4 ms·
It seems this style of writing is quite divisive, but those who liked it may also enjoy The Manga Guide series: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30120927 ht
by userbinator 5y ago
It seems this style of writing is quite divisive, but those who liked it may also enjoy The Manga Guide series: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30120927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30120927
There doesn't seem to be a Manga Guide to TCP/IP yet.
Personally, it's divisive for me too --- if I'm looking for specific information, this gets in the way; if I'm looking for "edutainment", then it fits.
- Closi 5y agoI think this style of writing can work - but it works best if the story is something other than two people just talking about 'how do you think this thing works?'. Like if you can pick any story, why make it about two people in a study hall, studying and directly asking each other the question? It could be a story about some rogue hackers, international spies, or the characters could be ducks rather than humans, or you could tell it from the perspective of a sentient computer or application... So if you are going to make it into a fictional story, you might as well make it a fun fictional story (either by the premise or by a character!).
- reilly3000 5y agoI think that the process of discovery is engaging, and far more relatable than a man page. Maybe the prose went a little further than it needed to, or as you suggest not far enough. I’m just saying that the mechanism of storytelling exploits some attributes of our evolutionary biology that make learning a concept more relatable and memorable.
- Closi 5y agoI agree with the process of discovery - but would personally prefer that to be communicated in the first person (which I personally find clearer and more enjoyable to read). As in telling the true story which is probably “I wondered how ports work, then I did this, then I wrote this script, then it had an unexpected result”, which still reads as discovery to an audience (but is the authentic and true story). IMO Readers will find a true story interesting if told with authenticity and passion. For fiction, you generally need ‘an ununsual thing’ in the story that happens that breaks it away from normality. I think this treads the awkward space inbetween - it’s made up (so no authenticity) but that authenticity isn’t replaced by something ‘unusual’ that drives the story forward. > Maybe the prose went a little further than it needed to, or as you suggest not far enough. I think this is right - although I don’t think there is a happy medium between those points. I think you can go in either direction (further or less), but straddling the middle is the tough bit.
- dghughes 5y agoI wonder if it's like recipes where the author writes in an elaborate style to prevent theft of their material. "I discovered this pizza recipe when I was hitchhiking through Naples after the death of my father. I was trying to find myself...". Instead of just typing out the recipe.
- pests 5y agoA recipe no is not copyrightable unless it's accompanied by "substantial literary expression". Also to get more page length from Google and to avoid duplicate content issues.
- stevage 5y agoI really liked it. Especially the implied message that the reader could also figure this out by a similar process of investigation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- suction 5y ago
- Twisol 5y agoW...what? I own copies of the Databases and Microprocessors books, and haven't seen anything like "up-skirt shots of teenage schoolgirls". What are you referring to?