4 ms·
This article is premised on one concept of the user (as a peer). It turns out, most people lack the knowledge, skill, or desire to be peers. They are far, far
by shadowgovt 5y ago
This article is premised on one concept of the user (as a peer).
It turns out, most people lack the knowledge, skill, or desire to be peers. They are far, far more comfortable as consumers.
Take the author's thought experiment for example: "You could buy a Raspberry Pi Zero today for less than 10€, connect it to the Internet, set up a chat server on it, give it a public address and the world would be able to connect to it and talk to one other." Ignoring for a second how hard it is to get an honest-to-God static IPv4 address... How many people actually want to do this? Set up their own chat software, buy their own RP0, maintain it? Play the game of cat-and-mouse with an entire Internet's worth of bad actors trying to break your server? "No thanks," say most actual users.
So the trend is towards consolidation under the flow of people offering doing the boring stuff in exchange for something, and most people end up on Facebook (or Twitter, or Reddit, or Tumblr, etc., etc.). Because having to adhere to FB's rules about breasts is a lot simpler than dealing with hackers pwning your open chat server.
How do we get past this seemingly-inherent difficulty in the infrastructure itself and the persistent threat of attackers?
- na85 5y ago>Play the game of cat-and-mouse with an entire Internet's worth of bad actors trying to break your server? "No thanks," says most actual users. In the context of today's tech stacks (possibly containerized daemons running on a userland and kernel written in C, designed in a time where the internet was not considered hostile) it's easy to see why the game is stacked against the owner of that RPi0, but maybe in a decade or so we'll see a great renaissance of operating systems design and we'll all be running devices designed from the ground up to operate in adversarial environments
- UI_at_80x24 5y agoI would like to agree and disagree with you after a fashion. > They are far, far more comfortable as consumers. Yes, 100%. >It turns out, most people lack the knowledge, skill, or desire to be peers. A decent percent of the population LOVES this kind of challenge. That's why I ran a C64 BBS in 1986'ish. That's why I setup my own IRC server that is still running today. That's why I was running Linux back in 1994. That's also why so many people work on cars as a hobby. The desire to control the "thing-in-your-hands" is powerful, and the more $EvilCorp tries to turn everything into a toaster the more people will rebel against it. You are correct that most people want stuff that "Just Works". Hell, the mental load needed to get people to do regular oil changes on their cars is too much; so we can't expect the hacker mentality from everybody. These walled gardens are dangerous, so we need to encourage resistance instead of dismissing it.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> These walled gardens are dangerous I think that's a separate topic from this article. But if they are, the problem remains: what's to be done about it when the incentives are so heavy towards consolidating behind service provision over becoming one's own service provider?
- rahoulb 5y agoEven if it were easy to set up that chat server, and millions of us started doing it - without systemic change (as another poster notes), all that would happen is we would have different gatekeepers (probably ISPs) because value has to be extracted from everything we do.
- gatonegro 5y ago>Play the game of cat-and-mouse with an entire Internet's worth of bad actors trying to break your server? "No thanks," say most actual users. I was listening to a podcast yesterday, and one of the hosts expressed this similar feeling, except he came from the opposite end of the spectrum—someone who has been deploying, maintaining, and working on Internet infrastructure for a while. Dealing with these headaches for an extended amount of time will probably nudge you to favour centralisation. He argued in favour of moving the entire tech stack to the cloud and paying a fee, instead of deploying and maintaining anything on-premises, in no small part because of the cat-and-mouse game you describe. Paraphrasing, "I'm just paying for a service, if something breaks in the cloud it's not my problem to fix."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]