5 ms·
The problem nuclear has is that if you build something that can last literally half a century and more, the operational environment has changed so much. People
by panick21_ 5y ago
The problem nuclear has is that if you build something that can last literally half a century and more, the operational environment has changed so much.
People consider 'nuclear' to be nuclear built many decades ago with technology principles from even a few decades earlier.
Building something that has such long term aspirations is inherently problematic.
At the same time, if you turn them off, how much of the replacement will be fossil?
If you actually had a carbon price, would they still not be competitive?
Nuclear is truly in a sad state. And those reactors if turned down can't easily be replaced with any next generation designs because they don't exist as a practical product right now.
I think in 100 years people will laugh at as saying things like 'They had all the technology needed back then, why did they use it so badly'? I think that future will be nuclear fission powered, and not sun and solar powered.
- downrightmike 5y agoThey really need to pick a utilization level and then just send everything to batteries. Massive generation linked with instant availability to smooth out the peaks and furrows. Really at this point, every power generation site needs batteries.
- panick21_ 5y agoFor traditional nuclear that probably true. The energy market doesn't reward stable. You really want to peak when wind/solar are gone or usage is high. Next generation has two approaches, some try to be very adaptable, scaling up and down quickly. Its not like nuclear isn't capable of that if you have the right reactor. But of course you would prefer to run at 100% most of the time. Other companies basically use a solar salt coolant loop as a heat sink and battery. Basically reusing the technology from Concentrated Solar Plants. Moltex Energy for example basically expect basically a default 1h battery and then depending on the costumer and where you deploy it you can have a larger battery and a bigger turbine. You should be able to basically mix and match the size of your heat battery and your turbine. I could also imagine something like Form Energy Iron batteries just sitting right next to a nuclear plant and simply charging those and saving energy in the form as electricity instead of in heat.
- downrightmike 5y agoUtilities at this scale need to become boring and stable. As long as someone can game it, they will.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"I think that future will be nuclear fission powered, and not sun and solar powered. " Every life on earth, was always sun powered. I doubt that fundamentally changes. "They had all the technology needed back then, why did they use it so badly'?" But I agree to that. The technology is there. Did you know, that you can make batteries in bulk with no rare elements, with just iron, copper and saltwater? And also, that you can transport electricity over long distances and that we have abundance of sunny desserts? (and many more concepts of solar power generating, than just solar panels) But sure, alternativly we can also build thousands of nuclear reactors, that contaminate their environment for a long time if they fail badly. I mean, fission is an quite awesome technology, which at some point of progress probably can handled safely under normal circumstances. But just because of unsolved human social dynamics alone (aka terrorism), it is maybe not very wise to scale them up and spread them everywhere. But whether solar or nuclear - the main problems that remain, are that in most parts of the world, it is still way cheaper to just burn coal and oil.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is not. But the furnaces and turbines are already built out. So, everybody continues spending a lot more on power than they should. We would not have this problem today if Ronald Reagan and his political heirs had not killed alternative power investment decades back.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat would have actually helped if Nixon and Jimmy Carter would not have killed and reduced nuclear power research. And solar and win power were simpy not ready, no matter what Reagan did. The simple fact is, green CO-2 free power grids were possible, and they were done in the 80s by France. The reality is both parties turned essentially anti-nuclear because of the backlash in the 70s.
- ncmncm 5y agoClearly you would like for that to be true. But Jimmy Carter was a trained nuclear engineer. He was well qualified to understand their true value. Or lack of it. He put solar panels up on the White House roof. Reagan scrapped them. Reagan, of course, was not qualified to understand much of anything besides PR. But did, that.
- bamboozled 5y agoIn Australia, wind and solar have already started to win: https://www.smh.com.au/business/companies/origin-energy-to-bring-forward-closure-of-australia-s-largest-coal-fired-power-plant-20220216-p59x50.html https://www.smh.com.au/business/companies/origin-energy-to-b... No sign of a nuclear reactor in sight.
- trenchgun 5y agoNuclear reactors for electricity production are illegal to build in Australia by law. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Australia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Australia So not very surprising they are not being built there.
- bamboozled 5y agoMy point is though, they're still planning to close large coal power stations ecause renewables are pricing them out. Coal could be Nuclear too in this regard.
- panick21_ 5y agoAnd my point is this could have been done 40 years ago nuclear and we would be a n far better position regarding climate change. It could have been done 30 years ago after Kyoto protocols. It could have been done 20 years ago when everybody started to take it seriously. And if nuclear had really involved at all since the 1970s nobody would even think about deploying solar and wind. Next generation nuclear plant based on first principle analysis have no reason to be more expensive. The reality is such plants can run with little human intervention for potentially decades and the total land and materials requirements are not very large. The fuel has the potential to be essentially free as thorium is a waste product and if you can run on natural uranium its also basically free. The key is reducing the total investment to build a plant and the time it takes to build it. Both are very likely if you build plants that are only 1/10 the size and require far less safety and cooling equipment while being able to run on commercial turbines from gas and coal.
- 5y ago