3 ms·
Wut? Jazz is heavy on theory from the start precisely to facilitate the improvisation. You need theory to improvise, basically. You do not need theory to perfo
by watwut 5y ago
Wut? Jazz is heavy on theory from the start precisely to facilitate the improvisation. You need theory to improvise, basically.
You do not need theory to perform existing pieces all that much. Which is why you can learn to play classical music while ignoring theory.
- sornaensis 5y agoJazz theory came decades after jazz.
- lewispollard 5y agoYes, to describe and group together the specific music theory elements that jazz musicians tended to use: sevenths, avoiding triads, modulation, etc. Not because there was no theory intentionally used in jazz music. If you think those guys didn't know what they were doing...
- danShumway 5y agoThat's why jazz theory is valuable, sometimes people don't want to spend decades re-learning things that other people have already learned. Also, I'm just plain not as good a musician as, say, Duke Ellington was, and there's a benefit to being able to understand what he was doing so I can try to imitate that style and incorporate his techniques into my own playing -- I don't want to rediscover all of his lessons completely on my own because I'm not talented enough to do that; very few people are.
- Rochus 5y agoMusic theory is always "after the fact"; it's a way to teach people what their idols did, even if the idols didn't know or didn't apply the theory. To improvise you first of all require musical talent on both harmonic and rhythmic dimensions, and you need practice. Theory might help, but it is not a prerequisite.
- watwut 5y agoThis is not even true across history. "The idols" in jazz did knew and did applied theory. > To improvise you first of all require musical talent on both harmonic and rhythmic dimensions I mean, you need ability to keep rhythm and play notes. But beyond that, you absolutely can get away with theory only with basically zero special talent. You wont become world famous, but you will be able to match what the rest of group is playing. > even what we know today as "classical music" was often improvised in the past; many great composers were also great improvisers. Also going back to original comment, you seem to put theory and improvisation into some kind of dichotomy. But, both being great composer and great improviser are heavily facilitated by understanding theory.
- jseban 5y agoYeah it's not true at all, just look at russell's lydian chromatic concept for example, and how much new ideas for jazz and improvisation that it spawned. Theory does not only come after practice. Oh how I wish people would stop venting their fantasies of the god gift whenever the subject of music comes up
- Rochus 5y ago> "The idols" in jazz did knew and did applied theory When jazz music appeared, there were no conservatories or theory for it. The first jazz conservatories emerged fifty years later. Today they find many graduates, for example, from Berklee. But this is a development that has only begun in the last forty years. It didn't make the music better, it just made it different. > You wont become world famous Very very few world famous exponents of popular music have a formal musical education.
- jseban 5y ago> Very very few world famous exponents of popular music have a formal musical education. This is just false. If you start to dig into this a little bit, you will easily find connections between almost all famous musicians, and universities. If they didn't have formal education themselves, they often had private lessons from someone with a degree. Or someone in the band had a degree etc. Or in the case of the beatles, the "producer" just happened to be a trained composer who was giving a lot of "suggestions". Other examples: punk band green day songwriter billie joe had 15 years of lessons with a jazz guitarist with a university degree. Bluegrass guitarist tony rice had private theory lessons with a berklee graduate. etc etc. It's part of the marketing to downplay the theory and knowledge involved, people want to relate to musicians, and not feel like their being outsmarted, or manipulated by "some formula".