7 ms·
The most lavish Mesopotamian tomb ever found
- richardfey 5y agoThe part that bothers me most is that servants must have been killed in order to be buried with the queen.
- KaoruAoiShiho 5y agoMaybe useful as an incentive to not assassinate you?
- brandall10 5y agoI had to look this up, it’s called a retainer sacrifice. The act was apparently largely phased out by the time this queen lived, so it’s a bit curious they found this. The idea behind it is the pharaohs were seen as deities, and as such needed their servants to come with them to the afterlife. The servants most likely were quite willing to do this due to that belief.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> pharaohs There weren't any of these in Mesopotamia.
- brandall10 5y agoFair point. It seems even when it comes to the ruling elite, there is some notion of afterlife that is at play.
- black_13 5y ago
- omnicognate 5y agoI feel dumb for not realising Meereen in Game of Thrones was based on the Ziggurat of Ur. The Tyrell Corporation building in Bladerunner too, I suppose.
- hodgesrm 5y ago> The Tyrell Corporation building in Bladerunner too, I suppose. Thank you for pointing out the connection! What an excellent use of symbolism in a film rich with it. (And D'Oh. Why didn't I think of that?)
- HNSucksAss 5y agoWe spent so much time studying Mesopotamia in elementary school... but essentially NEVER heard of it after that. So strange.
- Tagbert 5y agoIt did come up in the news when Saddam Hussein was deposed and then lots of people were raiding museums and ancient dig sites for artifacts to sell on the black market. Otherwise, it really depends on if you read anything about history, language, writing, etc.
- FlyNestor 5y agoThe picture of the Great Ziggurat of Ur is pleasing.
- _448 5y agoIt is not surprising. Women use to be heads of clans even before the "modern civilisations". There are lots of indicators of this in Asia and America(mostly in South America).
- jterrys 5y agoI really hate to be the person to raise this controversial opinion, which will probably annoy most readers (and moderators alike)... But this article really feels like its trying to squeeze feminist women empowering blood from stones. And I really don't necessarily see it. Here's some examples of the language used in the article that I find particularly misleading or unnecessarily loaded. --- "British archeologist Leonard Woolley uncovered the most lavish Mesopotamian tomb ever discovered. ...But the resplendent grave goods are not the only reason the discovery rocked the world in the early 20th century: this tomb belonged to a woman." Is it particularly noteworthy or impressive that an ancient tomb belonged to a woman? Is it out of the realm of possibility that this isn't just the only tomb they've found that wasn't robbed in antiquity? --- "Though no contemporary documents mention Pu-abi, scholars believe she may have ruled in her own right since her seal mentions no husband." That's quite the logical leap --- "There were very large workshops where women were engaged in the production of woolen objects. And within that group, there were actually women who were managers." It would be nice to find more supporting citations of these kinds of statements, but this will be a problem explained later on --- "But if I hadn’t studied Ur’s ancient women, I would have thought that the entire country was ruled by men and that all of the things that occurred in civilization, the beginning of civilization, was about what men did. And now I know that’s just one part of how civilizations develop" The author's own statements don't demonstrate a neutral point of view on this subject --- "Archeologist and textile expert Rita Wright, professor emerita of anthropology at New York University, is the first to ever study Pu-abi’s garments based on the only surviving image of her. Her findings have just been published in the new book Art/ifacts and ArtWorks in the Ancient World. Atlas Obscura spoke to Wright about the role of women in ancient Ur, what we know of Queen Pu-abi’s life, and why textiles are so often overlooked in archeology." This person is basically a gender studies professor specializing in ancient Mesopotamian textiles based off of her previous publications. And she is literally the only person to have written any papers or books about this particular niche that I could find on researchgate. I am not an anthropologist or archeologist, but I cast heavy doubts about articles and publications like these where you essentially have one singular subject matter expert focused on a thin niche that more or less only they know about casting wide generalizations about their field of study.
- zozbot234 5y ago
- HPsquared 5y agoThe Taj Mahal was also built for a woman.
- usrusr 5y agoAnd the gender parts of the article made me think of the Taj Mahal a lot: that one is rarely seen as a demonstration of any power held by that woman, it's seen as a demonstration of the power held by the man she left behind. Dead people don't commission lavish tombs. Widowers do (or perhaps widows, in a culture with women in power)
- smogcutter 5y ago> Dead people don't commission lavish tombs. The pyramids.
- usrusr 5y agoCommissioned long before death afaik, due to some cultural oddity that made leaders care a surprising amount about long term storage of personal remains.
- rsynnott 5y agoWealthy Romans also did this a lot; typically under the guise of building a _family_ mausoleum, and in no way centered around the builder, goodness no. Actually, ‘mausoleum’ is an example in itself; the building that the word derives from was almost certainly built during the lifetime of the guy who was buried there.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe pyramids weren't commissioned by dead people.
- smogcutter 5y agoYes, that was the point. It was a reply to parent’s claim that tombs are commissioned by the survivors, not the deceased.
- reactspa 5y agoI think the ziggurat has been completely restored. The old pics from when it was first photographed have it look like a lumpy mess. I suspect that even the current bricks are new. https://images.app.goo.gl/T3HxJqqHgMYzTca88 https://images.app.goo.gl/T3HxJqqHgMYzTca88
- ishtanbul 5y agoYes, by order of Saddam Hussein
- probably_wrong 5y ago"The most lavish Mesopotamian tomb ever found", and yet not a single picture or illustration of said tomb. This disappoints me greatly. When I was 13 I wondered what did Tutankhamun's tomb looked like, and yet it took me over 20 years until I saw an actual illustration. Looks like reporting on ancient tombs hasn't gotten any better since. In case anyone else wonders what the tomb looked like, I found this layout: http://www.arth.upenn.edu/522/puabi/puabi.html http://www.arth.upenn.edu/522/puabi/puabi.html
- agumonkey 5y agoYou got me to find pics of Tutankhamun's tomb and indeed I never saw much either https://www.vintag.es/2015/11/the-discovery-of-tutankhamun-in-1920s.html https://www.vintag.es/2015/11/the-discovery-of-tutankhamun-i... some shots are surprising.. the mess, the simplicity yet the eternal feeling of it
- gerbilly 5y ago> the mess The mess is because it was raided in ancient times, then hastily cleaned up and re-sealed.
- pavlov 5y agoMaybe. Another theory is that Carter and Lord Carnarvon faked the ancient raid to work around an Egyptian law that assigned untouched grave finds entirely to the state, but previously raided tombs would be split with the finder. In the end they didn’t get to ship that half of the treasure to British Museum and the NYC Met as they’d planned, as the newly independent Egypt asserted its rights more quickly than they’d expected.
- agumonkey 5y agoJust like we saw recently with the Robert Capa article.. history is often fuzzy right :)
- kingcharles 5y ago
- Aunche 5y agoThe most lavish Mesopotamian tomb ever found was probably most likely belonged to a man and got found by a grave digger. Tutankhamun's tomb was entact because people had forgotten about him shortly after his reign.