5 ms·
The unacknowledged secret to a lot of these games are that the maps and the rulebooks were the final product; they weren't really meant to be played, and certai
by pessimizer 5y ago
The unacknowledged secret to a lot of these games are that the maps and the rulebooks were the final product; they weren't really meant to be played, and certainly many were never played before they were published. Plenty of SPI games were absolutely unplayable and hopelessly broken, but you could spend hours upon hours reading the rules, looking at the maps, and going to the library to read more about the battles.
If I had to guess, I'd say 98% of all copies of hex+counter wargames are never played, just pored over and dreamed about.
- jleyank 5y agoThey were played then, as the college kids had the time and the lack of distractions. In a few cases, they were played by 10-20 people blind/moderated. Some, yeah, were turkeys but they made games and also games-in-magazines which published a whole lot of stuff. Some, on the other hand, were excellent. Remember, no pc's, no laptop's, no social media and the constant inability of (geeky) college males to score. Gotta do something other than schoolwork.
- vidanay 5y agoHad some great times in college playing Risk. We would set up three or four boards in different rooms and each player was separated and couldn't see each other. We then had "scouts" who went between rooms to provide limited reports about the other armies. There was much beer and weed involved.
- Enginerrrd 5y agoThis sounds like a much improved version of risk.
- drewcoo 5y agoThere were computers, whether at home or at the university. But playing with clever humans is much more challenging and rewarding than playing against a computer. That hasn't changed.
- busyant 5y ago> but you could spend hours upon hours reading the rules My brothers and I bought Axis & Allies about 25 years ago. We spent a few hours trying to assimilate the rules. Then we got bored and did something less mentally taxing. We concluded that Axis and Allies was supposed to teach you the futility of war.
- vidanay 5y agoYou're thinking of Tic-Tac-Toe. Me and my friends played Axis and Allies for probably close to 500 hours in the 80's (middle & high school)
- roofone 5y agoTic-Tac-Toe? A strange game. A&A and Supremacy were our go-tos.
- vidanay 5y agoIt was an allusion to the movie War Games. Air Superiority was also one of our favorites.
- scarecrowbob 5y agoThat was a hard enough to catch reference that I felt the need to post that I "got" it. I played a lot of A&A in the early 90s, as well as DnD.
- eesmith 5y ago"A strange game" is also an allusion to War Games. WOPR: "A strange game. The only winning move is not to play. How about a nice game of chess?"
- vidanay 5y agoWell that's embarrassing.
- User23 5y agoMy brother certainly played these grognard games and made up his own too. It’s hard for people today to grasp how far people in the pre-screen days went to find entertainment.
- ekianjo 5y agoyou are wrong. in the 80s kids and young adults did not spend their days on twitter on instagram and some of them spent hours playing wargames. there was a vibrant market for it at the time with magazines and shops supporting the players.
- morelisp 5y agoGP is correct. CfNA was specifically a joke and never intended to be played. Some others like AWaW are monster games by today's standards and were actually played, but still an order of magnitude smaller. And lots of wargames were (and still are!) a broken mess when they prioritize fidelity (or the author's idea of fidelity) over the player dynamics.
- pessimizer 5y agoPlenty of people (mostly the same people, 40 years older) still find the time to play them. I still think 98% of copies go unplayed. The market for buying/selling them is still fine (especially with the internet now), they're enjoyable to read and collect. I've got a dozen myself.
- bjelkeman-again 5y agoI not saying you are entirely wrong, but we did spend months playing things like Fire in the East, 2 m2 map and 2500 pieces. I have most of that series waiting for me to retire. :) https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/8993/fire-east https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/8993/fire-east
- pessimizer 5y agoI also left out solitaire plays. People get a lot more solitaire plays in than they get plays in with other people.
- ben_w 5y agoHmm, that sounds like my teenage experience of Star Fleet Battles. I should’ve stuck with just the base set and looked for people to play it with, but I kept buying the expansion packs instead.
- rightbyte 5y agoI think that this applies to a lot of board games in general, today too. It feels like many were play-tested like two times or something by people that were bad at playing board-games, because some mechanics/races/strategies are so powerful or useless. For war games though, it was probably really hard to find someone to play against that wanted to put in the hours ...
- tialaramex 5y agoLots of roleplaying games are like this too. The Tingleverse RPG will doubtless have some players but you can't sell enough volume to justify that book based on those players, that book exists because lots of people will read it, maybe imagine some scenarios or characters and then move on never having tried to see if the game is actually fun to play because they got what they wanted.