5 ms·
I'm looking forward to the future we have envisioned for a long time, where you carry your main computer around with you and simply drop it into a standardized
by sneak 5y ago
I'm looking forward to the future we have envisioned for a long time, where you carry your main computer around with you and simply drop it into a standardized i/o dock when you sit at a desk and it runs the big high res displays and accepts keyboard/mouse input, and you use it like a phone the rest of the time. (Basically, a phone that is also a laptop replacement - I know there are dockable phones now that can run a monitor and kb/mouse, but they're not really "laptop replacement" level.)
I could even imagine such a system having two different CPUs (or, more likely, different cpu performance cores in a single package) that power up/down based on wired power availability, basically just automatically getting many times faster when connected to power and not having to conserve juice on battery. Storage and memory are already fairly low power these days, and tiny. Mobile (i.e. handheld) GPUs are now powerful/efficient enough to run high-res handheld displays with all day battery life, which while probably not 4k gaming level, are more than enough to run a multimonitor desktop setup when not gaming, especially if you make the quite safe assumption that they'll have wall power to crank up the GPU whenever asked to run external displays.
I'm really excited about mobile computing over the next ten years. The Nintendo Switch and M1 iPad Pro are little glimpses into this future. I look forward to replacing the dozen computers in my lab with a single handheld device that can simultaneously virtualize many of them and conveniently multiplex several big displays between them, and come with me in my pocket when I leave.
- gigatexal 5y agoIsn’t this the Samsung Dex experience?
- dainiusse 5y agoProbably yes, but we haven't had a decent product like that. Now if it can decently run a linux distro (with external display, etc) I might ditch my iPhone....
- izacus 5y agoWhat's not decent about Samsung DeX?
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt's also what Ubuntu Touch aimed to do. Not sure if that's a use case that UBports still tackles, though.
- diffeomorphism 5y agoWe already had that, e.g. maru OS, ubuntu touch, Linux on Dex, whatever windows called their version, ... . It pretty much flopped. So it is "the future" in the same way 3D TVs were: Much hype and then kinda neat, but not great.
- wolpoli 5y agoIn a perfect world, it would work great. A world where hotels and workplaces have available phone docking stations that allow the travelling business people to plug their phones in, and their phones boot up an OS where we could have access to the full power of our personal computers on the provided monitors/keyboard/mouse. The world doesn't exist. And it's not that much more expensive for the workplace to add the computer, and it's much more convenient to just carry our own ultraportable laptops so that we could work at coffee shops and on the planes. But perhaps there is an use case out for parents with multiple kids who don't want to use low-powered or hand-me-down computers...
- diffeomorphism 5y ago> have available phone docking stations For that you want something that is ubiquitous anyways and works with everything. For samsung that was HDMI and usb (kinda works, but too many cables) a few years ago and nowadays is just a single usb c cable. Works with laptops, tablets and phones. Counter question: Why aren't docking stations for laptops common in hotels/coffee shops/wherever? Or am just not staying in the "right" hotels? To me it just seems that the demand is pretty tiny.
- IncRnd 5y ago> Counter question: Why aren't docking stations for laptops common in hotels/coffee shops/wherever? Or am just not staying in the "right" hotels? To me it just seems that the demand is pretty tiny. Well, there is an attack called the "evil maid" attack. This attack can happen whenever your hardware is unattended for some period of time. A hotel where maids enter the room every day unattended is quite literally the scenario for this attack. Imagine the surface area for attack, where a dock gets modified, then an unsuspecting user plugs into the dock. Not only is the demand tiny, but the liability is incredibly high for hotels.
- reshie 5y agohave to also figure out cooling at that level as well. hell even my laptop can get pretty hot. its definitely is a good step in that direction though.
