3 ms·
I don't see how she's casting "wide generalizations". She's simply pointing out that this kind of status for women in Ur was a new discovery; it was in no way f
by zozbot234 5y ago
I don't see how she's casting "wide generalizations". She's simply pointing out that this kind of status for women in Ur was a new discovery; it was in no way foreseeable from previous sources about Ur. And I don't know why you're calling her a "gender studies" professor; Textiles were not trivial "women's work", especially not back then; they involved serious developments in technology. This scholar has done what seems to be interesting and novel work about the iconography of this queen's attire, which lets us draw new inferences about how textiles in Ur worked.
- jterrys 5y agoI never claimed that textiles were trivial women's work. I call her a gender studies professor because most of the published work on her bio page are in reference to gender relations. https://as.nyu.edu/content/nyu-as/as/departments/anthropology/people/retired-and-emeritus-faculty/rita-wright.html https://as.nyu.edu/content/nyu-as/as/departments/anthropolog... In my opinion, there's a particular bias here that is mostly based off of inferences. The wording of the article attempts to showcase a perspective that I feel should be met with some skepticism.
- zozbot234 5y agoI imagine it would be hard to study gender-specific crafts in the ancient world without also touching on gender relations. Why is it that so many people seem to think "crafts" are irrelevant or unworthy of academic study? Are we still that bound to silly notions about what should carry 'prestige'? This isn't even about gender since there are male-associated crafts too.
- jterrys 5y ago> Why is it that so many people seem to think "crafts" are irrelevant or unworthy of academic study? Are we still that bound to silly notions about what should carry 'prestige'? Are you mulling about some general state of affairs, or are you making a targeted inference about me? I don't understand. I never claimed that textiles or crafts were irrelevant or unworthy of academic study.
- kergonath 5y agoThat came a bit out of the blue in the article as well. On one hand it makes sense of that activities that were not written about and did not leave much artefacts behind (say, like textile and cooking) are less known that things (like warfare) about which epics were written and that left a lot of traces as weapons, skeletons, etc. On the other hand, we do actually know a thing or two about textile making in antiquity (see here for example, with loads of references: https://acoup.blog/2021/03/05/collections-clothing-how-did-they-make-it-part-i-high-fiber https://acoup.blog/2021/03/05/collections-clothing-how-did-t... ). It is not absurd to assume that historians (with their own perspective and interests) were not necessarily that interested in what they could see as trivialities such as cooking and textile production, because of their frame of reference. But asserting that we know nothing about “women’s works” because of sexism is quite the leap.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoTextile craft even does make its way into epics and cultural imagery, at least in the Homeric tradition Penelope's weaving as a significant plot point in the Odyssey.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoYou can add Arachne to this list.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoYeah, there's a whole bunch of examples. The fates, too.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoAh, yes! > A metaphor for the lifespan of an individual, as generated by Clotho, measured out by Lachesis and terminated by Atropos.
- 5y ago
- FredPret 5y agoI think it’s the professor who cheapens her own work by seemingly counting the ways to work gender politics into everything. Textiles, Ur, and the social structure of ancient societies are legitimate and informative fields of study. It deserves an even-handed treatment. What if the author had an obsession with, say, democracy, or the colour red; and looked high and low for evidence of it in the world of textiles in ancient Ur. It would detract from her main work.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoHalf of the population is a different sex. It seems like understanding gender might be somewhat important in studying ancient societies.
- FredPret 5y ago…which is why I said she should be studying the social structure, not finding ways to bring as many points of gender politics into every facet. It reads like medieval Christian literature, where every last thing is meant to portray the glory of god in some obscure way.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoShe does study social structure. That's what being an anthropologist means. Have you read anything Wright's written? I couldn't find anything recent that could remotely be described as "finding ways to bring in as many points of gender politics". The books she edited in the 90s about studying gender in archaeology focus on the subject out of necessity. If all you're going on is TFA, you might have missed the context that it's a pop history interview by a writer at Atlas Obscura who focuses on historical women. It's not the entirety of Wright's area of study.