4 ms·
> We take an entirely different approach by building direct integrations... > Private APIs need to be reverse engineered and are liable to change at any moment
by ceejayoz 5y ago
> We take an entirely different approach by building direct integrations...
> Private APIs need to be reverse engineered and are liable to change at any moment, so we had to develop systems to catch breaking changes and are always on alert to address them.
Isn't this still, essentially, screen-scraping? Reverse-engineering private APIs (presumably from their mobile apps, I'd imagine) and doing the abuse/block dance with their protective systems?
- captn3m0 5y agoWho is liable if the user's brokerage account gets blocked?
- timothygoltser 5y agoIt depends on the nature of the activity that got the account blocked - we place limits on the types of legitimate account activity that are likely to get a user blocked (sending too many orders too quickly, sending orders that could be batched as a flood of single orders, etc.), but for fraudulent or otherwise illegal activity, that liability is on the user. When starting a new integration, we schedule a meeting with the brokerage in question (if they'll have us) to discuss issues of this nature. The response we've gotten so far has been "as long as you don't enable illegal activity or put unnecessary load on our service, we won't take action against you or your users," though we're sure some brokerages will have a more aggressive stance on this in the future. We aim to work in partnership with them and advocate for the ability to integrate in this way, and we encourage the brokerages that gives us an audience to build public APIs.
- melony 5y agoFor a copy trading app, what compliance problems do you envision using your service? Is the trader being copied liable if the people copying him lose money (generally speaking)?
- timothygoltser 5y agoWhile I'm not fully qualified to comment on this (I'm not a lawyer/have no formal experience with securities law), my understanding is that it would depend on if the trader in question is providing investment advice. The SEC seems to have no clear position on the legality of copy trading at the moment - some of our customers are building copy trading apps, and they all seem to be in agreement that regulatory uncertainty is just one of the risks of building that sort of product at the moment.
- seandoh 5y agoWe spoke with some lawyers while building our social investing app to gain a clearer understanding of this. Like Tim said, we're not lawyers, but the ones we spoke to said that this is a major gray area.
- jhirschi 5y agoThere is probably a reason eToro, the premier copy trader, only does crypto copy trading in the US. Just food for thought. Effectively managing others' money would effectively make the trade-makers RIAs
- timothygoltser 5y agoWhile we try to form relationships with all of the brokerages we integrate with (including the ones we reverse engineer), we do still have to do the abuse/block dance with their protective systems occasionally. We've found that cutting out headless browsers has made it much easier to do this, for two main reasons: 1) Some brokerages have fairly sophisticated anti-screen-scraping protections, but their private APIs are comparatively undefended. 2) It's generally more difficult to create protective systems for private APIs, since there are fewer ways to fingerprint non-browser clients.
- ceejayoz 5y agoI think "direct integrations" as a euphemism from "using reverse-engineered private APIs in violation of their terms" is dishonest.
- timothygoltser 5y agoThat's a fair point - we've been trying to determine the best way to compress "using reverse-engineered private APIs in violation of their terms, but in practice brokerages don't really take enforcement actions against this," and "direct integrations" is what we came up with. We'll work on finding a better way to express this and are open to suggestions.
- alistairclark7 5y agoI think "unofficial API" is probably the most succinct phrase without being dishonest. A direct integration does imply some kind of professional relationship with the other company.
- seandoh 5y agoThis sounds good - thank you for the feedback.
- sjtgraham 5y agoIt's not as long as they expressly state there is no relationship or endorsement with the brokerages where there isn't one.
- rmbyrro 5y agoThis sounds like backwards to how this industry should be evolving...
- wisdomtt 5y agoWe agree, we would MUCH rather be implementing sanctioned integrations and we will go the sanctioned route whenever possible. We're trying to establish relations with these big institutions to push them towards sanctioned access and also get feedback on what would be best practices for integrating with them. Our bet is that the industry in the long-run will be moving towards enabling sanctioned access delegation. That being said, at the end of the day users want to export data from their brokerage apps and they want the means of exporting this data to be stable.
- rmbyrro 5y agoEither force through regulations or gotta make it in their interests to support a public API. Financially or else. I don't think they'll do just for the sake of it.