3 ms·
"Twelve Years in a Monastery" (1897) by Joseph McCabe Discussed this, and the risks that the prelate in question may have incorrectly baptised priests, which in
by ggm 5y ago
"Twelve Years in a Monastery" (1897) by Joseph McCabe Discussed this, and the risks that the prelate in question may have incorrectly baptised priests, which in turn invalidates ALL rites they perform, marriages, sacraments, the works.
It's recursive.
Probably, there is a STACKFAIL path out, the local bishop can do something to declare things valid.
It's worth bearing in mid McCabe went "over the wall" and so was writing as a socialist-rationalist after he lost his faith. A catholic might well have reason to say he was wrong, and wrong at the time, as well as now.
A truly wonderful historian of the Vatican is Peter Hebblethwaite. I recommend "in the vatican" (1986) -It's obviously overtaken by events (Ratzinger wasn't a pope then, so he's still the head of the inquisition in the book, future white hat yet to come). Hebblethwaite died in 94. Shame, I would have loved to read his take on things now.
- graderjs 5y ago> Probably, there is a STACKFAIL path out, the local bishop can do something to declare things valid. LOL! Also, thanks for the book info. Sounds like interesting reads! :)
- ggm 5y agoMcCabe wanted to write an exposé and at some level he did: the sheer amount of beer the belgian monks were drinking would do my liver in completely. But, putting that to one side, he writes well, and he writes interestingly of what the monastic life really meant in those days. McCabe is probably available as an E-book, he was published by the rationalist press. Hebblethwaite wasn't trying to undermine the church, he really believed. He wanted to help people understand the complexity of the back-story behind the positions they saw at the front, but also to see the machine at work. So he does a lot of writing about how things really get done. An Amazon reviewer is not as kind as me and said he writes well but its just no longer applicable. I can't say, but I still think I enjoyed reading it and would recommend. This one isn't an epub, you have to find secondhand copies.