10 ms·
Privacy Sandbox on Android
- zmk5 5y agoI don't really follow android much anymore, so does anyone know how this would compare to iOS's privacy systems?
- chakrihacker 5y agoWhenever Google talks about privacy they are just joking. Don't take it seriously
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoEssentially, since Google is an ad company, and is supported by selling ads based on user tracking, they will integrate their ad tracking platform directly into Android itself. Meanwhile, Apple just blocks tracking behaviors.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoEvery time Google implements a new "privacy" feature, it's because they've figured out how to be mostly unaffected while harming their competitors.
- KKKKkkkk1 5y agoAccording to analysts, Apple made $5bn in ad revenue in 2021 [0]. [0] Apple’s privacy changes create windfall for its own advertising business. https://www.ft.com/content/074b881f-a931-4986-888e-2ac53e286b9d https://www.ft.com/content/074b881f-a931-4986-888e-2ac53e286...
- guywithabike 5y ago"According to analysts" tells you that you shouldn't take this very seriously. Analysts have a long and storied history of getting pretty much everything wrong about Apple for decades now.
- smoldesu 5y agoPlease, take the first-hand account of the multi-trillion dollar company over the results of independent studies. Next up, you should ignore the UN's accusations of Apple abusing Uighur labor in China because they're primarily comprised of nations that are not the US, which gives them a vested interest in badmouthing a spotless domestic company like Apple. It all makes so much sense now!
- meibo 5y agoPermissions for third party apps are pretty much identical to iOS now. People are always brigading these HN posts with useless snark because they think that Apple respects them.
- guelo 5y agoI think the main difference is the default. Android is now opt-out, iOS is opt-in. Defaults are significant.
- izacus 5y agoDefaults of what exactly? Permissions default to off on Android as well. Trackers and analytics default to on on Android and on Apple devices (where Apple devices differ only in the fact that they split tracking from apps and OS itself and enable Apples own tracking by default and prevent non-Apple tracking). Nevertheless, there's a massive amount of tracking going on in Apples ecosystem as well - all big analytics, marketing and mobile data services (like Facebooks's SDKs, Mixpanel, etc.) are iOS first and still provide massive amount of behavioural data on iOS users first and support Android second.
- urdinak 5y agoI think guelo is specifically referring to the Advertising ID that allows for apps' cross tracking. In Android, this ID is on by default, while in iOS is off by default. Regaring the permission managers, I agree that both are currently on par.
- saagarjha 5y agoYour comment would have been free of useless snark too if not for the last sentence.
- bobthebuilders 5y agoYour comment would have been free of useless snark too if not for the last sentence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- izacus 5y agoThey're very simillar these days, although Android is still easier to fingerprint just due to the higher amount of devices available out there. There's simply more informational content that can be gathered by the fact that you have a "T-Mobile firmware version of Galaxy S22" despite Google being pretty decent at plugging identifier leaks since Android 10 to new 12. Both operating systems assume something very basic though - that you trust the manufaturer of hardware and the developer of the OS. That is - Apple on one side and OEM/Google on the other.
- zibzab 5y agoThis is completely pointless if they don't also fix the (very deliberate) permission problems. For example, a lot of innocent operations such as connecting to your headphones have been tied to locations services. Google has been abusing this to extreme lengths to extract exact user location for years now.
- oauea 5y agoConnecting to your headphones requires bluetooth. Getting access to bluetooth means you can scan for nearby bluetooth devices. This may leak your location if identifiable bluetooth beacons are nearby. Hence, you need location access. iOS is similar. But they do not give apps access to the mac address of scanned bluetooth devices which makes the platform borderline unusable for actual bluetooth apps.
- Saris 5y agoThe problem is the permissions for bluetooth are lumped in with fine GPS location permissions.
- TurningCanadian 5y agoThey're lumped together correctly. If you allow bluetooth access, the nearby bluetooth MAC addresses could be used to identify your location with near-GPS precision.
- giaour 5y agoOr greater precision! GPS (at least as used on most phones) has a ~6 foot margin of error.
- Saris 5y agoFair enough, as long as those nearby devices have very precisely known locations in some database. But there's also the factor of battery usage, I'd like to be able to allow bluetooth but deny GPS hardware access for those occasional apps that like to trigger the GPS constantly for no good reason.
- mtgx 5y agoBut the Google Play service will still get data on everything, right?
- alphabettsy 5y agoSeems like a lot of words that don’t say anything.
- laegooose 5y agoI'm so confused after reading this. What exactly are they doing?
