4 ms·
Mozilla systematically shut down all the reasons to advocate for them back around 2015-2016 when they assassinated their extensions. After they switched away fr
by roenxi 5y ago
Mozilla systematically shut down all the reasons to advocate for them back around 2015-2016 when they assassinated their extensions. After they switched away from that, almost everything Firefox can do Chrome can do better.
Firefox advocates are reduced to trying to defend using Firefox based on either trivialities or philosophical concerns. And the philosophical concerns seem weak to me since, like Chrome, Mozilla seems to ultimately draw funding from Google.
I'm not against the idea of people keeping up the effort to maintain an independent engine, but it really is hard to justify why given Google's permissive licencing. I am overcome with the irony that the most interesting challenger browser I'm aware of - Brave, run by ex-Mozilla people - is itself using the Blink engine. A pretty sad statement of the strength of the Gecko engine as a renderer.
They needed that groundswell support of lots of extension developers and they torpedoed it. I hope the price was worth it.
- barneygale 5y agoI'm a firefox user. What am I missing by not using Chrome?
- roenxi 5y agoI'll tell you what you're missing. Chatzilla. I'm still sour even years later. :'[ The serious answer is hopefully nothing.
- ikurei 5y agoToday? Nothing. I used to hop between browsers often, and for a few years Firefox felt significantly slower. Does that really matter that much? I don't think so. I often think that Firefox never really got bad, the difference between FF and Chrome was never massive. It's a bit unfair that FF lost so much market share for that small difference.
- shadowgovt 5y agoBecause, at the end of the day, the internet is one big social network, there are huge positive feedback loops that will drive minor differences into massive market share differences. If one browser is 2% faster than the other, and the cost to choose one or the other is near zero, then expect huge switching. ... And that's before we factor in the far more dominant network effects, like "What comes pre-installed" and "which integrates with my accounts and syncs my aggregated data and preferences history onto a new machine transparently."
- philliphaydon 5y agoThe crazy memory usage! I switched from Firefox to chrome due to FF taking so much memory. Then I switched back to FF due to chrome chewing so much memory. It’s still true today. I installed a chrome on my laptop in December. Opened it and left it on the landing page. After a Day it was chewing 3gb of memory…
- chmod775 5y agoWhy does that matter? Both browsers will reduce their memory usage if there's actual pressure to do so. If nobody else is using that memory, they might as well.
- saagarjha 5y agoAnecdotally they will not.
- shadowgovt 5y agoChrome is more of an operating system in a virtual machine in which a web browser is running.
- rasz 5y agowebSQL /1/ for one thing, killed off in the cradle because of 'developer aesthetics' https://hacks.mozilla.org/2010/06/beyond-html5-database-apis-and-the-road-to-indexeddb/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2010/06/beyond-html5-database-apis... Ask anyone working with databases today about aesthetics of using indexeddb without wrappers hiding the shittines of mozilla brain child. 1/ yes its depreciated on paper, but it still works
- ikurei 5y ago> Mozilla systematically shut down all the reasons to advocate for them back around 2015-2016 when they assassinated their extensions I don't think most people advocating Firefox did it for the extensions. My non-technical family and friends don't care about that. Firefox used to be just better, obviously better, than what people were using before. Chrome changed that, but still Firefox was the one you could trust not to syphoon your data without your knowledge. It was about having the web not be mediated by a for-profit company that only wants you for your data. Having competition in the browser-engine space is important, but outside of the HN crowd I don't think most FF advocates did it for that reason. If you didn't suffer IE, it doesn't seem that important. FF lost because a) it stopped being perceived as better than the competition, b) Chrome took a lot of it's ground through attractive design and marketing, c) Chrome was perceived as better (and I'd argue it was in many respects, at least for a while), and d) Mozilla ended losing a lot of the trust of its previous advocates (with the pocket thing, the Mr Robot marketing stint...). > Mozilla seems to ultimately draw funding from Google. I never felt that bad about this point, but may be I was deluding myself. I trusted Mozilla to take Google money without compromising on making FF private and secure. > t the most interesting challenger browser I'm aware of - Brave, run by ex-Mozilla people - is itself using the Blink engine Here I agree. There can be lots of innovation in the browser space; may be not the engine, but I'm not sure we totally need it as long as the engine is OSS and there are other companies using it. Brave does some interesting stuff, but I still would love to see more innovation in how we experience the web. The UX/UI of a browser hasn't changed in a long time.
- roenxi 5y agoThese sort of "which-browser?" discussions come up regularly. In 2014 I would have been laying down 10-15 interesting extensions that gave Firefox capabilities that Chrome didn't have. Instead the points raised here are a) Perceptions b) Design & marketing c) Perception d) Trust Just saying, there used to be real technical ammo to bring to the table. Might have helped shore up the userbase if there were great reasons to use Firefox. Maybe users don't use software for its capabilities, but it isn't like Firefox is bringing much else to the table now.
- 5y ago
- JohnTHaller 5y agoThe vast majority of Firefox users never used an extension outside of an ad blocker. Chrome was eating their lunch without those deep extensions because they were slowing Firefox down, both in performance and in development.