- lmm 5y agoMy experience with a Surface Book (which I use in at least 3 different ways - as a tablet, as a laptop, and connected to a monitor/keyboard/etc. on my desk via Surface Dock) makes me think that's coming eventually, but it'll take longer than you think: - External GPUs are still pretty bad - Tablets with cellular connectivity are if anything less well supported than before. I think this is mainly because carriers aren't really supporting the idea of one person/account having multiple "phones". Smartwatches have the same problem - I remember going to a Samsung store and they were showing off a smartwatch that had its own SIM card and cellular modem, but the staff couldn't tell me what kind of phone contract you had to have to make it work - Small devices still mean a noticeable compromise in power. I've tried using Samsung Dex as well and it's... ok, but appreciably worse than even a netbook, even if on paper the processor/memory/etc. ought to be catching up. Laptop as primary computer only really took off once you genuinely couldn't notice any performance disadvantage compared to a desktop, at least in my friend group; I think it'll be the same with tablet and (eventually) phone/watch/ring form factors
- izacus 5y ago> Smartwatches have the same problem - I remember going to a Samsung store and they were showing off a smartwatch that had its own SIM card and cellular modem, but the staff couldn't tell me what kind of phone contract you had to have to make it work I might be missing something about cultural differences but... why would you expect an electronics store to tell you what kind of plans your telco has? Here in Switzerland pretty much every telco offers an additional SIM for tablets and watches, but you need to talk to the mobile operator not the electronics store ^^
- usr1106 5y agoI guess the OP was from the US. Most US providers still seem to live in the mental world of selling SIM-locked phones, they are no smooth experience for customers bringing their own device. Prices for just a SIM without buying a phone seem to be pretty high. Here selling SIM-locked phones is not even legal. In most European countries it is legal, but still less common than in the US. So operators have to serve customers not buying a device from them on competitive terms.
- chaos_a 5y agoWindows phone used to have this and it was called Continuum. Although it couldn't actually run proper desktop apps, only a few office apps made for it. The promo page for it is still up despite windows phone being dead for a few years now. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/continuum https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/continuum
- shmde 5y agoI feel you should get a Steam Deck then. It has almost everything you described you wanted in a pocket computer. 1.) Run windows/linux distro on the go. 2.) Can play graphically demanding titles in 720P. 3.) Has a dock which supports ethernet, Mouse/Keebs, HDMI out. 4.) Can have upto 4TB internal SSD with tweaks.
- tluyben2 5y agoThen I still have to carry 2 devices though. I am not very interested at gaming at this moment.
- MrYellowP 5y agoExcept that you will not be able to own a "main computer". It will be rented. And it also will be nothing more than a slightly less stupid terminal connecting into a cloud which offers you to rent the software you want to use, because you can't actually install your own thanks to everything being locked down behind VMs preventing the execution of unsigned code. Want to execute your own code? Fine! Buy a license! That's what you're looking forward to.
- goodpoint 5y agoPinePhone does that.
- tluyben2 5y agoEven cheap commercial phones are far more powerful though. I have a pinephone because I want a linux native phone, but it's not really useable still as a phone; it works ok as a very low powered Linux system though.
- pinephoneguy 5y agoI’ve had this for a year and a half with a PinePhone. I just don’t use the docking ability that much because: 1) Forwarding X11 to a desktop is easier (and all the apps run on X anyway) 2) Since it’s just Linux all the apps can run on a desktop just like the phone, all my stuff is synced with git or rsync, and if there’s something I need outside the usual folders it’s just an scp away. There’s absolutely no reason to use one particular machine over the other other than form factor and computing resources. It just makes a lot of sense to have a decent desktop permanently plugged in that you can use without any hassle. Devices like that will kill laptops though, I know it did for me. Of course I don’t think this will happen with Android. Google is way too greedy and they’ll find a way to make it unusable.
- sneak 5y agoMy laptop has more than 20x the memory of the PinePhone's maximum, and can run 3x external 4K displays, so the PinePhone would not even remotely approximate laptop-replacement level for me. The hardware in mobile phones needs to improve substantially for the scenario I described to be practical; there's no hardware that supports it today, but the software in TFA is a step in the direction.
- NotPractical 5y agoThis use case would be possible if Google didn't explicitly disable USB-C video output: https://www.androidpolice.com/2019/11/03/pixel-4-has-usb-video-output-disabled-in-software/ https://www.androidpolice.com/2019/11/03/pixel-4-has-usb-vid... (As far as I'm aware, they still do this on Pixel 6.) I already use my laptop as a desktop when I'm at home by connecting it to a USB-C hub, which in turn connects it to my monitor, keyboard, mouse, etc. I think the smartphone as a "single device which can be used for everything" is a cool concept and definitely possible considering how powerful modern smartphones are. The limitation is software.
- smackeyacky 5y agoThis idea is cool, but I already have a seamless experience of moving to different devices through my day and having access to everything I need. It is stuff like O365, Github, OneDrive, AWS etc that enable that. No plugging in, no reconfiguring devices. Moving between windows 11, android and debian everything I want is right there. I can't see the advantage, yet, of trying to consoldate down to one device.
- zozbot234 5y agoYou wouldn't even need centralized services to do this properly. Just bring back the old "My Briefcase" UI for device syncing, now additionally backed by a git repository for history, "fork" and "merge" support.