4 ms·
I think that rather than celebrating or condemning this, we should prepare, both personally/emotionally, as well as a society, for what will happen when the ine
by sneak 5y ago
I think that rather than celebrating or condemning this, we should prepare, both personally/emotionally, as well as a society, for what will happen when the inevitable occurs: totally censorship-resistant payments that even governments cannot meaningfully stop (only hinder/make more inconvenient). This has already occurred, so we know unambiguously that it is coming. In the next ten years they will be available widely to everyone who wants them who has uncensored internet access.
The integration of Mobilecoin with Signal is a good example. The wallets are pseudonymous, the chain has privacy built in, and it uses Signal's existing end-to-end privacy to arrange for coordinating payments between parties, such that the service has no idea what anyone's balances are or who is paying whom. You can't stop payments to anyone on the system without stopping the whole system.
Regardless of how you feel about Signal, or Mobilecoin, or Signal's integration with Mobilecoin: this is a demo of the fact that end-user-accessible private payments is technically possible. It's only a matter of time now until that future is evenly distributed to everyone who wants to use it.
You can, of course, think that Signal should be banned from the App Store. Perhaps it will be over this. People needing that functionality will switch to or augment with a platform that allows sideloading of apps. You can, of course, think that use of such completely unstoppable payment infrastructure should be prohibited as it eliminates existing government/legal control over who can pay whom and why. They could outlaw such payments, just as they successfully outlawed cocaine and speeding, but that doesn't stop them.
Fact is, though, it is now technically possible, and the only effective counters are aggressive censorship of apps that implement it (which is in short order any e2e encrypted messenger), or general internet censorship that blocks certain protocols like these sorts of p2p payment systems.
It's only a matter of time before these aren't going to be easily shutdown centralized websites.
What does the world look like, then? Is that okay? Is that terribly bad? What are the potential upsides? What are the failure modes?
- btbuildem 5y agoOne thing that made it work in this case was the ease of use. You can't expect the average Church Karen to sideload apps into a hacked phone. In the Freedom Convoy case, the PR went viral and lots of average people donated small amounts.
- ShamelessC 5y agoLots of assumptions here. It's naïve to assume cryptocurrency won't be co-opted and controlled by nation-states and corporations.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]