4 ms·
>I’m not sure where you’re getting the idea that a commonly agreed upon legal fiction has “rights”. He's not describing how things ought to be, just how it is
by gruez 5y ago
>I’m not sure where you’re getting the idea that a commonly agreed upon legal fiction has “rights”.
He's not describing how things ought to be, just how it is right now, given the current laws. If you really want to boil things down, the "rights" you have (guaranteed by the constitution or whatever) are a "legal fiction" as well. The ultimate arbiters of what you can and can't do are the Men With Guns working for the government. They can go away the next day if there's a coup.
- smoldesu 5y agoThis is a pretty bad argument, because it conveniently omits that antitrust regulation is also extremely open-ended. Sure, Apple has the right to profit however they see fit. The government also has the option to smack them down however they please; just a few months ago the DOJ and SEC demanded that Apple started unloading their liquid cash or risk a lawsuit. Why? They simply made too much money. That's all it was. I think the simple explanation is this: if Apple continues to make money with the insane software margins they have today, they're going to face regulatory action. The cat is out of the bag, developers are pissed off, and more than half of the states in the US have come forward in opposition to Apple's monopoly over iOS app distribution. Just short of incorporating in another country, there's very little Apple can do to maintain their status quo without some kind of regulatory action coming down the pipes.
- dumpsterdiver 5y ago> This is a pretty bad argument, because it conveniently omits that antitrust regulation is also extremely open-ended. What exactly are you disagreeing with in the parent post? Why would "omitting" your unrelated point from their argument be convenient?
- granzymes 5y ago> just a few months ago the DOJ and SEC demanded that Apple started unloading their liquid cash or risk a lawsuit What is this referring to?
- Mindwipe 5y agoIncorporating in another country wouldn't do them much good either to be honest, unless they also intend to stop selling in the US and Europe.