3 ms·
In science, there are still such things are "good manners" and "common scientific practices", not all of which are directly incentivised. For example, every art
by skrebbel 15y ago
In science, there are still such things are "good manners" and "common scientific practices", not all of which are directly incentivised. For example, every article contains references to other articles that helped create it. Every article credits all authors, usually in a particular order (which differs culturally per discipline). They're all fairly common sense, and there are many more. Some are listed explicitly as rules for journal or conference submissions. Some, however, are considered too obvious for that.
These are rules everyone follows. People get frowned upon when they are not followed.
Unfortunately, when these rules came to be, there wasn't that much code around. You can't print out your physics experiment setup. Additionally, every additional piece of info, be it data, code, or whatever, would need to be printed and shipped. This cost too much, which encouraged a culture in which only the most important parts, findings and a brief story of how they were obtained, were to be included in publications.
But then the internet came. The whole world adapted, but science culture didn't. The internet allows large sets of information to be shipped along with papers. This does not just hold for computer science. Entire data sets of physics experiments could be included. Survey data, code, Matlab models, and so on.
All this data is collected using tax payers' money, done for the greater good of the world. It makes perfect sense to include it all with the publication, online. In fact, it is criminally wasteful to make different teams collect the same data, or do the same work, over and over again.
I think the only change necessary to make this happen is for a few influential publications and conferences to require that all data, code, etc is published online along with the paper. It can start in a niche subject area and expand from there.
What Jacques (or anyone else) is doing to fix this system is yelling on the internet about it, so that conference programme committees and journal reviewers may at some point be swayed to add this little rule.
A rule that makes sense, just like "your paper must contain an abstract" makes sense, just like "you must include references to all works you borrowed from or built upon" makes sense.
- Hyena 15y agoHe's not actually saying they lack incentive so much as that there are significant disincentives. The rest of sience contains an incentive, various types of professional censure, for the behavior you describe. CS does not and in fact contains significant ince tives for secrecy.