8 ms·
Single Pair Ethernet (SPE) – a leap forward in technology (2020)
- mmastrac 5y agoThis would be useful for the gigabit runs in my house that aren't quite up to spec. Usually it's a single pair that was damaged by a finishing contractor.
- meibo 5y agoSame here, house was built around 1900 and they really never intended you to run anything more than power... Basically impossible to get anything else through without tearing up the flooring/wall, and the rooms are askew too. Damaged a CAT-8 a little while ago, trying to pull it into my office.
- collegeburner 5y agoWhy spend on cat8? You have that bandwidth on a home connection? Or a nas capable of serving it?
- din-9 5y agoGiven the effort required to put cabling in e.g. mine is underneath plaster, future proofing it as best you can could save aggravation in the kind of timeframe that people live in houses for.
- justsomehnguy 5y ago> future proofing The best future proofing thing you can do in a living house is lay down at least x2 cable per drop.
- goatsi 5y agoThe best future proofing is running a conduit, not just copper.
- meibo 5y agoIt wasn't that much more expensive and I knew that it was going to be such a pain that I was happy to do it once and future-proof. Probably won't max it out in my lifetime, but it's nice to have options.
- collegeburner 5y agoI remember 3 years ago I moved houses and had 1 jack with really bad performance. Looked in the attic and found that somebody had (for no reason) spliced the cable. With wire nuts. 1 per wire.
- reilly3000 5y agoThat is kind of amazing that it worked at all.
- justsomehnguy 5y ago10/100BaseT is quite robust one. I did an Y-splice for three computers, without switch/hub, it worked. I saw a damaged link with 50% loss on 3com 905 on the server end, RDP was unusable. Replaced with RTL8139 (other side was the same lost to time noname unmanaged switch) - less than 5% loss with ICMP ping. RDP worked fine.
- sephamorr 5y agoI just moved into a house where the contractor thought you could daisy chain ethernet like a standard phone line. The ports at the end of the chain did work amazingly, but unsurprisingly, the ones in the middle with tens of feet of unterminated stubs... Didn't.
- justsomehnguy 5y agoPowerLine adapters exists. Not the best solution, and usually quite pricey, but it works. If your power cabling is not from 1900 too. *grin*
- yosheli123 5y agoI certainly believe SPE is the future but not as an immediate replacement to ethernet for the following reasons: - BASE-T1 PHYs and connectors are going to be more expensive than cheapo BASE-T PHYs and RJ-45s for a while. - The entire industry is based around BASE-T, try finding off-the-shelf mobile imaging hardware (or other embedded sensors) that supports BASE-T1. - BASE-T technology is less fragile, ultimately a single pair is more susceptible to signal loss / reflections and needs more complex encoding/transmission schemes to overcome this. (For example, 100BASE-T uses 25MHz, two states, four pairs. 100BASE-T1 uses a 33.33MHz, three states on a single pair. This reduces the tolerable noise floor and requires the use of better cabling. 100Mbit ethernet is damn-near indestructible I've found. (There is another alternative here which I will get to in a moment). Despite these issues, SPE's benefits will win out for mobile applications that have Size and Weight requirements. GigaBit speeds (or even up to 10 gigabit) on a single pair is just too damn tempting and can translate directly into better products. Want an example? Imaging you're making a payload for a drone; you probably use slip rings and your electrical contacts are limited. Using SPE means you can cram more data down the same slip rings, resulting in higher resolution imaging compared to a competitor using standard ethernet. My understanding is that 10BASE-T1L is designed for long reach applications like factory automation, to connect between clusters of devices using 10BASE-T1S (all sitting on the same pair of wires). 100BASE-T1 and 1000BASE-T1 are for ideally for mobile applications. Anyway this is all theoretical, it so happens that I run a hardware startup called BotBlox where I design compact ethernet hardware. I've designed a compact 1000BASE-T to 1000BASE-T1 converter, partly as a working prototype to get used to this technology. I believe there needs to be affordable, compact bridging hardware BASE-T and BASE-T1, and I intend to develop it. My current tests with 1000BASE-T1 is that the range is not near 40m, I managed to get around 10m before it dies. I need to do more testing on this to see whether it's the cabling, and the firmware I made. I have a 10BASE-T to 10BASE-T1L board in manufacture because I'm ridiculously excited about the prospect of 1.6km copper transmission. We'll see how this goes. Anyway, there's a link below. The chip shortage has destroyed my ability to scale up on this board, hence the high price. I expect once chip shortages abate, achieving a $100 price point on this kind of board is achievable. https://www.botblox.io/products/tiny-single-pair-ethernet-converter https://www.botblox.io/products/tiny-single-pair-ethernet-co...
