4 ms·
wild theory, sometimes I have this feeling that divorce is badly seen because 1) people jump between partners too often when free, it's easier but maybe less d
by agumonkey 5y ago
wild theory, sometimes I have this feeling that divorce is badly seen because
1) people jump between partners too often when free, it's easier but maybe less deep
2) family stability is important, and noble (it's a hard compromise but others complicated things are important and noble)
3) in the past social, family and intimate stability were probably a lot more important than today, so we inherited that perspective, even though today we may care less
ps: saying this I understand perfectly how human relationship, marriage are complex, volatile and how no one wants to rot in a bad relationship. :)
- einpoklum 5y ago> 3) in the past social, family and intimate stability were probably a lot more important than today Many past societies did not have atomic families like we do today. In fact, even couple-marriage is not _that_ old (several thousands of years)? I remember reading about this stuff in "Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State", which, while somewhat dated (125 years ago or so?) is quite interesting. Matrilineal societies, group marriage (i.e. being 'married' to all people in a certain category so that if you travel to another village you have people in your 'family' or 'marriage group' there even if you've never met them) and other arrangements.
- coldtea 5y ago>In fact, even couple-marriage is not _that_ old (several thousands of years)? Cities and written language and written laws and such are not that old either... What was the case in some earlier societies shouldn't be a yardstick...
- agumonkey 5y agoEven without the social contract. First time I held someone in my arms I had visions of life long companionship. Not everybody is wired this way but it's often programmed deep down inside of us. Marriage is just the social incarnation of that feeling IMO. Also some people say that a lot of animals have similar emotional/biological needs. It's not just a matter of homo-* history it seems.
- BigRedDog1669 5y agoI'm not saying that there isn't something biological or authentic to it, but you probably saw a bunch of Disney movies and a bunch of other cultural messaging when you were a child that helped prime you to have this response.
- rackjack 5y agoReminds me of this image: https://i.redd.it/lr5rfu3paen61.jpg https://i.redd.it/lr5rfu3paen61.jpg
- agumonkey 5y agoI always have a big problem with this argument. To me the social protocol take roots in the emotional thus the biological. It's not really propaganda, it's self amplified reflection.
- einpoklum 5y ago> Even without the social contract. First time I held someone in my arms I had visions of life long companionship I would assume you were brought up in a modern cultural environment. That means your view of the world, your values, your expectations, your fantasies - are shaped by that upbringing. So, your feelings are not good evidence that this is "programmed deep down inside of us".
- throwaheyy 5y agoAre you claiming that a desire for companionship with another human being is purely a modern social construct? That seems a … bizarre opinion. Until industrialization, human relationships were directly tied to survival.
- einpoklum 5y agoI claimed no such thing... And, in fact you're making the point even more strongly, in that you seem to identify lifelong, formal, monogamous pairing with the potential for human companionship.
- buscoquadnary 5y ago> "Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State" By Fredrick Engles, known most popularly when associated with his co-author Karl Marx. Who among their many philisophical ideas advocated things such as - "All history is class warfare" - Dialectical materialism that proved to be so wrong no one even knows about it anymore. - Or my personal favorite that the communist revolution would come first to the most capitalist countries, when in fact the only countries that fell to communism were backward feudal societies or those that had communism forced on them by the Soviet Union. My point if your source of information is Engles then I'd suggest checking out some resources from people haven't been quite so thoroughly eviscerated by actual reality when their ideas were put to any sort of test.
- coldtea 5y ago>ps: saying this I understand perfectly how human relationship, marriage are complex, volatile and how no one wants to rot in a bad relationship. :) There's a difference between "no one wants to rot in a bad relationship" and "no one wants to put the effort and time to make a relationship work", though. And while a number of divorces are because of the first, another number is because of the latter. Now, a question would be "So? Why shouldn't people just jump ship, even if they're just frivolous/bored/have short relationship attention spans/etc?" And an answer would be, "Well, look at our modern relationship landscape. Does these trends work out well for us? Is yes, then fine..."
- agumonkey 5y ago> There's a difference between "no one wants to rot in a bad relationship" and "no one wants to put the effort and time to make a relationship work", though. This is a very timely question. There are a few topics about how easy our lives should be, how much effort is considered normal. And beyond efforts, the skills to know when, what and how to apply them to avoid just struggling 24/7.
- dahfizz 5y agoThere is a certain level of arrogance in looking at how fundamentally important the family unit is for all of human history, and then deciding that this generation knows better than the billions who came before us and that marriage / family / kids is a sham. And shockingly, depression and anxiety is on the rise, we have a "loneliness epidemic", etc because people can't seem to fill that void.
- agumonkey 5y agoWe could argue that modern technology-oriented cultures are even stretching the social fabric. I'm nobody but it seems that survival made most mammals social, but we don't owe our survival to the group now, but to a blurry and large system. So why bother with people when I can swipe for all my needs /s But the thing is, as an ex introvert I can understand, dealing with people is not easy. Just like dealing with love, intimacy, marriage, existence is not easy. But we used to try to find solutions of better quality. Not just "i'm out".