I’m not confused and I don’t really understand why you think I am. I believe the content that is indexed is the content you can see. Sites used to be penalised

I’m not confused and I don’t really understand why you think I am. I believe the content that is indexed is the content you can see. Sites used to be penalised, heavily, for returning different content to google. Hiding the paywall for google falls into that bucket. At a minimum the search results should display if they’re paywalled and provide tools to exclude that content from results.