- 5y ago
- myself248 5y agoSo that's three separate single-pair standards that I'm aware of, and I can't get _anyone_ to tell me if they interoperate. Perhaps they're different names for the same thing? Perhaps the wheel just keeps being reinvented? One is the Single Pair Ethernet industrial partner network mentioned in this post: https://www.single-pair-ethernet.com/en https://www.single-pair-ethernet.com/en which seems to be standardized as 802.3cg and calls itself 10base-T1L. The second is the One-Pair EtherNet (OPEN) Alliance: http://www.opensig.org/ http://www.opensig.org/ which seems to be standardized as 802.3bw and calls itself 100base-T1 and 1000base-T1. I believe this is the one I see deployed in production cars today. The third is HDMI Ethernet, which rides pins 14 and 19 of the HDMI connector. It is absolutely impossible to find information on. Does it have a standard? Does it use a standard MAC? Where can I buy the PHY? What a stinking mess.
- bofh23 5y agoGood luck finding any consumer products that ever supported HDMI Ethernet Channel (HEC). In contrast, HEC capable HDMI cables with pins 14 and 19 in a twisted pair were widely available to the confusion of many. Audio Return Channel (ARC) uses the same pins as HEC. Enhanced ARC (eARC), available on some newer TVs and AV Receivers/preamps/soundbars, takes advantage of the twisted pair to support greater audio bandwidth and surround channels (ARC was limited to 5.1), so it’s a happy ending for folks who bought HEC compatible HDMI cables.
- addaon 5y ago100base-T1 and 1000base-T1 are indeed the old OPEN, and are indeed what's deployed in production cars. 100 Mb PHYs are available from multiple vendors, and are mature and quite pleasant to work with (built in TDM for detecting wiring issues, etc). 1000 Mb PHYs are rarer (I've only seen Broadcom in person), but it's clearly coming. The 100- and 1000- protocols are pretty different; both are really focused on allowing cheap crappy wiring, but this is hard enough for 1000- that things like FEC are added. The equivalent of PoE for -T1 is PoDL (power over data lines), which is much more civilized than PoE (no transformers); and since 1000- runs at a higher lowest frequency than 100-, it's significantly easier to get power over it with smaller inductors. I'm not too familiar with the current state of -T1L, but the little I've seen about it in the past was a focus on taking the advantages of -T1 (low wiring cost, simplicity, robustness, PoDL) and applying it to industrial applications, where MUCH longer cable runs than in automotive are desired. While I was following this was mostly done by adding in a 10base-T1L physical layer, giving up an order of magnitude of speed in exchange for an order of magnitude or two more run length. Don't know if there's any intent to have faster -T1Ls, haven't followed that far. 10base-T1L, 100base-T1, and 1000base-T1 are all pretty different physical layers, although they share some principles. I /think/ the Broadcom 1000base-T1 PHY can run in 100base-T1 mode, and maybe even auto-negotiate (yuck), but they're quite different under the hood.
- ggm 5y agoCould I use passive devices breaking out to get 4 connections on rj45 and so move switches back to my wiring cupboard but keep multiple devices in the remotes? I only wired one rj45 per (bed)room. Domestic, so <20m runs of cat5e/cat6. Don't need more than 100mbps per host.
- addaon 5y agoYes, the cabling will handle it, but you'll need a media converter (e.g. [1]) for each device, so probably not a win for most use cases. [1] https://phytools.com/products/100base-t1-media-converter https://phytools.com/products/100base-t1-media-converter
- ggm 5y agoNo win. Device needs power. I'd hoped for passive splitter
- InvaderFizz 5y agoThere is the UniFi NanoSwitch[0] if a dumb switch with passthrough power will work for your usecase. Works on anything 12-24v. 0: https://store.ui.com/collections/operator-airmax-and-ltu-accessories/products/nanoswitch https://store.ui.com/collections/operator-airmax-and-ltu-acc...
- addaon 5y agoYeah, PoE makes this sort of thing much easier. The Unifi Switch Flex Mini [1] is even cheaper, but requires "real" PoE (not passive 24V), and doesn't pass through PoE. The various in-wall access points [2] are PoE powered, PoE pass-through, flush mount to a wall plate, and have an integrated four-port switch -- depending on use case the WiFi is almost just a bonus. If you have ethernet cabling in your place, it's definitely worth putting PoE on it for the options it opens up. [1] https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-network-switching/products/usw-flex-mini https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-network-switching/pro... [2] https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-network-wireless/products/unifi-in-wall-hd https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-network-wireless/prod...
- More-nitors 5y agoif weight is the factor... what about optical fiber?
