3 ms·
I think it’s a purely scientific question with a simple answer. After conception, the organism is plainly alive. Like if we found it on Mars we would say we fou
by rayiner 5y ago
I think it’s a purely scientific question with a simple answer. After conception, the organism is plainly alive. Like if we found it on Mars we would say we found life on Mars. It’s also human according to its genetics—which is generally how we decide what species something happens to be.
I don’t know why you’d call that a “fringe belief.” Fully 38% of the public holds that view: https://www.wbur.org/npr/730183531/poll-majority-want-to-keep-abortion-legal-but-they-also-want-restrictions https://www.wbur.org/npr/730183531/poll-majority-want-to-kee....
I suspect when most people assert that “life doesn’t begin at conception” they’re not referring to the literal beginning of human life, but the metaphysical question of when “human life that justifies legal protection” begins. That I agree is complex.
- akvadrako 5y agoScience cannot provide definitions, like of what consititutes life.
- rayiner 5y agoSo when scientists talk about evidence of life on Mars, or the possibility of life on other planets, they don’t have a scientific definition for that?
- akvadrako 5y agoDefinitions are just assumptions and can differ for each paper. They come from convention or philosophy, not science itself.
- akerl_ 5y ago“Definitions are just assumptions” is pretty tautologically false. Science at its core aims to define things: hypotheses are proposed and proven/disproven in search of pinning down clearly defined rules and patterns. Is gravity just an assumption that differs for each of us?
- akvadrako 5y agoGravity as you mean it isn't a definition, it's a theory. If you named it vticarg instead and defined the word "gravity" as loud noises, that would be fine scientifically. Indeed you will find "gravity" defined different ways in different papers. Sometimes it's Newtonian, sometimes relativity, sometimes MOND.
- tptacek 5y agoYou pounced on their use of the word "life", but of course the question here is "human life", not "life" in general, and that's a term that does not simply mean live human cells, and does not have a straightforward scientific definition the way "life" does (at least, not when used in the sense it's used in the abortion debate).
- akvadrako 5y agoBut life doesn't have a straightforward definion either. Are viruses alive? What about robots? Or cities? Or earth? It's a philosophical question and not something that can be decided by experiment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]