3 ms·
Much of this also applies to tablets, and the comments here apply largely equally: - Data is siloed into apps. If it’s stored locally at all its within app-spe
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Much of this also applies to tablets, and the comments here apply largely equally:
- Data is siloed into apps. If it’s stored locally at all its within app-specific databases. In many cases it’s principally stored on cloud.
- Applications cannot interoperate / share data. At best they share URLs or clipboard content.
- The filesystem is not univerally user-accessibly.
- Application process management means that any app can be closed at any time. Any unsaved state, and there’s frequently a lot, may disappear. Even within apps, content is unstable. E.g., if I am composing a longer comment or post and am researching it in other browser tabs, odds are high the composition itself will be wiped. This is the largest single issue I have.
- Linux userland tools are limited. For me this is key to productivity. Termux is very, very, very good for what it does. What it does is still limited, and not available on iOS.
- Simple basics such as keyboard-based navigation (see Mozilla Firefox/Android / Fennic/Android).
Keyboard implementation in applications themselves is at best inconsistent. This is functionality that’s as old as interactive computing (1960s and before) that is failing. In Pocket, (article archiver) I cannot use the backspace key when writing tags, there is simply no response. In PocetBook (an ebook reader), I cannot enter a space when composing a search, instead the document scrolls. There are other similar issues.
- Surveillance and monitoring are pervasive throughout the OS and applications ecosystem.
- At the OS and application level, all design intent is focused on consumption and surveillance rather than my own productivity and creation.
- Hardware support by OS vendors is limited to a few years for most owners. Google “commits” to three years, which is mostly aspirational as it may be a matter of months, if not no OS updates at all following purchase. Apple does somewhat better here.
- The touch-focused interface is imprecise and frustrating, lacking the multi-mode functionality and locational precision of a mouse-based interface. Or the blunt effectiveness of text.
In short: I can’t control my own data, I can’t rely on basic input functionality, tools are insanely crippled, decades-old UI/UX conventions are flouted, user state is at peril of being lost at any time, power-tool availability is limited, and surveillance is pervasive.
Tablets are a shit productivity environment. Full stop.
FWIW: I’m writing this on a tablet. I know its limitations well.
In another post I make the case against tablets noting that there is virtually nothing they do which isn't better performed by either a far-more-capable laptop (even a cheap and minimal one) or a dedicated device: a dedicated (and preferably dumb) phone, a still or video camera (now largely the same thing), an audio recorder. Yes, it's a backlash against "convergence", but the gains and wins are huge.