- hericium 5y agoAdvertising.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoIf you’re familiar with the mobile advertising landscape, on device identifiers are either OS-provided and deterministic or are computed through a “signature” or “fingerprint” based on unique signals the app has access to. This move is one where either of those will be removed/made universal so there is no way to identify uniquely, one user from another when they perform actions outside your app or for many scenarios within it as well (such as clicking on an ad that takes them to the app) Lots of advertising companies (predominantly Facebook) have made an industry standard out of selling ads based on THEIR interpretations of users actions across apps and time leading to a conversion. For example, a 7day “click through conversion” means , if your ad is shown to a user through Facebook on any of their apps or partner apps with the Facebook ad network sdk, and a subsequent conversion occurs in the next 7 day window, that user is counted as 100% credit to Facebook. Is this logical? Nope. Advertisers pay for the nice looking metrics they can stick in a PowerPoint and be done with it. Now, Facebook can’t use their “eye of Sauron” to put out numbers such as these and need to compete with companies such as google and Pinterest and Reddit and snap for where users are looking for things, not just “snipe” the attribution at the last minute when they know the user is about to pull the trigger and buy.
- Jwarder 5y agoLooks like they are trying to create a distinct set of APIs for third-party advertising (and I think everything else) SDK libraries. Those libraries are submitted to Google independently from the app. The apps now have to declare they are using library X version Y and Google will deploy that library to the end user's device when the app installs.
- jcranberry 5y agoThere are a few links which seem to describe what its all about. https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/sdk-runtime https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/sdk-runt... https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/topics https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/topics https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/fledge https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/fledge https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/attribution https://developer.android.com/design-for-safety/ads/attribut... The SDK Runtime sounds like a major step in the right direction (separating advertising SDKs into its own process with distinct permissions, separate from a hosting app and with no app-to-app communication). Also the ability to custom audiences from apps (in the fledge article) and control topics both sound good. These things dont appear to have any current plans to be required, but in the future I hope they do.
- xvector 5y agoBoth iOS and Android desperately need a "Network" permission (as is found on GrapheneOS.) I'd say at least half my apps don't need internet connectivity.
- username190 5y agoThis is available in iOS - but for whatever reason, on devices outside of China, you are only allowed to disable use of cellular data (not WiFi). This is also available in some Android skins (OxygenOS is one, for example) - but it is not in AOSP.
- grishka 5y agoThe fun part is that android.permission.INTERNET is something you have to declare in your app's manifest, otherwise any and all networking for your app will be blocked by the system. It has existed since the very first Android version. This permission is automatically granted by the system upon app installation. So the only thing missing is this permission being a runtime permission that the app has to request and user has to grant.
- infthi 5y agoThere are controls to disable internet access on a per-app basis. Seen them in devices from at least two different vendors, one of them being Pixel - thus I believe this is a stock feature on at least Android 10+.
- infthi 5y agoClarification: looks like I misremembered things; apparently those controls are not present on Pixel.
- antifarben 5y agoAbsolutely. Currently I'm using solutions like Blokada for that.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoI see a lot of comments here reduce the argument to “Ads are bad” . . . Well, Remember that ad-supported business models have underwritten the vast majority of technology R&D and improvements over the past two decades. Yes, including Apple. Hardware devices would never have the utility they do at present without large scale, low margin, high throughput ad models that benefit developers building insanely complex systems around said hardware. The whole advancement in AI we’re seeing today would never have been accelerated the way it has been this past decade without the monetization models of the present internet. It is a fine balance to strike where we don’t want to kill off the model that works so well, for fear of parts of it. The alternative monetization models are things that many people here would despise much more: - More closed-source , paid services , apps, devices that are more expensive without the scale of ad supported models - Smaller (and arguably harder to oversee) spin offs of major ad supported services. - etc
- crossroadsguy 5y agoLooked at the Android part of it. Seems Google is trying it make it such that third party will lose access to these data but Google will still have it and now Google can say this is now privacy. This sounds like a corporate/PR joke.
- cs702 5y ago> Today, we’re announcing a multi-year initiative to build the Privacy Sandbox on Android, with the goal of introducing new, more private advertising solutions. Translation from corporate-speak: "Today, we’re announcing a multi-year initiative to build a sandbox on Android that makes complete unrestricted access to your data available only to Google, with the goal of introducing new advertising solutions that keep all those pesky third parties, like Facebook and TikTok, outside of Google's garden." Calling it the "Privacy Sandbox" is... unintentionally Orwellian.
- jensensbutton 5y agoYeah, just like Apple did.
- smoldesu 5y agoAnd Aol, and Skype, and YouTube and Facebook and Yahoo and Microsoft[0]. The domestic surveillance nightmare never ends! We on HN laugh about this stuff and love to make noise about E2EE and whatnot, but the battle was lost decades ago. There's nothing left, privacy is a myth from a different era of the internet. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program)#/media/File:Prism_slide_5.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program)#/...
- hunterb123 5y agoApple isn't an ad company. Yes they have access to your data if it's not E2EE, but you don't have to worry about their core revenue stream conflicting with your privacy.
