4 ms·
I honestly don't think this is the problem, like at all. There are human websites made by humans, still. There's more crap, sure, but the good stuff is largely
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
I honestly don't think this is the problem, like at all. There are human websites made by humans, still. There's more crap, sure, but the good stuff is largely still out there.
The problem begins and ends with the conflict of interest that Google both sells ads and selects search results. If they didn't have a vested interest in people visiting sites with their ads on them, they could decimate the number of spam results.
- cosheaf 5y agoShow me a site made by people with manually instead of algorithmically curated links and content.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI'm not quite sure what you are asking, but this maybe one of these? https://simplifier.neocities.org/ https://simplifier.neocities.org/ https://cheapskatesguide.org/ https://cheapskatesguide.org/ https://indieseek.xyz/ https://indieseek.xyz/ https://www.gameboomers.com/ https://www.gameboomers.com/ https://sadgrl.online/ https://sadgrl.online/
- cosheaf 5y agoGreat, now compare this to all the content generated on content farms for selling ads and gaming search engine rankings.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, but that's pretty trivially identified. I've had great success doing that with my search engine. Here's a thousand domains that are low in farmed contents in no particular order: https://downloads.marginalia.nu/good-domains.txt https://downloads.marginalia.nu/good-domains.txt
- cosheaf 5y agoSo why do you suppose Google doesn't surface the domains and results you presented? For example, I searched for "game reviews" and gameboomers was nowhere to be found.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI have no insight in their search engine, but I do know it would hurt their ad revenue to surface results that have no ads. Lends itself to speculation. But it could just be some confluence of other factors, of course. They seem to aggressively favor recent content (I do the opposite).
- cosheaf 5y agoWhich is why I said it's an ouroboros eating its own tail. The scale it operates at and given that it's also an ad network guarantees that whatever results it finds will favor its own ad network. It doesn't even have to be intentional since all they're doing is optimizing some metrics and running ML algorithms. There is no single person that could be blamed for the deterioration of the results. There is no way around this conflict of interest and they will continue pushing the envelope to increase their own revenue at the expense of useful results for as long as possible. If a site is hosting ads from the Google ad network and is barely above being spam then Google will prioritize it over other results in order to maintain its quarterly revenue predictions.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThat's a reasonable analysis. I do think Google has grown about as it can legitimately grow, which means the only way it can maintain an appearance of growth is by cannibalizing itself. The increasingly aggressive use of search ads are probably an example of this.
- Firmwarrior 5y agoWhen are you going to have a VC fork over $10,000,000 and start your empire?? I use your crazy search engine all the time, and it's fucking great. Last time I checked, though, you're getting like $30 a month from Patreon and that's it, haha. You're too much of a well-adjusted normal human being, that's your problem. You need that touch of Zuckerwellian sociopathy to get to the next level
- mark_mcnally_je 5y agohttps://goodwebsites.org https://goodwebsites.org
- xanaxagoras 5y agoHello, I have never heard of cheapskatesguide.org before and I am loving it so far. Thanks for sharing, I will check out the rest as well.
- _cs2017_ 5y agoWhich websites are shown in the search results is not influenced by whether Google has ads on them. The only thing that influences Google search results is Google's desire to keep as many people using Search as often as possible, since nearly all of Google's money comes from showing those text ads at the top of the Search results. This is all public information, you can read it in the 10K etc. So if Search sucks, it's not because Google has the wrong incentives but because they can't solve the problems Search faces.
- ajmurmann 5y agoHard to proof this but anecdotally lots of energy that used to go into people's hobby or passion websites now is going into digital platforms like reddit, pinterest or Twitter, or if lucky substack or Medium. Some of those are walled gardens and Reddit as discussed here is where people now search. Much less out on the actual net
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWell, since I actually run a search engine looking for this sort of stuff, I think I'm able to demonstrate that a lot of what was out on the net is still there, just exceptionally hard to find on Google. Admittedly more in some areas than others.
- ajmurmann 5y agoHah, I didn't catch that I was responding to you. Definitely would defer to your experience. Love your search engine btw. It brings the fun back to the web!
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIf anything I think I'm only scraping the surface, since a lot of my methods involve ruthlessly discarding data that doesn't live up to a fairly blunt set of criteria. I think with something like a headless browser (and a lot more processing power), I could probably use laxer standards and find even more good stuff.