- addaon 5y agoMOST150 was a previous attempt at this, tunneling 100 Mbit ethernet and a separate realtime channel over a 150 Mbit incredibly-cheap plastic optical fiber. It's pretty well cost-optimized -- designed to use single quantum well LEDs instead of laser diodes, 1 mm POF with pretty lax coupling, etc. Hard to beat super-cheap twisted pair copper, though.
- exikyut 5y agoHmmm, this could be interesting for high-voltage/current isolation applications, eg generator or battery bank control/monitoring. Would be really cool if there were prefabricated Ethernet-to-<this> boards out there. A quick check of Amazon finds 100Mbps Ethernet to fiber adapters for around the $20-40 range, but that doesn't cover the cost of the (mainstream) fiber cable they use.
- sxates 5y agoThis also carries power over the wire, which optical can't do.
- Gibbon1 5y agoWhat think it interesting is you get 50W of power. You could run lights and small appliances off that. Since it's low voltage wouldn't require an electrician to install it either.
- waste_monk 5y agoPower over fibre does exist, but it's only used for niche applications (I think some MRI machines use it, for example) due to the low efficiency. I think there are also problems with heat dissipation.
- Animats 5y agoDo you get to send in both directions over the same pair simultaneously, like DSL, or do you take turns, like coax Ethernet?
- addaon 5y agoSimultaneously, like 1000base-T.
- Animats 5y agoThat uses 4 wires. I was curious to find out how it's done with two. Sites promoting Single Pair Ethernet are amazingly unhelpful. The relevant standard is IEEE Std 802.3ch™‐2020 [1] This is actually the automotive standard for 10Gb/s over a single pair, but the industrial version seems to be the same thing with different connectors. The relevant section is 149.1.3, "Operation of 2.5GBASE-T1, 5GBASE-T1, and 10GBASE-T1". It's a single twisted pair of wires, but with a grounded shielding braid. It's not an unshielded untwisted pair, like DSL, or unshielded twisted pairs, like CAT 5 and up. The shield is grounded through the connector. That keeps the noise level down to where 10Gb/s can work. The cables will be more expensive and will be harder to make up than CAT 5, etc. Cable length limits are rather short. It uses a modem, of course. The basic signal is 4-level pulse amplitude modulation. There's echo cancellation, so sending doesn't blind receiving. That's how it does full duplex over one pair. One end is master, the other is slave, and this is negotiated automatically at startup. The master end provides the bit clock, and the slave end synchronizes to it. That simplifies echo cancellation; the interference is the same on every bit. (OK, symbol.) At startup there's a link characterization process, where each end finds out exactly what voltage levels it is getting from the other end, and adjusts for that. That's called "training" for historical reasons. There's 340 bits of forward error correction, because crosstalk from other cables might be a problem. Although this is nominally a baseband system, actually all the information is in the 1GHz - 4 GHz part of the spectrum. The data is, as with most modems, XORed with a cyclic scramble pattern to eliminate the DC component. That leaves room for DC power over the same wires. One cute feature - if the two wires are reversed, that's supposed to be detected at startup and corrected. But the connector, which came after the PHY layer spec, isn't reversible. [1] https://standards.ieee.org/ieee/802.3ch/7058/ https://standards.ieee.org/ieee/802.3ch/7058/ Requires an IEEE account.
- wanderer2323 5y ago(2020)
- sslayer 5y agoIs this used by starlink? A recent video review was complaining about a proprietary Ethernet cable with a weird adapter and high cost.
- wyuenho 5y agoThat Starlink adaptor is just a regular RJ45 in waterproof housing. The complain about it has no merit as it's meant to be connecting to the dish outside the house.
- exikyut 5y agoNo, that's all firmly within the consumer class end of the spectrum. IIUC (this is speculative presumption, the worst kind :P) the Ethernet port may use a form of USB, or at least what looks like a USB-like connector, possibly to provide power to the module so it can do its <proprietary>-to-Ethernet thing. (I am of course boggled at how the proprietary thing is cheaper than just adding Ethernet full stop.) It would seem sufficiently low numbers of users want an Ethernet port that this strategy is actually cost effective. I'm a little surprised at this to be honest, all the CPE (consumer premises equipment) junk/ewaste I've ever seen is typically littered with 100/1000Mbps Ethernet ports (usually four), regardless of Wi-Fi capability. And this is not to mention the fact that StarLink is touted as a low-latency network, so wouldn't it only make sense to proactively maintain that status quo over the last few feet? I definitely would get just a tad uncomfortable if I were ever handed eg a Wi-Fi only fiber modem...
