4 ms·
It is clear that the space shuttle was a disaster for US space exploration. It is a miracle that outer solar system exploration was not gutted, and we got New H
by ncmncm 5y ago
It is clear that the space shuttle was a disaster for US space exploration. It is a miracle that outer solar system exploration was not gutted, and we got New Horizon, Cassini, Galileo, and the foolish excess of Mars rovers, and Hubble and solar, x-ray, UV, IR, and other observatories.
There is no way the space shuttle would have happened without stupid politics.
- Tuna-Fish 5y agoThe tragedy of it is that the stupid politics were an intended feature of the original program. NASA got really spooked when the Apollo program got castrated just when they were starting to do real science instead of just testing hardware and delivering flags, and so they strived to make the program after that impossible for congress to kill. Jokes on them, the contracts started then are still impossible to kill today, and none of them have produced anything of real value for 20 years now.
- SEJeff 5y agoNot fully true. Much of the initial NASA tech was transferred over to the Department of Defense and is used for ICBMs and various missiles. There is a lot of overlap with NASA and the DoD when it comes to these things. The difference is that the DoD basically has infinite budget when they really ask and NASA has a paltry percentage.
- ncmncm 5y agoExcept, it isn't used in ICBMs. Expensive parts of STS are not used in anything except maybe X37, which by all indications is useless, spending years parked in orbit just so it doesn't look totally disused.
- greedo 5y agoI think this is backwards. The majority of the launch technology used by NASA (the rockets themselves, not the capsules etc) were military. It wasn't until the Saturn system that bespoke rockets were being used, IIRC.
- SEJeff 5y agoThe technology, the wind tunnels, the materials science. Much of it overlaps with military applications and the DoD works with NASA. The original NASA was military only. Then an all civilian nasa was formed and the two quasi competed. There is a really good overview of this in Chuck Yaeger’s autobiography.
- p_l 5y agoStupid politics are also what gutted Space Shuttle, and why NASA went begging for money to Pentagon (which led to horrible design faults). Cassini would have spearheaded standardised long-range exploration bus, but despite tremendous effort Congress slashed funding for the program so all the stuff that was to support serial production got slashed along with the other mission. Similarly nuclear space propulsion and nuclear power outside of RTGs in US space program were killed unilaterally by Nixon, killing all heavier missions outside of moon orbit.
- voldacar 5y agoA lot of different trends in technological stagnation can be traced back to Nixon. The book Where is my Flying Car? goes into this in depth