6 ms·
I’m glad you seem to be happy with your payout, but can we talk for a moment about how much you got? For an exploit like this, especially given how much effort
by saagarjha 5y ago
I’m glad you seem to be happy with your payout, but can we talk for a moment about how much you got? For an exploit like this, especially given how much effort was put into it and how much the market rate of a security engineer like this would be, plus given how much this could be worth on the exploit market, $2 million is literally pennies. This could’ve easily been a bug worth hundreds of millions of dollars. I guess Optimism is lucky that people like you are willing to do “the right thing” even if you’re not being compensated fairly for it, but exploits like these are going to keep happening (and we’ve seen a bunch in this space already) unless bounties go up to match their true value.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoMorals aside, which seems to be popular in sec communities, Do you not understand the immense amount of effort they would have needed to expend to hide, not to mention the ongoing stress involved afterward?
- saagarjha 5y agoSurely someone with the skills to find bugs like these would be an expert in cashing out on those bugs?
- revax 5y agoThose skills are unrelated.
- saurik 5y agoYeah... and as the person in question who found and exploited this particular bug ;P, I can definitely state that I would not feel comfortable betting the rest of my life on my ability to safely launder a giant pile of crypto back through to fiat (and then, further, keep that secret for the rest of my life, which shouldn't be downplayed). I am much happier being able to get a bunch of clean money and then be able to give talks on the subject at conferences and get a lot of "street cred" in the tech community for my effort than spending the rest of my life wondering if there's someone from a real-world mob out there trying to hunt me down to recover the $100M I "owe them".
- jacquesm 5y agoThe whole assumption that your ethics have a pricetag attached is faulty, it's not as if the choices were 'commit crime / get bounty'.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoEveryone’s ethics have a price tag. It’s better not to pretend otherwise, since it clarifies a lot of human behavior.
- jacquesm 5y agoI strongly disagree with that. You really can't claim to speak for everybody.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoIf you don’t play ball in certain parts of the world, you end up in a river. The price tag is just different. Yours would likely be family or close relatives. I think you’d take money to do something untoward if that was the alternative. Almost everybody would. And there’s nothing wrong with admitting that.
- jacquesm 5y agoMy 'goalposts moved' detector just twitched.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoIf you say so. It’s the same thing, even if it’s more comfortable to believe it’s not. It helps to frame it this way, because once you accept that you’d do that, you’re more likely to accept you would do something unethical for a billion dollars if it had no consequences to you. And from there, it’s a binary search to determine exactly what your price is. Would you be able to say you wouldn’t lie to your wife if it meant you’d walk away with a billion dollars? Certainly this is contrived, but all examples in this territory are contrived.
- 323 5y agoThis is $2 mil of clean money. > This could’ve easily been a bug worth hundreds of millions of dollars That doesn't mean that you could find someone to give you $100 mil, clean or unclean.
- rosndo 5y agoWe have atomic swaps to monero now, cleaning your stolen eth is easier than ever.
- aqme28 5y agoHow are you going to turn that into actual goods and services though? You'll still need to go through an exchange with KYC and AML and the IRS will still be asking questions.
- rosndo 5y agoIRS doesn’t care as long as you pay taxes on the money. KYC and AML? Just lie that you mined the monero on a now defunct pool. I have a plenty of coins that I genuinely acquired in such manner and haven’t had issues selling them. The bank only cares about hearing a vaguely consistent story, they aren’t cops. The KYC stuff will only become a problem if you get caught via some other means, because lying to the bank is a crime.
- jacquesm 5y agoA reminder not to take legal advice from HN.
- capableweb 5y ago> IRS doesn’t care as long as you pay taxes on the money. Lol, you never actually handled the sums the submission is about right? The IRS will definitely ask questions about where the money you spend come from, if you end up on their radar. And if the answer is not satisfactory, they will grill you on it.
- saurik 5y agoIf we choose to value everything we touch by way of "the next highest bidder might have paid $X for this" while fully ignoring their intentions (and so allowing black market sales to be in scope for the implied auction), I think you won't actually enjoy the society you end up with :(. Like, as a security researcher yourself, it might feel interesting to posit the exact addition of value we protect per incident, but I think the ramifications on how other work gets valued as well as what adverse side effects result from this mental model are scary. It is thereby really only "required" (for the world to function) that there is sufficient monetary motivation for people who don't want to spend the rest of their life feeling either the guilt or stress (even if merely due to the ramifications of people finding out) of having done something "wrong" (which I put in quotes as I feel the "code is law" argument that can result at this point isn't actually that useful in a discussion of morality) to bother to then go out of their way to help (as opposed to not searching hard in the first place, looking the other way instead of reporting, or merely hoarding the bug as a parlor trick). And so like, while I totally see how this bug could easily be worth at least tens of millions of dollars to someone, it isn't clear to me that finding and reporting this bug should imply that I would need to be paid (and "by who?" is a then a hard question to answer even if we think this, one which might bleed into "and how?" a bit as the first answer is probably awkwardly decentralized in scope) the tens (or even hundreds) of millions of dollars that that hypothetical black hat might have figured out how to extract (which I make a bit theoretical as profiting from crypto hacks is harder than people often assume, something I touch on in my article; I think you might have to go for extortion, and even that didn't work for the Wormhole hacker)... most people simply aren't of the moral constitution to be black hats (which is probably a good thing). (In this case, the main lingering ethics question related to this bounty that I come back to occasionally is that there are projects--such as Metis--that forked Optimism and now compete with it using Optimism's own code and vision... projects that (in the case of Metis) are actually of similar size to it (based on "total value locked", which is imprecise but probably the best measure here for potential impact: Defi Llama lists Optimism at $344M and Metis at $347M) which are still relying on Optimism to motivate the security efforts for their platform... it feels at least awkward to me that they should get a "free pass" here simply because their listed bounties were lower than Optimism's? Like, even if you don't think I should get money from them, maybe they should be helping compensate Optimism?)
- doopy1 5y agogtfo with that. it's a generous payout.
- berkes 5y agoWhen you sell your car, and someone is paying more than usual. Should you keep looking for someone who might pay ten times that amount? That person is there, maybe not today, maybe not within 10km. By wait a few years, or drive a few thousand KM or both. Does that make the first, already above-average offer 'pennies'? Off course not.
- ycombobreaker 5y agoThis post openly advocates being an accessory to fraud to maximize profit. The true value of exploits is NOT the cost of the damage they could do, because that externalizes various costs to the perpetrator: evade law enforcement for the rest of your life, lose access to friends and family, become a high-value target for traditional organized crime, etc. For many people that is a net negative, even for a 9-figure payout. And that is a good thing, I think.
- saagarjha 5y agoFull disclosure: https://twitter.com/_saagarjha/status/1493021803802890242 https://twitter.com/_saagarjha/status/1493021803802890242