4 ms·
I just spent two weeks in Detroit. I don't plan to go back anytime soon. The first day I got there, chock full of excitement to see the city and get a feel for
by SwellJoe 15y ago
I just spent two weeks in Detroit. I don't plan to go back anytime soon.
The first day I got there, chock full of excitement to see the city and get a feel for the place (really, people were laughing at my extreme enthusiasm about going to visit Detroit), I biked downtown for the jazz festival and was nearly mugged, or worse, on the way back around midnight (a bunch of guys in a van kept trying to get me to stop and approach the van, to help them get gas...there were gas stations within three blocks in either direction, and the guys in the van were young and looked perfectly capable of walking a couple of blocks to get gas...and the van seemed to be running fine and the guys were giving off seriously nefarious vibes, whispering to each other, etc.). I've biked through the tenderloin in SF in the middle of the night, walked through Brooklyn and the Bronx at 1 AM, and spent time in numerous so-called sketchy places; I travel full-time, so I've been to some interesting places, and I don't travel like a tourist. I try to see the real side of the places I go. I've rarely felt threatened in the nearly two years I've been travelling. I felt threatened in Detroit, on more than one occasion.
Detroit has a reputation for being a scary place because it is a scary place. And, while I enjoyed some aspect of my visit, like finding a walk-up outdoor movie theater setup among old abandoned buildings, and seeing little farms in urban areas (though they seemed to be in a somewhat bedraggled state; they seemed more like a media ploy that has played out rather than an actual sustainable community effort in some of the cases I saw), and the music scene is good, it doesn't make up for the sadness of the place itself.
Also note that those $6000 houses (and even less) will have property tax of several thousand per year. Detroit is still valuing houses at the rates of 10+ years ago, and the tax rate has climbed drastically in the past several years to try to keep revenue up to the level required to keep schools running, roads in decent condition, and police on the streets. Despite all the increases, the city is still experiencing significant budgetary problems. I looked into buying a house there, as it's cheap enough to be damned near an impulse purchase, but the cost of buying, restoring, securing (because you're going to need bars and cameras if you have a decent house within the city of Detroit), and paying the taxes on it will make it much more costly. Still incredibly cheap, but nowhere near $6000. And, you'll be living in Detroit. Not worth it.
Oh, and starting a tech company there? Madness. Notice that only one of those companies is actually worth more than a few hundred thousand (and it's not a startup, anymore, and hasn't been in a couple of decades), or maybe a couple of million, at best. That's not a coincidence. Those would be also-rans in the valley. I've noticed the same thing about most "look at us, we can be a startup hub, too!" articles. They mention a half dozen websites no one has ever heard of, as proof positive that the city can compete with actual startup hubs for tech companies.
It's cool that Detroit is improving. I'm sure some people will make solid money on real estate in the coming years in Detroit. And, I'm sure with an investor making a number of investments in Detroit-based companies, they'll eventually churn out a few decent-sized businesses, and they may improve the city further. But, it's not where you go if you want to start a tech company and you want it to succeed.
- angkec 15y agoCouldn't agree more. I'm from Detroit area, and just got back from a month long tour around Seattle and Bay area. I must say metro detroit feels so outdated and dead compared to the above too. It's almost a worldly difference. Yes I'm moving my startup to either Seattle or Bay area in a few days from Detroit.
- rick888 15y agoIf you are interested in tech, Ann Arbor is really the place to be in Michigan. Lots of startups and also a great university. Some areas of Detroit are OK, but if you don't know your way around, it can get real bad real fast. I know at least three people that got robbed at gunpoint in the last couple of months.
- SwellJoe 15y agoI hit the road to see the world that isn't involved in technology. I was in Mountain View, CA, when I moved into the motorhome. I wanted to escape the tech echo chamber for a while. I mostly seek out interesting music and America's remaining wild places. So, I went from Detroit (which has a great music scene, all things considered), to Mammoth Cave National Park, to Nashville. My next stop is Austin. If there happens to be technology, or a conference that's useful to my business, on the way, I'll get involved...but, mostly I'm trying to achieve an appropriate work-life balance, that doesn't revolve around tech. Ann Arbor sounds nice, and I know Google has a sizable office there, but it's not high on my list of places to visit (no music scene to speak of, no wild places). If one had to start a tech company in Michigan, I reckon that would be the place to do it. But, why start a tech company in Michigan, at all?
- RandallBrown 15y agoAnn Arbor definitely has a music scene. I wasn't in to it, but I know it existed. I believe the blind pig is pretty famous http://www.blindpigmusic.com/ http://www.blindpigmusic.com/
- jonbischke 15y agoThanks for this commentary. I'm the author of the article and certainly didn't mean to gloss over some of the really big problems Detroit has. But I was impressed with the energy there (I also co-hosted a dinner for education innovators in the city during my time there and felt a similar energy). I do think we have two options with cities like Detroit. We can give up on them and move elsewhere and let them become ghost towns. Or we can fight to keep them alive, similar to what people did in New Orleans post-Katrina. I'm a believer that the latter is what we need to do. It's not going to be easy but I'm really proud of the folks there who are committed to sticking around and doing whatever they can to help make the city better.