3 ms·
You need a conflict resolution mechanic. There are games which just don't bother providing one of those at all, and I feel like they're not really games. I don'
by tialaramex 5y ago
You need a conflict resolution mechanic. There are games which just don't bother providing one of those at all, and I feel like they're not really games. I don't hate them but I rarely will choose to play one and I can't remember anything from such games I have played, it's just too flimsy.
I've had a good time in games with a fairly lightweight conflict resolution, like certain classes of action are going to involve drawing cards from a (conventional) card deck, but I most enjoy playing something where it's about an even split between tactical combat (which yes, a computer game could do) and full roleplaying. I enjoy 4th edition D&D, apparently enough people didn't that 5e undoes many of the changes I liked.
One of the big problems older games often have is their resolution mechanic traps the GM by allowing for conflicts to end in a way that destroys the story. There should be a chance that our bullshit "merchants" cover story doesn't work and we get arrested, or our weapons are confiscated, or something else interesting happens. But a chance that we're just dropped into a pit of acid and die instantly is rubbish. If we're trying to open the Space Tomb it's OK if a bad roll means all the sentries inside are alerted, or the Galactic Archaeology Police are on their way to investigate tomb robbers, but it's not OK if now the door can't be opened and so the entire adventure is impossible.