4 ms·
It's a meaningless "probability" on several counts. 1) It applies to everyone reading it, and it would apply to me if I were different and reading it. It tries
by jodrellblank 15y ago
It's a meaningless "probability" on several counts.
1) It applies to everyone reading it, and it would apply to me if I were different and reading it. It tries to convey a specialness which doesn't seem to exist. If a billion people win a penny each then winning a penny isn't miraculous, even if it is a 1 in 1,000,000,000 chance that you win any particular penny - but the 'particular' part has no significance.
2) I am reading it, so my existence probability is ~1.
3) I wasn't waiting in the wings somewhere with a dice roll choosing whether I would be born or not, I am what was born to and raised by my parents. Birth and youth happened before "I", not the other way around.
- xianshou 15y agoI appreciate point #2: "The probability that I exist, given that I exist, is 1." However, the question addressed by the OP is not "What is the probability that I would exist in this world?" but "What is the probability, across the space of all possible continuations of the world from the dawn of humanity, that the world would end up in a state that includes me?"
- hugh3 15y agoBut given that "me" includes all my experiences as well as my genetics, we have to throw the probability of all those into the equation as well. At the very least, if you're going to take these sorts of calculations seriously you're going to have to ask what the probability is not only that I exist, but that everyone I've ever met also exists.
- yohui 15y ago> "What is the probability, across the space of all possible continuations of the world from the dawn of humanity, that the world would end up in a state that includes me?" Not particularly more or less probable than most particular states that don't include me, I imagine?
- jodrellblank 15y agoI don't understand talking about possibility when discussing the past. Probability reflects our uncertainty about what outcomes will happen. Uncertainty is a property of our understanding, not of macro reality. When looking backwards, we know what happened and what didn't, I happened (probability: 1) and those other worlds didn't (probability: 0). Saying "they could have happened" seems to me a sentence with no real meaning. Even if you go with a many-worlds view, that only means that all things happened with a probability of 1.
- yohui 15y agoPeople seem to habitually miss point #3. See, for example, many hypotheticals that ask you to imagine yourself in another person's shoes. (Not sure what a succinct alternative would be, though.)
- JoshTriplett 15y agoI love your description of your existence probability as approximately 1. ;) Nice to keep the remote possibilities in mind.