4 ms·
The problem with this is that it doesn't work as well with intermittent source of electric power. The pot has to be kept hot. Contrast this with production of
by pfdietz 5y ago
The problem with this is that it doesn't work as well with intermittent source of electric power. The pot has to be kept hot. Contrast this with production of hydrogen. A hydrogen electrolyser can ramp up and down very quickly and is not damaged by long periods in an off state. The hydrogen can then be cheaply stored for a very long time, even seasonally, allowing the direct iron production facility to be operated continuously.
- rocqua 5y agoI was thinking the same thing. Though I am surprised to hear that seasonal storage of hydrogen is doable. I imagined that the size of pressure vessels required, as well as the leakage losses of hydrogen in general, would make that infeasible.
- pfdietz 5y agoHydrogen can be stored underground just like natural gas. The cost is very low, particularly if there are salt domes available where large cavities can be solution mined. For example, the salt formation at Delta, Utah has room for 100 such cavities that could store enough hydrogen that (if burned in combined cycle power plants) could power the entire US grid for 30 hours. The estimated storage cost is as little as $1/kWh of storage capacity (power related costs are extra).
- flumpmaster 5y agoHere is a commercial example of underground hydrogen storage that has been in service since 2007. It is a salt cavern in Texas. It is part of extensive hydrogen infrastructure connecting many industrial users (600 miles of pipeline) https://investors.linde.com/archive/praxair/news/2007/praxair-commercializes-industrys-only-hydrogen-storage https://investors.linde.com/archive/praxair/news/2007/praxai...
- prpl 5y agoWould not have expected to see Delta, UT on HN. I spent a significant amount of time there as an undergrad.
- DennisP 5y agoSo maybe the intermittent sources of clean electric power aren't the best way to go for absolutely everything.
- pfdietz 5y agoThat depends on how cheap they are. Intermittency is a negative, but it's not an infinitely costly negative. Here, the question is how expensive the electrolysers would be -- and they are quickly falling in price now, due to China. https://www.rechargenews.com/energy-transition/will-us-and-european-green-hydrogen-markets-soon-be-flooded-by-cheap-chinese-electrolysers-/2-1-1165966 https://www.rechargenews.com/energy-transition/will-us-and-e...
- jillesvangurp 5y agoSo, all you need is a bunch of batteries or other storage plus some links to back up power supply from the grid (wind, hydro, geothermal, etc.). Hydrogen is basically just a really inefficient battery. Nice if you really need it for e.g. energy density reasons but basically sub-optimal for other things. The challenge with hydrogen hydrogen is energy losses in producing it are about 3-4x (so use 4 kwh of electricity to produce 1kwh of hydrogen). And then you lose more actually burning it. And storing and transporting it add to those losses. Using the electricity directly for heating the iron/steel is much more efficient and potentially a lot more cost effective since you effectively use at least 3-4x less MWH. That's a lot of cost savings. And those can finance a lot of batteries and other solutions.
- ncmncm 5y agoHydrogen has many other uses than for energy storage. And, when top-line energy production gets cheap enough, round-trip losses come to matter less than other things, such as raw usefulness. Hydrogen is directly useful in electrical synthethis of methane and ammonia, besides myriad current industrial uses, and, as LH2, is disruptive as an aviation fuel: LH2 aircraft will be impossible to compete with, wherever they are available.
- pfdietz 5y agoLH2 has very low density, so it cannot be used in an aircraft that looks like what we're currently using. I suspect synthetic hydrocarbons will be used instead. Hydrogen is likely essential in making those. Low density is also a big reason why using LH2 in the first stage of a rocket launch vehicle is a dumb idea.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt will need new airframes and new cryo infrastructure, which is why it has been slow to happen. Once it does, building out will take a long time. But the competitive benefits are big enough to move a lot of activity. In the meantime, we will need synthetic hydrocarbons, using captured carbon, for extant airframes. It will need to get (or be made, through carbon taxes) cheaper than the mined, refined, and transported stuff. Having a big hydrogen synthesis infrastructure in place feeding hydrocarbon synthesis will then ease the transition off of hydrocarbons, as equipment that can use hydrogen directly comes online. Stationary uses will come first, displacing natural gas electric generation.
- scythe 5y agoI think the bigger problem right now is that the pilot scale reactor didn't work. Cf: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1534664 https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1534664 >Bench scale experiments made use of an externally heated reactor while pilot scale experiments conducted under this grant used a reactor that was self-heating. >At the bench scale, oxygen was produced with minimal corrosion of the anode material. At the pilot scale experiments in the self-heated reactor were not able to demonstrate oxygen production at the anode, or the production of iron as measured by tracer dilution. Further work is necessary to elucidate the difference between bench and pilot scale results.
- virtue3 5y agoIt is not trivial to store hydrogen. It takes a very large and expensive tank to store it at any practical level. And it has a tendency to leak through most materials. https://planetforlife.com/h2/h2swiss.html#:~:text=Hydrogen%20is%20difficult%20to%20store%20because%20has%20very%20low%20volumetric%20energy%20density.&text=Hydrogen%20is%203.2%20times%20less,gasoline%20on%20a%20weight%20basis https://planetforlife.com/h2/h2swiss.html#:~:text=Hydrogen%2.... "B&E estimates that a liquid hydrogen tank designed for automobile use will loose about 5% of its capacity every day, which is to say that all of it will be gone in 20 days. Losses of this magnitude are acceptable for, say, a taxicab fleet, but unacceptable to most people." Also new to me that it's a greenhouse gas: "Hydrogen cannot be vented to the atmosphere because it is an explosion hazard and because it is a greenhouse gas. The vented hydrogen must be burned. A continuously running gas stove with one burner set to "medium" would do it."
- pfdietz 5y agoAs I noted elsewhere, in large quantities it would be stored underground as compressed gas. The world uses many millions of tons of hydrogen a year. There are already 1600 miles of hydrogen pipeline in the US. So, while materials must be chosen carefully, materials compatible with hydrogen obviously exist. Transportation is not the only, or even a particularly favorable, use case for hydrogen. Pointing to it to paint all hydrogen uses as inadvisable is not honest, especially in a thread where we're talking about reduction of iron ore, not cars. Hydrogen is a greenhouse gas in this sense: hydrogen consumes OH radicals in the atmosphere which would otherwise go to destroying methane. So, indirectly, hydrogen causes warming by reducing destruction of methane. The effect is not large, however. Carbon monoxide has a similar indirect effect.