3 ms·
People might down vote because they are uninformed. Once you seriously look into Japan plans for suicide attacks on massive scales would have been very costly.
by panick21_ 5y ago
People might down vote because they are uninformed.
Once you seriously look into Japan plans for suicide attacks on massive scales would have been very costly. They were doing series effort in transformed their air-force and navy into suicide attack armed forces.
And these suicide attacks are not crazy, they were well plant and well executed attacks designed inflict massive costly attrition on the US.
Think about literally 10000s of well planned and executed suicide plans and suicide submarines attacks, army willing to suffer mass sacrifice.
And the fact is, the US did not have any solution for these suicide wave attacks. They were literally designed to work around US air defense patterns, and by the end of the war, the US had not figured out how to decisively defeated these attacks.
Landing 100000s of troupes in Japan against massive waves of suicide plans would have been insane.
> the systematic starvation program that the Bolsheviks unleashed in the Ukraine (The Holodomor)
Just FYI, it was not a systematic starvation program, it was a systematic food export program. And it was not target at Ukraine, but was applied in much the same way all over the Soviet Union.
I know there are some books that push the ethnic angle (and doing so is very popular particularly now), but its pretty clear from the top level documents and policies that it wasn't some form of ethnic warfare.
It was do whatever you need to export food so you can buy machines from the West.
- myth_drannon 5y agoI think less of an export issue but mass collectivization all across USSR. My g-grandfather was sent to Siberia in 1932 for refusing to give up his cow to collective farm. That's one good farmer family less to produce. Now multiply it by one million and you get a famine on unimaginable scale.
- panick21_ 5y agoSure, the reason they did the collectivization beyond the ideology is so they could then control that production and channel it towards the uses they desired. Total production was expected to go down. The regime was very well aware of that. But their control over that production was increased exponentially. And considering the industrialization, a lot of that went into exports where it was exchanged for industrial goods. Sorry for your g-grandfather, must have been a horrible time. Its insane that back then they considered anybody a 'wealthy farmer' who had like 1-2 cows.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Just FYI, it was not a systematic starvation program, it was a systematic food export program. And it was not target at Ukraine, but was applied in much the same way all over the Soviet Union. Food production was initially fine. After USSR central planning shenanigans shaking things up production was less. Those crops were then allocated away from Ukraine because they were last in line to be fed and first in line to starve for political reasons. Whether that constitutes "systemic starvation" or just "normal starvation" is pretty much an exercise in taxonomy because the fact of the matter is that intentional decisions by the people in charge are what lead to the problem.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat matter to the top people at the government was not total production, but rather total share of production controlled by the government. They didn't not care if total production went down. > intentional decisions by the people in charge are what lead to the problem And I am not denying that. What I am arguing against is the claim that this was ethnic derived warfare target at destroying Ukrainian nationalism. That is the story often told today. Stalin certainty was engaged in class warfare ('taking a class approach' is the common translation used from his writings) and many different cultures and ethnicity were hit. Kazakhs, Ukrainians and lets not remember the many Russian victims too, and of course many more. Their fundamental driver was getting the resources need for spending on industrialization.
- csense 5y ago> They didn't care if total production went down. They didn't care if millions of people died slowly and horribly of starvation. Phrasing it as "Production went down" is a rather extreme euphemism.
- panick21_ 5y agoYes that's correct. From a practical standpoint that simply means lower overall production, that communist party logical for you. Gaining control over the means of production is what mattered to them. Anything cost was acceptable to achieve that outcome.
- InTheArena 5y agoIt's fair to note that this is contentious - I would just point that the most recent scholarship has focused on (not surprisingly) Stalin's point of view with the Ukraine (and he absolutely did view it as a systematic way to weaken the Kulak's and the Ukraine), and Historians seem to now be generally viewing it as a genocide. That's not universal, but certainly the way that the scholarship (at the moment) is trending.
- panick21_ 5y agoI do not venture in what is and isn't genocide. The legal definition and common use and so on. I don't know. My point is that it is not primarily target towards ethnicity. It was certainty targeted towards Kulak's and of course, Ukraine had a productive land and thus a fair number of 'Kulaks'. The typical translation that is most often repeated in Stalin writing and the 'party line' was 'taking a class approach'. What I dislike is the Ukrainian nationalist attempt to own the history. The same policy hit other ethnic groups just as hard. The Kazakh population was probably more effected in terms of %. A huge amount of ethnically Russian farmer died as well, and they often get no mention in discussions of this. I has become fashionable to portray it as a Ukrainian tragedy, rather then a Eurasian tragedy. It effect people between Moldova, Omsk and Arkhangelsk and beyond. The most powerful version of that is Red Famine by Anne Applebaum. And that book as a pretty clear focus on Ukraine and a political message for the current situation for Western audiences. Ukrainian nationalism has been trying to use the Holodomor in the same way Israel does with the Holocaust, it gives it the permenent victim role and the moral high ground. She her self of course is a political commentator on those matters and her husband is politically active in trying to pull Ukraine into Europe. While here book does pay some small amount of attention to the other aspect and other victims, the overwhelming message is about Ukrainians suffering and overcoming basically intentional attempts at destruction of Ukraine and that is what the conversation around the book has universally focused on those aspects. Steven Kotkin biography of Stalin that just came out spent a lot time at looking at the Presidential archives, meaning the archives of actual stuff on Stalin desk. With Stalin writing on it. Very often Stalin notes his responses directly on the reports he gets. And the overwhelming focus on that is showing how Stalin had on his desk lots of reports of starvation from all over the Soviet Union, his response a lot of focus getting his party to hit requisition quotas and that the reports about starvation were exaggerated or excuses by functionaries for failing to hit quotas. Very little is about 'lets plan a mass starvation because we are afraid of Ukrainian nationalism'. The overwhelming focus is on building and wielding a governmental machine to impose a new state dominate economic system on everybody, no matter the cost. I have certainty not done an exhaustive study of all books and paper published on this topic in the last decade so your overall characterization of the debate might be accurate. The term 'systematic starvation' implies that starvation was the goal. This is not the case in my opinion. The Soviet certainty expected economic disruption and people like Alexei Rykov (2nd most powerful guy in the Soviet Union) opposed the collectivization on those grounds. However even in Rykov worst prediction fell well short of what was actually required to push this all the way to the end. Their reports don't say 'great success, mass starvation achieved', they actually believed their own propaganda about how collective farms would be far more efficient and so on. The difference seem to me that Soviets are willing to tolerate starvation to achieve their goals, not that they deliberately engineered starvation to achieve their goals. And their primary goals were not targeting Ukrainian nationalism. All in all, its a difficult topic and has been used as a political weapon before it even started so its of course a minefield.