6 ms·
> These data imply an upper bound of 0.9 eV, which goes down to 0.8 eV when combined with the earlier results. For comparison, the mass of an electron is appro
by gus_massa 5y ago
> These data imply an upper bound of 0.9 eV, which goes down to 0.8 eV when combined with the earlier results.
For comparison, the mass of an electron is approximately 510,998.950 eV and the mass of a proton is 938,272,088. eV.
- Koshkin 5y agoToo many digits… TL;DR: .5 MeV and .9 GeV, respectively.
- pdonis 5y agoThat's what the GP wrote. Their electron value has a decimal point before the last three digits. The GP values are approximately 510 keV and 938 MeV.
- gus_massa 5y agoI prefer to use the same unit for all numbers because it makes the comparison easier. The bound of mass of the neutrino is really low. Using M and G hides it. I was going to write: > For comparison, the mass of an electron is approximately 500,000 eV and the mass of a proton is 900,000,000 eV. But all the numbers I wrote are measured experimentally. Both values have a lot of experimentally measured digits! I only removed the part that overlaps with the uncertainty, because the notation with parenthesis is somewhat confusing.
- fknorangesite 5y ago> I prefer to use the same unit for all numbers because it makes the comparison easier. Thank you; this is a style guideline I wish more writers would adopt.
- robotresearcher 5y agoAlternatively, you can use exponential notation to compare numbers of very different sizes while writing them similarly and using the same unit.
- fknorangesite 5y agoYeah. The point is keeping the units consistent.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _Microft 5y ago511 keV and 938 MeV would have been much clearer than a distinction via comma/point like in 510,998 -> . <- 950 eV and 938,272 -> , <- 088 eV.
- gus_massa 5y agoI agree that the coma/point distinction is confusing. Also, I'd like to cut all the numbers in the same digit, but the next digit of the proton is too dubious. What about this version: > [an upper bound of 0.9 eV] For comparison, the mass of an electron is approximately 510998.9 eV and the mass of a proton is 938272088.0 eV.
- cecilpl2 5y agoI would just round to the nearest eV and keep the commas. > the mass of an electron is approximately 510,999 eV and the mass of a proton is 938,272,088 eV. This reads best to me.
- panda-giddiness 5y agoI know we're just bikeshedding now, but neutrino: 0. 8 eV/c^2 electron: 510 000. 0 eV/c^2 proton: 940 000 000. 0 eV/c^2 (Note: neutrino mass is given as the upper limit.)
- _Microft 5y agoThe first value has one, the others two significant figures in this example. The decimal point is also giving a false sense of certainty when used like this. You can find more about significant figures at Wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Significant_figures https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Significant_figures
- panda-giddiness 5y agoYes, I know about significant figures. In fact, I considered adding a note about sig figs before deciding it was too minor of a nitpick to elaborate on. Elsewhere in this thread, people have already listed these masses to much greater precision than almost anyone needs (including me, a practicing physicist); obviously people can infer I'm rounding from context. Of course, if you were to present the masses this way without context, you should add a note about rounding.
- codeflo 5y agoIn contrast to some sibling comments, I think using the same unit is a great idea. It’s just that long numbers with commas are a bit hard to read. At least I think 511 keV and 938 000 keV would have been another clear way to present those numbers.
- throwhauser 5y agoWriting out the digits gives a more visceral impression of the difference in weight, from roughly one, to a six-digit number, to a nine-digit number.
- andrekandre 5y ago(total layperson here but) why is mass measured in electron volts? (also i would have expected an electron to be... 1 electron volt?)
- FranchuFranchu 5y agoMy understanding is that an electron volt is the energy an electron needs to move against an electrical gradient of 1V (imagine like rowing against the current). It is a unit of energy, so at first glance it doesn't really make much sense to use it a a mass unit. However, since e = mc2, you can calculate the mass that is equivalent to 1 eV (which, in kg, turns out to be about 10 to the power of -36). The electron volt is related to the electric charge of the electron, not to its mass. Similarly, a magnet weights more than its strength turned into mass.
- ghaff 5y agoBecause eV is not (directly) a mass measure. Though of course it can translate into a mass. To C&P Wikipedia it's "the measure of an amount of kinetic energy gained by a single electron accelerating from rest through an electric potential difference of one volt in vacuum."
- aroberge 5y agoelectron volts is a unit of energy. Using E = mc^2, one expresses masses in the equivalent energy quantity. It turns out that electron-volts is a convenient scale for the (energy equivalent) mass for elementary particles -- much better than trying to express the mass in kilograms.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoOr energy in Joules, which are around 10^19 bigger. So you'd have the inverse of that everywhere as an inconvenient factor. As it happens eV works nicely from meV up to TeV for particles in all the most useful contexts, from chemical bonds to particle experiments. You only start getting insanely huge factors when you stop being subatomic.
- wiz21c 5y ago
- Maursault 5y ago> the mass of a proton is 938,272,088. eV. No it isn't. At least, not all of them. The mass of a proton varies.
- dtgriscom 5y agoDepends on if it's been dieting recently.
- hbrav 5y agoI assume that is the mass of an unbound proton.
- Maursault 5y agoA proton in a hydrogen atom does not have the same mass as a proton in a Helium atom, nor do any protons in any particular element have the same mass as the protons in any of the other elements. Again, the mass of a proton varies.
- shirleyquirk 5y agoWhy does it vary? Changes in gluon/quark energy due to nucleon-nucleon interactions?
- Maursault 5y agoYes, in nucleons of different sizes, the amount of binding energy changes according to quantum mechanics. The result is the average mass per proton is different in different isotopes. The mass differences are explained by the energy differences. Anyway, idk about you, but this really bothers me.
- robotresearcher 5y agoapproximately <8 significant digit value>, <9 significant digit value>. Y'all use a lot of bits for an approximation. In how many digits is the uncertainty?
- gus_massa 5y agoProton: 938.27208816(29) MeV/c^2 Electron: 0.51099895000(15) MeV/c^2