5 ms·
On the other hand ... What's wrong, if your wealth distilled to the limits of abstraction dies with you? If you haven't shared it with anyone, why would anyone
by scotty79 5y ago
On the other hand ... What's wrong, if your wealth distilled to the limits of abstraction dies with you?
If you haven't shared it with anyone, why would anyone get it?
If you didn't trust anyone with the keys to it while you were alive, why should anyone have it?
- zwirbl 5y agoMost people don't trust their adult children with access to their wealth, and yet they leave it as an inheritance to them when they die. Often even accompanied by a will
- snek_case 5y agoPeople sometimes die pretty suddenly, with no planning for what should happen after.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 5y agoI mean, another way to look at this is that wealth, assuming it’s reasonably liquid, can be exchanged for other goods (that is, after all, the only real point of wealth in the first place). Surely you wouldn’t think it’s absurd to expect that if someone dies with some extra food, that other people ought to make use of that food, even if they hadn’t made a formal last will.
- brigandish 5y agoOn the other hand, if money is destroyed and not replaced that then makes everyone else's money more valuable as no one else's wealth (and hence overall wealth) has been affected.
- tshaddox 5y agoI doubt that’s true in any meaningful sense. You could say the same thing for food: if you make it more scarce at some point you will probably observe an increase in price of existing food. And yet you could have eaten the food instead of destroyed it.
- neilknowsbest 5y agoI believe the parent here is making a distinction between "capital" and "money"; "money" being a claim against real physical "capital". When a pile of "capital" is destroyed (i.e. a bushel of wheat spoils, or a factory burns to the ground, or the lyrics to Bohemian Rhapsody are somehow lost forever) then this is a loss to society in general and to the owner of that "capital" in particular. If a pile of "money" is destroyed (i.e. Pablo Escobar burns $2MM in currency, private key to crypto wallet is lost) there is no corresponding loss of real physical "capital". There is simply a reduction in aggregate outstanding claims against the unchanged real physical "capital". So the unaffected holders of the other claims see their purchasing power increase, i.e. they no longer have to outbid the person whose "money" was destroyed, they have now "cut out" the loser from claims against "capital".
- tshaddox 5y agoThis is why I added "assuming it’s reasonably liquid" to my initial comment. If one's wealth is reasonably liquid, then I don't think it makes much sense to make a distinction between whether it's "capital" or "money." For the vast majority of people, I think this is a reasonable assumption. If you could liquidate the deceased person's estate and exchange it for consumables or capital and donate those to a good cause, is that really worse for society than the nebulous idea of increasing the value of everyone's money by destroying the deceased person's money? I guess I'm having trouble seeing the distinction between "destroying existing capital is bad" and "destroying money that could have been exchanged for capital or used to create capital is good."
- nybble41 5y ago> If you could liquidate the deceased person's estate and exchange it for consumables or capital and donate those to a good cause, is that really worse for society than the nebulous idea of increasing the value of everyone's money by destroying the deceased person's money? That would depend on who gets to decide what counts as "a good cause". I can think of worse ways the purchasing power could be employed than distributing it widely among other users of the currency. Even assuming the best of intentions, you're still directing resources rather arbitrarily away from other goals in favor of the selected cause, which is not necessarily a net benefit to society. In general it makes sense to follow the wishes of the deceased, if they are known—it serves no good purpose to distinguish between gifts made just before death vs. ones made at the time of death via a will, and doing so penalizes those who die unexpectedly before making their bequests. Beyond that, I see no reason why relatives of the deceased should have an automatic claim in the absence of a will—but their claim is stronger at least than any the state might make, so given the choice I'd rather see the property go to the heirs than the state. Personally, though, in the absence of a will I would just consider the property abandoned and available for anyone to freely use and thus claim for themselves via homesteading. In some cases that process may have already begun—for example, if the owner of a house dies without leaving a will then anyone else who was already living there (presumably the deceased's family) would have priority to assume ownership once the deceased's claim was abandoned. Their prior investment in the home didn't matter as long as it had an owner, but with that owner gone it should count in their favor for the homesteading process.
- pjc50 5y agoIn this case, it wasn't his money! It was the Quadriga customer wallet! Besides, "how do I ensure my wife and/or children get my wealth when I die" is a question humans have been addressing for thousands of years. Only a bitcoiner could be so nihilist to not care.
- wbobeirne 5y ago> Only a bitcoiner could be so nihilist to not care. I feel like the people I know who are most enthusiastic about Bitcoin are the ones who care most about generational wealth and the long-term mindset. There are tons of ways to establish backups for family members (multi signature wallets, time locked wallets.)
- scotty79 5y ago> Besides, "how do I ensure my wife and/or children get my wealth when I die" ... ... but can't rip me off a second earlier.
- helen___keller 5y ago> If you didn't trust anyone with the keys to it while you were alive, why should anyone have it? Wills and inheritance have been a part of human society since the beginning of civilization, I think it’s more likely we will need to find a way to make new technology adapt to society and not the other way around
- slyrus 5y agoThen again maybe this addresses the inheritance tax issue. Instead of debating how much money goes to heirs vs the state, folks net worth could just "evaporate" on death, thereby slightly (presumably) reducing the supply of whatever currency was held at the time of death.
- carlob 5y agoYeah, but inheritance law has changed a lot over the centuries: before the French revolution only the first child (possibly son, I don't recall right now) could inherit, then the revolutionary government made a big deal of splitting properties equally among siblings in order to break up large estates. After WWII most Western countries had very punishing inheritance taxes, and that's been dialed back in the 70s. Some economists (Piketty and co) make a big deal of bringing back high inheritance taxes and using them to finance a universal basic capital to be disbursed at a young age. In a sense, due to the deflationary nature of most crypto, dying without telling anyone what the key to your wallet is, is equivalent to redistributing all your funds to everyone in a way that is proportional to the amount everybody already owns. So it's kinda regressive, which seems to align well with the current crypto political climate...
- maerF0x0 5y ago> If you haven't shared it with anyone, why would anyone get it? This is the wrong model, technically it causes micro deflation that would be similar to distributing it to everyone weighted by their current amount. The rich get richer-er (in an absolute sense, but not in a proportional sense). The effect is probably minuscule on a case by case basis, but if it were happening on nation scale it might make a difference.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> What's wrong, if your wealth distilled to the limits of abstraction dies with you? What do you mean, what's wrong? Everything is wrong. If I have children, I absolutely want them to inherit everything I own when I die. I want them to use it all to reach even further than I have and be more successful and richer than I was. This is how wealth is built across generations. I don't want my money to be forever lost in the unimaginably large cryptographic search space. I certainly don't want my money to go to anyone other than my children, especially the government.
- scotty79 5y agoWhy don't you give them your stuff now?
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoMany do but even then you have to drip feed it extremely slowly.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI don't have children yet.
- wbobeirne 5y agoTaxes.