4 ms·
The point is, if someone being accused of or investigated for a crime and they say ".*Lawyer.*", in the United States this should automatically trigger the poli
by metadat 5y ago
The point is, if someone being accused of or investigated for a crime and they say ".*Lawyer.*", in the United States this should automatically trigger the police to stop talking to the suspect until the attorney is present.
- ineedasername 5y ago>this should automatically trigger I agree, should. But ruling precedent by judges has said otherwise, that the request for a lawyer must be clear and unambiguous. It should not be a question, speculation about the need for a lawyer, "I think I need to..". Yes, this is unfortunate. Especially considering the way the US very broadly interprets rights under other amendments, yet so very narrowly in the case of the 6th amendment.
- avs733 5y agowhich is the (great great?) grand parents point ... laws not being reasonably applied.
- Talanes 5y agoI'd go a step further and make it explicitly opt-out. How confident is the average person on exactly what point they are entitled to a lawyer?
- kingcharles 5y agoIt essentially is in a couple of states now.
- wisty 5y agoSo we should discriminate against the people who don't know to say "lawyer"? Why not just give every suspect a lawyer immediately. And since any sane suspect will listen to their lawyer (who will advise them to plead the 5th), why not ban police from interviewing suspects altogether, and simply give a list of questions to their lawyer to discuss.
- vouwfietsman 5y agoExactly! we should! By giving everyone a lawyer immediately we focus on establishing truth. Only reason we don't is that its obviously too expensive and impractical. This is why we initially try without, and involve a lawyer when "it gets serious". So consider this: Why should the suspect be punished for this reality?