4 ms·
I was a crypto skeptic, and for the most part still am, but I also own a bunch of NFTs, and I see the value in it. What I own are tokens that represent ownersh
by jedberg 5y ago
I was a crypto skeptic, and for the most part still am, but I also own a bunch of NFTs, and I see the value in it. What I own are tokens that represent ownership in a bunch of LLCs that own houses in the USA. Now you might say, "but shared ownership of houses has existed forever!" and you'd be right, but the NFTs have some advantages:
1. I can trade them on the blockchain any time I want to, I don't need permission for any entity to do so.
2. Anyone in the world can buy and sell these assets -- they don't have to US citizens or even hold any US currency.
3. Decisions about governance are made via the token holders having a vote.
4. Rent is paid out daily in crypto using smart contracts. Although this gets complicated because the rent comes in once a month as USD so it goes into the company bank account which then distributes it daily in equivalent crypto. So you can trade the crypto, or you can trade your crypto with the company for USD, but then you run into US banking regulations where you have to give up your identity and follow all the usual KYC rules and all the other requirements for foreign holders.
Overall it's been a positive experience so far, and I'm making good returns (about 9% annual return on my cash).
It's definitely made me slightly less skeptical of the promises of Web3 and crypto, but it also has shown me that a purely permissionless system probably won't work -- this only works because we own a stake in an LLC that follows US law and is subject to US courts.
- AlexandrB 5y agoThis sounds like owning voting shares in a traditional LLC but with extra steps. Especially (4) where an awkward USD->crypto->USD transaction has to happen instead of the LLC just paying a dividend. The novelty seems in 1 & 2 being open to everyone. But one could argue that this is just unwinding the last 150 years of financial regulation and will lead to the same kind of scams and instability that this regulation was meant to curb.
- jedberg 5y agoPart 4 is only necessary because there isn't good infrastructure for working directly in crypto. I can see a future where say a food vendor could take the crypto tokens directly so that you don't have to convert to USD, and a future where the rent is paid in tokens. And you're right there is a danger about unwinding financial regulation, some of which is there for good reason. Which is why I think it only works because the LLC is still subject to US law.
- MaknMoreGtnLess 5y ago> Part 4 is only necessary because there isn't good infrastructure for working directly in crypto > Overall it's been a positive experience so far, and I'm making good returns (about 9% annual return on my cash). Just to be sure - both of these that you said are concurrently true?
- jedberg 5y agoYes, I have actually taken money back out to test it, and it is running at a 9% annual return rate in USD (and I put in USD to get the tokens to start).
- MaknMoreGtnLess 5y agoI am planning to rebut all your 4 points one by one but first: i. Are you actually using NFTs at this very moment the way you write here without a parallel system of property title management that's independent of NFTs? ii. Please show me where I can access and view these NFTs then because I will (attempt) a transaction into this ownership today. If I am not allowed to do that right now, explain to me why not?
- jedberg 5y agoI see you all over this thread accusing Marc Andressen of engaging in massive fraud, so I don't feel like you are debating in good faith. That being said: > Are you actually using NFTs at this very moment the way you write here without a parallel system of property title management that's independent of NFTs? Of course not, I specifically said that they represent ownership in an LLC, which participates in the normal real estate market in the normal way. > Please show me where I can access and view these NFTs then because I will (attempt) a transaction into this ownership today. If I am not allowed to do that right now, explain to me why not? Start here: https://www.lofty.ai https://www.lofty.ai
- MaknMoreGtnLess 5y ago> I see you all over this thread accusing Marc Andressen of engaging in massive fraud, so I don't feel like you are debating in good faith. If: i. We know that consumer electronics depreciate rapidly over time eventually to become obsolete ii. I were you tell you that "Assets gain value over time so I will sell you this CD player from Walmart today for $10 that you will be able to sell for $100 in the future" and you said "No, it's untrue that a CD player is an asset likely to gain value over time, so you wont even get $10 leave alone $100 in the future", than you arn't debating in bad faith. What you are doing is using the system and logic and inferences. High school stuff > https://www.lofty.ai/ https://www.lofty.ai/ Do you have any stake in this venture (or exclusively a fee paying user)? Here are 3 red flags about https://www.lofty.ai/ https://www.lofty.ai/ right off their homepage: > Investing in real estate is now easier than buying stocks > Become a direct owner of A.I. vetted real estate in 5 minutes and sell anytime. > Invest in tokenized real estate for only $50 This company will make a lot of people loose money. I am glad to see you're making 9% in a market that's currently averaging ~15+% Net IRR. Using deep neural networks in real estate? Wasn't Zillow's iBuying massacre enough educational experience? You have been around a long time to form an quality opinion: you think this is a good solution to a hyperlocalized, human scale problem? No actual RE investor in the real world gives a hoot about $10 avocado toasts and Tesla charging stations as prominently shown on the website. It's all about cashflow, tenant rolls and contracts. Anyways, I wish you and the current users there, luck. We need even more ~speculation~ investors in RE in the U.S. > Of course not, I specifically said that they represent ownership in an LLC, which participates in the normal real estate market in the normal way. So instead of NFTs, you could have used a shared, versioned, auditable Excel spreadsheet/AirTable to get the exact same effect without losing any functionality? What additional gain does NFTs bring over this AirTable solution (and I am aware of the DropBox comment)? What am I missing?