3 ms·
If somebody under questioning, in a situation where people often request and have rights to lawyers, mentions a lawyer, what's the correct action? A) consider
by lozenge 5y ago
If somebody under questioning, in a situation where people often request and have rights to lawyers, mentions a lawyer, what's the correct action?
A) consider whether the person might be requesting a lawyer and help them exercise their constitutional right.
B) find some way, any way, to interpret their request as something else. Apparently the police thought he wanted a "lawyer dog"? Come off it.
Rights are only real if people can exercise them. This court decision decimated the right to a defense in every meaningful sense.
- JetAlone 5y agoWillful misinterpretation is precisely what any self-preserving legalistic person or system will do. In a situation like this, they'll choose B, because if they don't, they are choosing to lose in the face of an inconvenient truth.