- vivekraghunatha 5y agoFounder of @Neeva here. In my experience, this is mostly PR that will go nowhere -- these are efforts that are not structurally set up to succeed given the internal constraints at Google. The Chrome sandbox efforts have been going on for 3-4 years with no progress. The mobile app ads businesses (UAC campaigns) at Google are just too profitable, and depend too much on IDFA/ADID tracking for the Android team to be able to do anything meaningful here. So we all know the stakes here, and to put this abstract "tracking" into "real world" perspective, a big use case of ADID/IDFA tracking is gaming advertisers identifying "whales" (kids/adults who spend a shit ton of money on their games) and accurately targeting them across all their usage on the phone. If your kids are being tricked into spending hundreds of dollars by these ads, this is why.
- Crash0v3rid3 5y ago> Founder of @Neeva here. In my experience, this is mostly PR that will go nowhere Let's be honest here, this post is clearly your own PR for Neeva.
- vivekraghunatha 5y agoFor sure, there's a bit of that. You would still agree w/ the point I'm making?
- freediver 5y agoThanks for providing your insights. It is a pretty strong comment against your former employer and presumably former colleagues. Were you not a part of the same spiel, building these very systems for years including those tricking kids into spending hundreds of dollars with ads, presumably with the same passion as you have now? Working at a corporation as big as Google and at a high position as you had must have left a mark. I am curious what changed for you and how do you look at your friends and colleagues that are still working in Google today?
- jefftk 5y ago> The Chrome sandbox efforts have been going on for 3-4 years with no progress. There has been progress: many APIs have been implemented in Chrome, with several origin trials for testing them and iterating. Ex: FLoC started an origin trial, people raised issues, Chrome proposed a replacement (Topics) which looks like it will be in origin trials soon (https://privacysandbox.com/open-web/#the-privacy-sandbox-timeline https://privacysandbox.com/open-web/#the-privacy-sandbox-tim...). (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)
- loteck 5y agoApple and Google are doing their best to redefine the term privacy to mean "information choices you make within the confines of our total surveillance." Prisoners are free to move about in their own cells.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI do not see the prospect of an alternative without a government codifying it into law and funding R&D for alternative devices.
- deusum 5y agoSo... you're saying it's possible!
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoI think that's an open question; FOSS Android ROMs and the assorted non-Android mobile Linux options are somewhat niche, but they're not nothing.
- teddyh 5y agoThere are alternative devices.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- godshatter 5y agoSo, Google, how about giving me the option to completely delete my advertising id? It would be nice to completely opt out of your advertising empire, at least as far as personal tracking is concerned.
- jayd16 5y agoIt would mean removing any and all anonymous user identity, right?
- jcranberry 5y agoYou can delete the data that google currently has and reset your advertising id.
- godshatter 5y agoSure, and then they start tracking me with that id. I just want to opt out of the entire experience. I'm fine paying the price by not having any personalized ads sent my way. I'd actually really really like that, in fact.
- jcranberry 5y agoI think there's a privacy focused firefox browser on the play store which is good for that. Maybe its possible to also create a service which resets your advertising ID daily or something?
- guelo 5y agoI can delete my advertising ID in Android 12
- godshatter 5y agoI guess I need a new phone. I'm on Android 9.
- grishka 5y agoGoogle is an advertising company. It's not interested in any real privacy because that would negatively affect its revenue. I'm a very anti-advertising kind of guy. I block ads on all my devices. I wish all forms of cross-app tracking identifiers were simply abolished, and any API that could be used to pass data between apps like this would require explicit user consent. Anything lesser is a pathetic half-measure.
- smoldesu 5y ago> I wish all forms of cross-app tracking identifiers were simply abolished, and any API that could be used to pass data between apps like this would require explicit user consent. Real question: how would you try to abolish fingerprinting? Processing identifying info on your device can mostly be done server-side and requires no device permissions, accounts or APIs, just some basic identifiers like screen resolution, storage capacity, software/library versioning, battery health... anything is fair game.
- grishka 5y agoFingerprinting is "analog" by its nature and thus never 100% reliable. Besides, here's another idea: not only make internet access a runtime permission like I suggest in another comment here, but also make it per-domain. If you don't trust an app, run it in a "paranoid mode" where you have to explicitly allow it to access every domain it tries to access. Advertisers always use their own infrastructure to prevent fraud among other reasons. And another one: a docker-style fully isolated container for you to run apps you don't trust. The container simply lies to apps with hardcoded or random values for anything that could possibly be used for fingerprinting.
- fsflover 5y agoOne possibility is to use Tor (or Whonix on Qubes, which I use).
