2 ms·
The difference is that nobody is running around selling credit cards by saying they’re anonymous. Monero is much better than Bitcoin in that regard but it still
by acdha 5y ago
The difference is that nobody is running around selling credit cards by saying they’re anonymous. Monero is much better than Bitcoin in that regard but it still requires a leap of faith to trust that a complicated tech stack is working.
Even if it’s true that banks log serial numbers pervasively - most public sources say the opposite, except for things like money given to robbers - the many businesses which accept cash do not. Again, not perfect but the threat model is much easier for most people to reason about.
- lrvick 5y agoImagine one needs to make a life or death, but illegal, purchase like a life saving drug for someone unable to meet hospital prices. You would trust cash from your bank before Monero because some public sources you read promises banks never log serials? I do not know what public sources you have read but FWIIW my interactions with financial fraud investigators in private sector and multiple government agencies have convinced me cash transactions and those that make them can be logged in great detail for people of interest if nothing else. While complex I would recommend Monero or tumbled Bitcoin for people that require high privacy over anything else today. It also avoids the major risks of having to meet in person to transact as with cash.
- acdha 5y ago> can be logged in great detail for people of interest if nothing else. That’s the key part: this is very different than all activity being routinely logged. Most of us never need to worry about this and someone in a hypothetical situation like you describe is presumably not a person of interest until afterwards, where that public blockchain history is a risk for the rest of their life. Similarly: > It also avoids the major risks of having to meet in person to transact as with cash. This wouldn’t matter in your hypothetical scenario where physical goods need to be exchanged. Again, my point is that this comes down to the marketing push. Even if the system works as planned, the number of people who made other opsec mistakes is high enough that in practice cash is not less safe.