5 ms·
I’m gonna say something pedantic and perhaps obvious. You don’t manage people. If you do, you’re a bad manager. You manage problems and projects and enable pe
by Waterluvian 5y ago
I’m gonna say something pedantic and perhaps obvious.
You don’t manage people. If you do, you’re a bad manager. You manage problems and projects and enable people to do their jobs well. You facilitate conversations and make sure they have what info and tools they need.
People are not robots you control. You are not better than them. You aren’t above them. In fact you’re usually far easier to replace than them.
Maybe I have a chip on my shoulder but this is core to bad managers: they think their reports are their subjects to lord over.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- senko 5y ago> You don’t manage people [...] You manage problems and projects and enable people to do their jobs well. This is, like, the definition of managing people. Let's call a spade a spade. > People are not robots you control. Control is not management. > they think their reports are their subjects to lord over. Bossing someone around is not management.
- ThalesX 5y ago>> You don’t manage people [...] You manage problems and projects and enable people to do their jobs well. > This is, like, the definition of managing people. Let's call a spade a spade. That's not like. The definition of managing people. A project is some stakeholders (including the people you 'manage'), some wants, some resources (including the people you 'manage' as well as yourself) and some constraints. People are people. >> People are not robots you control. > Control is not management. What does this even mean? If control is not management, therefore people are not robots you (not) manage, so, are they robots you do manage? I think GP was sort of leaning towards the 'people are not robots' part of that. >> they think their reports are their subjects to lord over. > Bossing someone around is not management. It can be. If you're a shit manager. This 'is not management' thing feels very similar to 'is not Agile'.
- lmilcin 5y ago> You don’t manage people. If you do, you’re a bad manager. People are not spherical beings in vacuum. Of course, you have to manage people. My experience is that throwing projects at people and assuming that they are all interchangeable cogs that will be able to complete projects if they fit the project is just asking for problems. Now, managing people does not have to be tantamount to standing there and pointing with your finger what they have to be doing next. "If you do, you're a bad manager." But there are other more subtle ways of managing people and learning to be a manager means learning to be able to influence people to do what you want them to be doing as much as learning what they should be doing.
- NumberCruncher 5y ago> You manage problems and projects and enable people to do their jobs well. This is based on the assumption that people want and can do their jobs well, or at all. Lucky you, if this sounds strange to you.
- Koshkin 5y agoIsn’t there a standard process of dealing with employees who are unable or unwilling to do their job?
- kqr 5y agoMost people in an organisation have, very roughly, the same desire to do their jobs well. There are outliers in either direction. If most people in an organisation are not interested in doing their jobs well, then something about the organisation is incorrectly set up. Humans have intrinsic motivation driven by autonomy, mastery, and purpose. If the masses of people don't want to do their jobs well, the organisation has taken too much autonomy, mastery, and purpose away from their employees. If most people in the organisation are willing to do a good job, but some outliers misbehave, there are, as another commenter mentioned, standard ways to deal with that. (Mentorship, counceling, retraining, warning, firing.) But critically, the standard ways to deal with struggling individuals should not be applied if there's a large majority struggling, because then the problem is in the organisation, not the individual.
- NumberCruncher 5y agoThanks for the insightful comment.
- cammil 5y agoI was going to say basically this. Let me add a thought. You manage something that needs managing, that is to say, problems. If you see people as problems, then you are the problem.
- Kranar 5y agoIt's fine to feel that way, but it's not a particularly effective approach in my opinion and in fact quite the opposite of what I look for in a manager. A good manager manages people; they understand people's strengths, weaknesses, goals, how to motivate and reward people, how to resolve potential conflicts, how to delegate, and how to help people grow. These are all people things. People are not robots which is exactly why they need to be managed. After all you typically do not manage robots, the point of using robots is that they're autonomous. Problems are not things you really want to manage, maybe in the short run you can try to manage a problem, but ultimately the goal is to solve a problem as opposed to managing it. The goal of a manager is to assemble a team of people who can work together to solve problems. Your issue is conflating management with superiority, you seem to think that someone who coaches a basketball team feels superior to its players. That couldn't be further from the truth. While Michael Jordan's coach was in his time a competent basketball player, he would never claim to have ever been better than Michael Jordan, and yet both he and Michael Jordan had an excellent working relationship without either of them feeling superior to the other [1]. The issue you have about superiority has nothing to do with solving problems or managing people. You could be a lawyer working entirely independently from developers and feel you are superior to them (or vice-versa). A good manager can cross multiple projects and multiple problems, because a good manager understands people first and foremost and lets competent people work on solving problems, as opposed to trying to manage problems. [1] https://www.netflix.com/title/80203144 https://www.netflix.com/title/80203144
- Godel_unicode 5y ago> Your issue is conflating management with superiority... Your issue is not realizing that many managers feel this way. They think that being a manager puts them above the people they are managing, and that their job as a manager is to boss people around (thus the genesis of that term). Edit: I'll see your Phil Jackson and raise you Bobby Knight.
- MathCodeLove 5y agoAre you arriving at this conclusion from a place of jaded bias or from actual data? Some managers feel that way sure, but your statement implies that its essentially the norm to be expected which is not the case.
- willseth 5y agoYou're correct about bad managers, but not about the idea that you shouldn't manage people. You summed it up: > People are not robots Exactly, people are motivated in different ways, have different backgrounds, aptitudes and weaknesses, the list goes on. A good manager takes these aspects into account to help people and teams do their best work. There is no generic template.
- bell-cot 5y agoIf you think that your manager could improve...if only he'd read the Evil Overlord list* and really give that some thought, then your "manager" is actually an Evil Overlord (or wanna-be), and you might want to look for a new job. Working for a real manager. *http://www.worldconquer.org/evil_overlord.html http://www.worldconquer.org/evil_overlord.html