RS is rather absurd (only something laypeople do and not something people in the energy community do). But in that case we can easily see that c_N << c_R, since nuclear provides a baseline storage. This brings us back to using the systems to complement one another (aN + bR + cS). After all, the goal is to get zero emission energy at the cheapest value, not energy at the cheapest value.
- qqqwerty 5y agoI did consider it, I work in the energy industry after all. But even your equation over simplifies things considerably. Things like cost over time (batteries are likely to get much cheaper in the future, whereas solar and nuclear are not likely to decrease much), and deployment characteristics (much easier/cheaper for the grid to add small incremental solar+wind+storage deployments over time then to add large individual nuclear deployments once or twice a decade) I am fully supportive of using whatever technology that gets us to a zero carbon grid as quickly as possible. And right now the most advanced research in this area is suggesting that renewables + storage is our best bet.
- pfdietz 5y agoWhy is solar not likely to decrease much? If the historical experience curve continues there's still room for a factor of several decrease in its cost.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt would not be surprising if costs for storage fell much more than photovoltaics, over the next decade, and for the same reasons as for the latter.
- godelski 5y agoIn fact, cost of storage is expected to fall over the next following decade or two. Problem is, we needed to start solving climate 50 years ago. We don't have time to wait another 10 to 20 years. We now are forced to go the unoptimal route and more expensive.
- ncmncm 5y agoStorage costs are plummeting already. But because generating capacity is now so cheap, we can afford expensive storage construction. Storage typically has very low operating cost, but is just now expensive to build. So, it will be cheaper to build storage later, but anything built this year will continue operating.
- qqqwerty 5y agoSolar is already dirt cheap, and there is not much more juice left to squeeze. We might get a little bit more cost reduction over the next decade, maybe somewhere in the 10-50% range, but this isn't much compared the multiple hundreds of % that we saw over the last two decades. Also, at least in the short term, we are seeing some increases in cost due to supply chain and inflation issues.
- pfdietz 5y agoYou're just repeating the assertion there. What fundamentally prevents the cost of solar from falling even more? This cost has to come from some irreducible input. Materials? Energy? Labor? Which is it? As for cost of delivered energy from solar, there is a final reduction that can still be obtained even if the cost/watt were to plateau immediately: extension of the lifespan of the system. This could be obtained by, over time, identifying and addressing all the degradation modes of the components of the system.
- qqqwerty 5y agoPredicting the future is hard. You are asking a question that pretty much no one has a good answer to (at least no one who is being honest). Are permitting fees an irreducible input? Probably not. Are lawyers fees an irreducible input? Maybe but unlikely. Are project developer salaries an irreducible input? I have no idea. But I also think you are mis-applying a mental model about the cost of manufactured goods to the cost of solar plant development. In a competitive free market, the cost of manufactured goods should eventually be reduced to a sum of their inputs plus any profit. But solar development is inherently an exercise in value capture. The project developers are trying to capture as much value as possible for their investors. The only thing that matters is that solar stays competitive in the energy market. As long as that happens, someone somewhere in the value chain can try and capture more value as other costs decrease. For example, what is stopping land owners from raising rents for solar projects? Right now, land is relatively cheap because there is not a lot of competition for it. But there are only so many parcels that are near transmission lines with good geographical features, and I fully expect land prices to increase as solar penetration increases. But this is really just a guess. If you are interested in current project cost breakdowns, figure 30 in this report does a pretty good job[1]. Module costs were the primary driver of cost reductions in the last 20 years. But they now account for only 40% of total project costs. So even if module prices fell by 50%, that would only result in a 20% decline in total project cost. While a 20% drop in prices would be nice, I don't think it really changes the math much with respect to nuclear (the math is already overwhelmingly in favor of solar). Also, I do agree that the average lifespan of these systems are going to be much longer than 20 years and that has not been priced in. But I don't think that is going to really change things anytime soon. Financial models and risk models are incredibly crude instruments. Using them to model even 5 to 10 years in the future is already extending them well beyond what they were designed for. But we have to put an end date on these models because at some point every project is going to cease to exist. And 20 years is what the banks like, so that is what we use. [1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy21osti/77324.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy21osti/77324.pdf
