3 ms·
Interesting test, I recommend people take it, but for purposes of discussion, I have put the first 4 questions here, along with my thoughts >Question 1: Tortur
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
Interesting test, I recommend people take it, but for purposes of discussion, I have put the first 4 questions here, along with my thoughts
>Question 1: Torture, as a matter of principle, is always morally wrong.
False. People have a right to be free of torture, but this right can be invalidated based on their actions
>Question 2: The morality of an action is determined by whether, compared to the other available options, it maximizes the sum total of happiness of all the people affected by it.
False. This is utilitarian thinking. I hold that there are certain rights an individual has that can not be violated unless they first have taken action to void them, see Q1.
Question 3: It is always, and everywhere, wrong to cause another person's death - assuming they wish to stay alive - if this outcome is avoidable.
False. See question 1. The word avoidable does a lot of heaving lifting here and is ambiguous. For example, how much cost and risk there is avoidance.
Question 4: If you can save the lives of innocent people without reducing the sum total of human happiness, and without putting your own life at risk, you are morally obliged to do so.
False. Again, this is utilitarianism. Sum human happiness is not the only or driving moral imperative.
This set of values produces a 100% compatibility with the following trolly questions. What was the experience of others? I'm guessing 100% utilitarian would do the same
- csdvrx 5y agoT/F/F/F 100% consistent - I save no one and even in the last question refuse to give a pass torture, because I think it's wrong. In the proposed scenario, it will have dire consequences, but such are my beliefs.