- octoberfranklin 5y ago> (I am of course boggled at how the proprietary thing is cheaper than just adding Ethernet full stop.) I think their hope was that if the cord were to be yanked with enough force, it would not damage the expensive dish module and force the customer to mail that whole thing back for repairs. If you yank hard enough on an RJ45 cable, it will probably damage the female jack. That jack is cheap and can be replaced, but not by customers in the field. The dongle doesn't appear to have any kind of retention clip, so it should just yank out without any damage to anything. And if the dongle gets damaged it's cheaper and less expensive to ship overnight than a whole new dish. This is just my theory.
- ksec 5y ago>Is Spe Replacing Existing Ethernet Infrastructure? >Most likely not. In the current state of development and standardization, SPE transmits 1 GBit/s only up to a distance of 40 meters. 8-wire Ethernet, however, up to 100 meters transmission length. In addition, a large number of interfaces and devices would have to be converted, which is not necessary. Ethernet via just one pair of wires is used where advantages arise through enormous space and weight savings. These are, for example, applications in the railway industry. Here, less weight means enormous cost saving potential. Interestingly as I was looking up at single pair ethernet, there was even a standard for 2.5Gbps and 5Gbps Ethernet to bring Single pair working within 15M. [1] https://blog.siemon.com/standards/ieee-p802-3ch-multi-gig-automotive-ethernet-phy https://blog.siemon.com/standards/ieee-p802-3ch-multi-gig-au...
- psudohadex 5y agoHow will this impact FTTx?
- dsr_ 5y agoIt won't, as all of these standards are shorter than the necessary pole-to-house link. If you have a situation which needs relatively high-speed short-range networking between subsystems and is space-constrained for the wiring -- inside a vehicle, mostly -- these will be helpful. Fiber is great at everything except installation and robustness, and if you know the distance you'll be going and/or can coil up extra, installation is solved with pre-terminated connectors.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rcarmo 5y agoSo coax is back, but it’s not coax. But 1000Base-2 sounds nice.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> Transitioning to SPE from standard Ethernet What's this "standard ethernet"? Would that be the "standard" version that used fat coax and multidrop? (which happens to be two-wire) I thought the essence of ethernet was the protocol, not the physical transmission media. You could set up an ethernet circuit using sound waves, microphones and speakers.
- NavinF 5y agoThere’s only one L2 Ethernet, but there are many many L1 Ethernets. 1000BASE‑T and 10GBASE-LR are by far the most popular L1 standards and that’s probably why you don’t hear about the other 1000 standards.
- walrus01 5y agoAll of this mess of absurd mutually incompatible standards for single pair on copper is never seen in the ISP world, if we want a single pair of anything we use 9/125 singlemode fiber.
- WimLeers 5y agoWhen/where can we buy this for use at home?
- netfortius 5y agoWhere is Panduit?!?
- toast0 5y ago10base-t1l would be very useful for me, if there were consumer priced products available. I've got a single extra pair running to a gate controller that can do 10baseT ethernet, which would be a perfect fit for this as a bridge. With the power over data line standard, it could be super easy. One side has a power input, a rj45 connector and a two pin screwdown (or whatever), the other side just the rj45 and the two pin. There's a product out there that's using an analog hybrid to run 10baseT over a single pair, but my run length seems to be just a bit too long for it to work.
- InvaderFizz 5y agoYou are likely going to be waiting years for this. In the meantime, a directional CPE pair[0] as a WiFi bridge would probably do the trick for you in almost any scenario. You can run 24v down the single pair for power, if needed. Then again, for a gate controller, I would probably prefer to see if it used 900/433mhz and do that instead directly from the house instead of doing a 5GHz bridge. You could also use the existing pair as a serial bridge, or even an antenna for the 433/900. 0: https://store.ui.com/collections/operator-airmax-devices/products/nanostation-loco5ac https://store.ui.com/collections/operator-airmax-devices/pro...
- myself248 5y agoYou could also run SDSL modems, which have been the traditional way to do this for years. They'll adapt to the line's properties and give you as much throughput as they can. I'm not sure if any commercial offerings have a way to superimpose power, but I presume there should be some sort of power available at the gate too, no?
- toast0 5y ago> presume there should be some sort of power available at the gate too, no? There is and there isn't. The gate controller does have power, but the manual says not to tap into it, and it's fed low voltage a/c from a transformer elsewhere. The SDSL modems are usually too big to fit inside the box with the controller too (and it's metal, which makes wifi not an option). And, of course, it's only nice to have, so limited desire to make things fit or drill holes for antennas.
- sndman 5y agoI'd be interested in connecting two computers over existing unused POTS wiring. Would this even work on the existing wiring? I believe it's simply 22 gauge wire. I can't seem to find any charts (BW vs length) for SPE.
- sndman 5y agoFound some nice charts here: https://singlepairethernet.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/SPE-Alliance-Bruno-Escher7.pdf https://singlepairethernet.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/SP...