6 ms·
It’s congress not government bureaucrats that are in charge of the really big ticket items. As such these companies setup manufacturing to be in an optimal set
by Retric 5y ago
It’s congress not government bureaucrats that are in charge of the really big ticket items.
As such these companies setup manufacturing to be in an optimal set of districts to ensure their success even if it’s inefficient that’s just more pork.
- fsloth 5y agoI'm not from USA, but my limited understanding is that the contractors (Boeing etc) work for Nasa, which in turn is guided by congress. And congress does not specify engineering or scientific goals, but how much government funds they want directed to their district. Hence it's broken from the start as a vehicle for engineering progress, but successful if the measure of success is to create jobs and subsidies.
- wolf550e 5y agoCongress mandates specific technical details to force contractor choice and factory location in right district. For example RAC 2 (Saturn V reboot) won the NASA engineering trade off but congress mandated RAC 1 (shuttle tank, engines and boosters but without orbiter) becomes "SLS", to give jobs to shuttle contractors in their districts. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNZx208bw0g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNZx208bw0g
- HPsquared 5y agoThat's the big difference, these contractors get given the contract with a big pile of restrictions on how they should build the thing, which usually aren't optimal in terms of cost or performance. Commercial companies like SpaceX on the other hand, who are spending their own money (i.e. no strings attached) have much more of a free hand on things like technology choice, architecture and procurement.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoSpaceX is spending plenty of taxpayer money. They have significant contracts from NASA.
- HPsquared 5y agoStarship is funded by profits from other contracts. After fulfilling the other contracts (for launch services on Falcon 9 etc.) that cash is theirs to spend without further strings.
- WrtCdEvrydy 5y agoRight, but the specs don't come from NASA before the thing is built. The thing is built and then shopped to NASA as a possible launch platform.
- ceejayoz 5y agoNASA absolutely got to set some specifications on the cargo and crew Dragons, and I'd expect there's at least some consideration to their potential requirements and quiet communication with NASA in Starship's design as well. There'll be quite a few specifics on the HLS award variant (which, hilariously, still manages to shoehorn an Orion capsule into the plan, at least for now). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS
- taylorfinley 5y agoOne wonders if that Orion capsule is designed to be interchangeable with some other payload with another function that the US might like to be able to continue to use.
- thebigman433 5y ago> hilariously, still manages to shoehorn an Orion capsule into the plan, at least for now Why is this hilarious? It makes perfect sense for the mission to me. The HLS probably isnt going to return to Earth, and even if it did have that capability, it seems extremely unlikely that we will have humans on a propulsively landed Starship by the end of the decade. Id be much more concerned if Orion wasnt part of the plan
- ceejayoz 5y ago
- croddin 5y agoSLS is like that, but Starliner is playing by that same rules as Crew Dragon as they are both commercial contracts rather that passed into law up by congress.
- Retric 5y agoStarliner is a multi year contract that can be canceled by congress. Which means they are still dependent on congressional good will.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoExactly. This is basically the modern replacement for earmark spending.
- Datenstrom 5y agoThe number of stories of contractor companies hiding innovation and automation to maintain a higher number of butts in seats is astounding. Never saw it at NASA but otherwise I know someone who automated his job away and that of over a 10 man team, made it a one button solution. When they told their boss the company immediately claimed IP, took the code, hid it away, and it was never seen again. Now my company is innovating in a space where we could similarly eliminate a lot of busy work and unless the product becomes industry standard these contractors wont touch it because they want to maintain the most useless workers on busy work they can. Missaligned incentives.