3 ms·
I also didn't like some of the tone (I'm generally pro AI driving, electric vehicles, electric flight and decentralized app-based public transport which is part
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I also didn't like some of the tone (I'm generally pro AI driving, electric vehicles, electric flight and decentralized app-based public transport which is part of what Uber is purporting to deliver) but the core of the argument is:
> This is the first of a series of articles addressing the question of whether Uber’s pursuit of global
industry dominance would actually improve the efficiency of the urban car service industry and
improve overall economic welfare.
> For Uber (or any other radical industry restructuring) to be welfare enhancing, it would have to
clearly demonstrate:
> The ability to earn sustainable profits in competitive markets large enough to provide attractive
returns on its invested capital
> The ability to provide service at significantly lower cost, or the ability to produce much higher quality
service at similar costs
> That it has created new sources of sustainable competitive advantages through major product
redesigns and technology/process innovations that incumbent producers could not readily match,
> and
> Evidence that the newly-dominant company will have strong incentive to pass on a significant share
of those efficiency gains to consumers.
> Unlike most startups, Uber did not enter the industry in pursuit of a significant market share, but was
explicitly working to drive incumbents out of business and achieve global industry dominance. Uber’s
huge valuation was always predicated on the dramatic growth towards global dominance. Thus if
Uber’s valuation and industry dominance were to be welfare enhancing, Uber’s efficiency and
competitive advantages would need to be overwhelming, and there would need to be clear evidence
of Uber’s ability to generate large profits and consumer welfare benefits out of these advantage
All of the above was written, and obviously true, in 2016 but somehow business journalists don't seem equipped to ask these basic questions.
You getting cheap, subsidized taxis is like society investing in a perpetual-motion based electricity grid because the huckster pushing it charged your phone for free.
It is understandable that people might be angry with perpetual motion promoters, as they are dangerous criminals.
- telchior 5y agoI get your point but don't fully agree. For one -- I did not get cheap, subsidized taxis. I got a service that moved me from one place to another, yes. But it's incorrect to call that service "taxis", considering what the taxi industry actually offered. That's not fair to the entire taxi industry. I've lived in places that had incredible taxis. London and Tokyo, for instance. Uber didn't actually improve those places much. But in San Francisco? Manila? Any given tier 2 or tier 3 city? It's a different service. One that actually works. Now the taxi industry, at least in some places, is finally improving; adding some tech, making itself a serviceable option. And that's fine! If you want that to replace Uber -- great. I'm on board. But that would not be happening without Uber having acted as the hoard of rats chewing the blockage out of a sewer tunnel. Similarly, the article argues that Uber has done some massive harm to public transit. It gives no evidence, so I'm disinclined to believe it. Public transportation was either good or very, very bad in each of the places I've lived, with not much in between. That was before Uber, and the "very bad" category was not on track to improve. Cities can turn around now and decry Uber and blame it for their terrible buses, but those same cities were doing an awful job before. So largely my point is backward-looking. Whatever changes Uber has wrought are already in the past; and looking into the past, I say they were good. I can imagine an argument with more nuance than mine, but this article is pure outrage and vitriol. Nor do I think it's even reasonable to say that, if Uber goes into bankruptcy in the future based on its inability to turn creative accounting into profits, the entire transportation industry will somehow collapse. It will be fine, and still greatly improved over 2005.
- db48x 5y agoI think you’re both right. Uber will eventually crash and burn spectacularly, and probably take down similar services simply by proximity. Afterwards we will miss it because it is in fact better than the average taxi service.