- caoilte 5y agoYou make a good point about nuclear potentially requiring less storage since it (in theory) provides a constant power. Unfortunately, whilst nuclear power tends to be constant while it is on, it still goes down a lot either for servicing (planned or unplanned) or because of lack of cooling water (a problem that's going to get much worse due to climate change). Worse when there is a lack of cooling water it tends to affect lots of nuclear plants simultaneously (eg France). So in total, Nuclear is just as reliant on grid inter-connectors as solar/wind to perform optimally. The difference is that solar/wind are sooooo much cheaper you can now build solar/wind/interconnectors/storage and still come in cheaper than nuclear. No country in the world ever figured out how to build out nuclear power efficiently and in the last ten years the decline in solar/wind/storage costs has been astronomical. That's why Nuclear is going nowhere. If we were to give storage plants subsidies at a level with what nuclear receives, there wouldn't even be a discussion about this.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoIf you have 30 reactors, maybe 3 are going down due to maintenance or other random reason. 90% capacity factor. If wind doesn't blow over Europe, you can have 15% overall capacity factor.
- qqqwerty 5y agoFortunately no one is suggesting we go 100% wind. Wind, solar, biomass, geothermal, hydro, storage. Plus some nuclear if it is already built. That is what folks are recommending. If new build nuclear can compete, then great. But right now it can't, and models show we can get there without it.
- opo 5y ago>...it still goes down a lot either for servicing (planned or unplanned) or because of lack of cooling water Unclear what you are basing that on. Nuclear energy has by far the highest capacity factor of any energy source and its not even close: https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/nuclear-power-most-reliable-energy-source-and-its-not-even-close https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/nuclear-power-most-reliab... >...The difference is that solar/wind are sooooo much cheaper The levelized cost for residential rooftop solar is higher than nuclear, but that cost doesn't matter? https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020 https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020 https://www.statista.com/statistics/493797/estimated-levelized-cost-of-energy-generation-in-the-us-by-technology/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/493797/estimated-leveliz... Modern society is dependent on 100% reliable power. Even that relatively small blackout in Texas caused: >...At least 246 people were killed directly or indirectly,[3] with some estimates as high as 702 killed as a result of the crisis.[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis If we were to rely just on solar and wind, the low capacity factor would likely require massive grid storage. The only large scale grid storage we have at this point is pumped hydro and that isn't scalable. For example, one estimate is that for Germany to rely on solar and wind would require about 6,000 pumped storage plants which is literally 183 times their current capacity. https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/144985/1/cesifo1_wp5950.pdf https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/144985/1/cesifo1_wp5... If making more grid storage was cheap and easy, we would have built it decades ago. Overbuilding could alleviate some of this, particularly the natural variations in seasonal energy output, but obviously this would be a multiplier to the cost and it won't get more power from solar at night, etc. As Bill Gates said in an interview: "…They have this statement that the cost of solar photovoltaic is the same as hydrocarbon’s. And that’s one of those misleadingly meaningless statements. What they mean is that at noon in Arizona, the cost of that kilowatt-hour is the same as a hydrocarbon kilowatt-hour. But it doesn’t come at night, it doesn’t come after the sun hasn’t shone, so the fact that in that one moment you reach parity, so what? The reading public, when they see things like that, they underestimate how hard this thing is. So false solutions like divestment or “Oh, it’s easy to do” hurt our ability to fix the problems. Distinguishing a real solution from a false solution is actually very complicated." https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/11/we-need-an-energy-miracle/407881/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/11/we-need... Gates is investing in 4th gen nuclear and energy storage companies so he is at least putting his money where his mouth is. The goal should be to decarbonize the electrical grid while maintaining the reliability we depend upon.