2 ms·
> Essentially no crypto transactions can be reversed. Bitcoin transactions are hard to reverse (not strictly impossible, as shown by the recent example, and a
by littlestymaar 5y ago
> Essentially no crypto transactions can be reversed.
Bitcoin transactions are hard to reverse (not strictly impossible, as shown by the recent example, and a few others of the same vein, but it requires to arrest the key owner and seize the key, which is obviously kind of hard) but practically all other cryptocurrencies are centralized enough to allow for transaction reversal (The ethereum hard fork after the DAO hack is the practical example of this). And I'm not even talking about weak chains for which an attacker can even reverse transaction against everybody else's will[1]…
[1]: https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2020/08/29/ethereum-classic-hit-by-third-51-attack-in-a-month/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2020/08/29/ethereum-classic...
- sophrocyne 5y agoI'll bite. > centralized enough to allow for transaction reversal You can argue that the developers held outsized influence over the consensus mechanism early in Ethereum's lifecycle. You can also debate their recommendation & push to hard fork to a new ledger that undid the hack. But to argue that it is anywhere close to 'centralized' today is disingenuous at best. It should be impossible for any one agent to change the record, but it is the nature of blockchains that consensus holds as "accepted fact". In the event a blockchain is ever relied upon for anything of social importance, the ability for consensus mechanisms to fork away from "systemic ruin" is a desirable trait. I'm one of the few that argue the DAO Hack was a proof of concept for an ultimately 'required' capability for any critically important blockchain systems.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> But to argue that it is anywhere close to 'centralized' today is disingenuous at best. Ethereum devs have absolute power on ethereum. Things like EIP 1559, or Ethereum 2 illustrate this point really clearly: miners have zero power, neither do full nodes. No matter what the algorithms (which can be patched anytime anyways) say, power is a social thing and in the case of Ethereum, the devs have literally complete power over it. The storage is decentralized, the computation is decentralized, but power clearly isn't (and with PoS, it will become more centralized even on an algorithm point of view).
- DennisP 5y agoEIP 1559 was immensely popular among everyone in the community besides miners. The same is true of proof-of-stake.
- littlestymaar 5y agoWith “the community” being the name for a bunch of online forums whose admins are… Ethereum devs. How surprising… The foundational decentralization feature of a cryptocurrency is the fact that the blockchain is edited by a distributed network of competing people: yes I'm talking about the miners. If the miners have no power in your system, then their is no practical decentralization because mining is the only thing actually decentralized in a blockchain!
- sophrocyne 5y agoI’m not arguing that both systems (PoW and PoS) don’t have their issues with some measure of aggregated power, but it’s just a false narrative to say that staking and mining aren’t equally decentralized. The migration to PoS isn’t some rug-pull on miners, they’ve known about it for years. If there was legitimate protest, they’d refuse to adopt new versions that incorporated the ETH kill switch. The reason they haven’t? They have no skin in the game - most are mercenaries for hire, operating through centralized pools, cashing out whatever they mine. PoS is a superior system - more flexibility for decentralized participation (only benefit to pooling is convenience), and dramatically better for the environment at scale. Everyone who holds the asset (I.e. the people who should have the most say in platform operations) have invested in PoS, and want it. It’s widely supported. Unwillingness to accept anything other than “bitcoin is the way” is just baseless faith in modern garb.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> Unwillingness to accept anything other than “bitcoin is the way” is just baseless faith in modern garb. I've never said “bitcoin is the way”. Let me be clear, bitcoin is a giant CO2-emmiting turd invented by a libertarian who wanted to bring the gold standard back. But, if you're doing PoS you're not in a permissionless blockchain anymore (since you need to buy staking power), that's it. (And, BTW, if you don't need the sybil-resistance that permissionlessness implies, then you are in the realm of traditional distributed systems and using a blockchain is just path dependency at this point …)