4 ms·
Is there a legal basis for requiring Harvard, a private university, to change its admission criteria (however arbitrary or unfair they may be?) Private univers
by musicale 5y ago
Is there a legal basis for requiring Harvard, a private university, to change its admission criteria (however arbitrary or unfair they may be?) Private universities routinely make admissions decisions based on non-academic criteria including geographic diversity, likelihood of parental donations, ability to pay, athletic skill, and demographic desirability (e.g. maintaining similar numbers of men and women.) Needless to say, some of those criteria convey additional advantages upon the privileged and wealthy.
Or is it simply the power of the purse, given that Harvard depends heavily on grants (especially research grants) from the federal government?
(Edit: the answer appears to be both: Title VI of the Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination by private schools receiving federal funding, and Section 1981 prohibits discrimination in private contracts; discrimination may also affect the tax-exempt status of universities.)
(Another question is whether Title IX permits admission of men at a higher rate as a form of equity, or prohibits it as a form of discrimination.)
- scarmig 5y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runyon_v._McCrary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runyon_v._McCrary for a precedent for the federal government prohibiting private schools from discriminating based on race.