- bentcorner 5y agoI'm very anti-advertising as well. I use ublock and youtube vanced, and have a pihole on my home network. While privacy is certainly a bonus, the main reason is that ads interrupt what I want to look at, consume power, are ugly, intrusive and a vector for malware. I know many content creators consider me to be stealing their content, I wouldn't exactly disagree. But so be it. Some sites block me from visiting them, I think that's completely fair, and I don't put up much effort in circumventing such blocks. This Privacy Sandbox initiative appears to not at all address the problems I have with advertisements.
- bko 5y agoI heard on an interview somewhere a security advocate mention that android phones "phones home" basically everything you do every so often (GPS location, app data, even voices recordings). But I couldn't find that anywhere apart from a few "malfunctioning" google nest devices. Is there any resource about what exactly is communicated to google while using android phones? Everything I read is either conspiracy theories or corporate speak. [edit] The interview in which the claims were made was with Dr Robert Epstein if that makes any difference https://open.spotify.com/episode/4q0cNkAHQQMBTu4NmeNW7E https://open.spotify.com/episode/4q0cNkAHQQMBTu4NmeNW7E
- sixothree 5y agoI think one of the problems is "what is google" and "what is phoning home". So many of these services make simple requests that wouldn't be considered "phoning home" but absolutely fall into that category. Additionally, the number of google products and the number of calls being made is vast.
- bko 5y agoI don't expect apps to be collecting data when not in the app. I think I get a permission warning like "this device uses GPS - allow when in app, allow in background, etc" But with android, I just want to know if there is a log of every place I go for instance and does this get sent to Google periodically. This is outside of the map app. Also, I definitely want to know if it's recording data any time apart for when the microphone indicator is on. This is on an OS level. I know there's some nuances, but I think what I am asking for is pretty basic.
- izacus 5y ago> But with android, I just want to know if there is a log of every place I go for instance and does this get sent to Google periodically. This is outside of the map app. There's two ways this can happen: - There's a feature called "Location History" which does exactly what it says - reports your location periodically to Google. You can disable it under Location settings on Android. - Your location may leak via IP requests in background - the most common way would be via persistent connection to FCM servers (servers that provide push messages, analogous to Apples Push notification services) or when the phone background syncs. Similarlly, you can leak your location to websites by simply browsing with your phone. > Also, I definitely want to know if it's recording data any time apart for when the microphone indicator is on. This is on an OS level. As far as I know there new microphone switches and notifications are implemented deep enough in AOSP code that a piece of software can't easily open the microphones without triggering that notification.
- Havoc 5y agoDon’t think I trust a single word google announces on the topic of privacy anymore
- jefftk 5y agohttps://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/bounded-distrust https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/bounded-distrust might be helpful in thinking about statements from entities you don't trust
- fleddr 5y agoGoogle basically has tracked the crap out of everybody without caring one bit about it, and now under regulatory pressure finds itself caring about privacy. They're going for this "reasonable middle-ground" approach but this is an issue where a compromise is not possible. This Sandbox idea basically means that instead of every 3rd party tracking the crap out of you, it's now exclusively in Google's hands. Where they may track "a little". There's even a privacy budget, where it is decided what "a little" means. Guess who controls this budget? Tracking should be opt-in. And not the Apple way either, where you "ask" the tracker to stop tracking whilst it happily continues. It should block tracking at a technical level. Apps can give intelligent options: - Enable tracking: app is free, some personalized ads. - Disable tracking: app is free, but more ads, that are not personalized. - Disable tracking: pay $ for non-tracked non-ad experience. This is real user choice. A privacy sandbox is no choice, you can't opt-out of it. To remind myself of how creepy tracking is, I often visualize the physical analogy. You're at home and somebody stands behind you, making notes of every webpage you visit, and when. You take a drive, and a car is following you all day, making notes of where you went. As you arrive at your friends' house, the follower makes photos of your friends and tries to find out their names, the connection is logged and they make a note to follow that person too. The creep following you has plugged a cable in your camera so that when you make a photo or video, they get a direct copy, along with all metadata. You want to send a postcard to your parents but the follower snags it from your hands, opens it, makes a copy and scans it for clues. You put some of your valuables in a storage box but the follower has a spare key and regularly inspects it. Not a single of the above interactions would be acceptable in the physical world, but it's the norm in the digital world. And to finish the analogy, the output of all of this is junk mail in the mail box which you immediately throw in the paper garbage department. Also, any of the above can be shared at will with institutions. Which seems totally reasonable, until it's not. Governments can turn against their citizens, it's common, also today. I don't mean to escalate this to unintended proportions but I can't help but share this powerful example: During WW2, Germany occupied the Netherlands and the one thing that helped them to find Jewish people was a single data field in the population registry: religion. Would you have ever guessed or anticipated that such a single unimportant piece of data would have led to the ultimate consequence? That's why privacy is a human right. Stand for it with everything you got.