4 ms·
I don't know that I agree with the thesis that it's dying, but I think the symptoms it describes are very real. Searching for "good restaurants in <city I'm vi
by fishtoaster 5y ago
I don't know that I agree with the thesis that it's dying, but I think the symptoms it describes are very real.
Searching for "good restaurants in <city I'm visiting>" is useless. Entire real companies exist to fill the top few slots on that search for any given city. My workaround is, as the article says, to search Reddit instead. Look for the subreddit dedicated to that city, then find their most recent thread on good places to eat - you find much better results.
That said, I strongly suspect this only works because it's not a widely-known strategy. As soon as a critical mass of people start going to reddit instead of google, the same enormous weight of effort people put into SEO will instead go to finding ways to subvert Reddit's authenticity. Sock puppet accounts, astroturfing, generating spammy subreddits, voting rings - there are plenty of strategies, and dedicated experts will have a huge incentive to invent more. Reddit will put up countermeasures, just like Google tries to prevent SEO spam. I don't have any reason to believe Reddit will be more successful in the long term than Google is.
So... enjoy it while it lasts. :)
- bigthymer 5y ago> I strongly suspect this only works because it's not a widely-known strategy I think this post in combination with HN users' comments indicates that this is a widely-known strategy. It's cool. I've been doing it too and didn't know that everyone else did it too. Reddit is already being secretly advertised on but I guess we'll see how things end up.
- fishtoaster 5y agoSure, but "widely known on hacker news" is a very different bar. :) Really, the question is, "is it a widely known enough strategy that there's big money to be made subverting it?" And as soon as the answer is "yes," the battle will be on between spammers trying to fill Reddit with low-quality info and Reddit trying to keep them out without hurting legit users.