3 ms·
For that fusion budget you could develop very viable commercial molten salt (or molten salt cooled) nuclear reactors. Fusion has no practice reason to exist co
by panick21_ 5y ago
For that fusion budget you could develop very viable commercial molten salt (or molten salt cooled) nuclear reactors.
Fusion has no practice reason to exist compare to advanced fission. The improvements in energy density are not really relevant factor at that scale, meaning the difference from oil to fission, and oil to fusion doesn't really gain you much.
Fusion fuel cost over the long term is likely more expensive then a fission fast breeder (not to mention a potential of thorium thermal breeder).
Is a fusion reactor going to be cheaper to build then a advanced fission reactor? Not from anything know so far. Advanced fission concept are viable with pretty normal tubes pretty industrial steels or at most advanced aerospace materials. Any fission reactors actually consider would have waste more complex and expensive parts.
The nuclear waste argument is sometimes made in favor of fusion but with the right kind of fission reactor this problem and issue that has very viable practical solutions and storage for a few hundred years is viable.
Sometimes nuclear proliferation is held up as a reason why fusion is good, but that argument doesn't really work either once you think threw it. Access neutrons of fusion can certainty be used for all kind of things.
Are fusion reactors inherently safer? That's questionable. To come up with a scenario where a modern molten salt breeder (or even molten salt reactor) leads to massive safety hazards for anything outside the exclusion zone is very hard to imagine.
The scenarios you have to come up with for both fusion or advanced fission to be massive safety concerns are both possible and incredibly unlikely.
My approach would be to do something like NASA did for Commercial and Crew, have competitive fixed price competition between a group of providers and offer the 2-3 winners of them at least 2 deployments.
- willis936 5y ago>For that fusion budget you could develop very viable commercial molten salt (or molten salt cooled) nuclear reactors. Could you, though? Look at the "Nuclear Energy" category. It is entirely devoted to fission reactor research and has a 1.85 Bn USD budget. That's a SPARC every year. Where are the LFTRs on the grid?
- ncmncm 5y agoTokamak fusion is a complete dead end. Advanced fission is, by contrast, just wildly uncompetitive, and getting more so every day.
- panick21_ 5y agoSo your argument is that nuclear energy can not innovate and be cheaper? Why? What exactly is inherently expensive. From first principle, total resources invested, advanced nuclear wins by a huge amount. The same goes for land use. A single building with a modern nuclear reactor in it could replace a gigantic wind-farm.
- ncmncm 5y agoNukes are mature tech. No surprises coming. They are not getting cheaper. If you got approval to build one, you would get no power for ten years, minimum. A billion dollars buys a GW of solar panel generating capacity today. Another billion buys plenty of storage. No NRC approval, no containment vessel, no disaster plan. You can start generating power almost immediately, while you are still building out. Prices continue falling the whole time you are building, so the last panel you put up costs half what the first did. It all fits well within the exclusion zone of a typical nuke reservation. You can put up wind turbines too. And keep adding panels, paying for them with income from ones already up.
- panick21_ 5y ago> Nukes are mature tech. No surprises coming. That is just complete nonsense. I think you are mixing up standard light water technology with nuclear power. A common mistake but also complete nonsense. I would highly advice you actually study nuclear power and nuclear reactor technology. I believe the same as you do now because I was ignorant about the technology, the I actually engaged with it. > If you got approval to build one, you would get no power for ten years, minimum. Again, this is not even true for PWRs if you built more then 1 every other decade. And the type of reactors I am talking about are totally different and require less then 10% the amount of resources and far smaller build project. They have no cooling towers and don't use any low heat steam power. A single factory mass producing nuclear modular nuclear vessels has a far higher potential energy density then anything else imaginable. The first principles are not really in question.